Acts 1–3 · 33 journal steps · playing as the Dark Urge
You wake with no memory, a pounding head and a hunger you can't name. Your own story runs through all three acts, and keeps asking the same question: how much of that hunger is really you?
Act One
Waking up with nothing
Nautiloid and the crash site
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I've no memory of who I am. Do my early answers matter?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Not the ones on the nautiloid. Your opening thoughts are flavour; pick whatever suits you.
Hint 2
What does matter early on is your first night's sleep. Rest before you wander far from the wreck.
Hint 3
Your very first long rest plays a dream of your own. It only happens if you rest at the crash site, or a camp near it, before you leave the crash site area or head into the forest.
Missable The first-night dream (and its journal entry) is gone if your first long rest comes after you've left the crash site or entered the forest. It never plays on a later rest.
Why do I keep having violent thoughts?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
They come with the territory. Plenty of conversations give you a sudden, nasty impulse, and you can act on it or not.
Hint 2
Each different conversation where it happens counts once. Repeating the same one doesn't help.
Hint 3
After the third, the journal notices the pattern. Early chances include pulling Gale out of his portal, the first humanoid corpse you loot, and several people and animals around the Emerald Grove.
Missable The three impulses have to come before a particular night at camp later in Act 1 (the one with a visitor, below). After that night the journal stops counting them.
Hint 4
Searching your first humanoid corpse plays a short scene with an Intelligence check (DC 7). Being targeted by Heal, or eating a Noblestalk mushroom, brings back a memory, and after that those memory rolls are easier.
At Gale's portal I get a very different idea. Should I go with it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Pulling him out the ordinary way still works: a Strength check at DC 7, then another at DC 12.
Hint 2
The other option is a fantasy about the hand reaching out of the portal, and what you could do to it. You carry it out.
Outcomes
Pull him out
Gale is freed and can join you as normal.
Go with the impulse
You chop the hand off and keep it as Gale's Severed Hand. Gale is not freed. The hand counts as an offering for the Murder Tribunal in Act 3.
Missable Chopping the hand off means Gale isn't freed from the portal, and as far as the research shows you lose him as a companion.
The scripts show Gale isn't freed after the chop; whether he is dead, gone or recoverable later hasn't been confirmed in play.
Act One
A visitor at camp
Your camp, after you head west of the Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Someone turned up at camp asking to stay the night. What happens?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This night is part of your story, and it comes for everyone playing as you. Walking onto the forest road west of the Emerald Grove (by the goblin ambush) sets it up for your next long rest.
Hint 2
The visitor is Alfira, the tiefling bard from the grove. If she's dead, or you reach Act 2 without ever entering the grove, a dragonborn minstrel called Quil Grootslang comes instead. How you treated Alfira at the grove changes how she greets you.
Hint 3
Whatever you say to her, she doesn't survive the night. In your sleep, you kill her. You wake beside the body.
Missable The victim always dies. You can't save Alfira, or Quil, once this night plays; recruiting Alfira first doesn't help.
Hint 4
What you do next only decides who finds out: wash the blood off, hide the body, go back to sleep, or wait for the others. In the morning you can lie about it.
Missable If you put this night off, it's forced when you leave for the Rosymorn Monastery or travel from the Underdark on to Act 2.
Solution
Hiding the body is a Stealth check, DC 12. There are also an Intelligence DC 12 check to remember, Investigation DC 7 and Arcana DC 10 while you look around, and a passive Perception DC 10 while you wash. Next morning, with the others: blaming an animal is Deception DC 7 if you're still bloody, DC 15 if you washed; claiming she attacked you is DC 18; blaming Astarion needs his vampirism known and is DC 18, or DC 10 if you washed. Whether they suspect you comes up again later, for instance with your favourite companion in Act 2.
Outcomes
Invite her to join, let her stay, or send her off
No difference. She dies either way, and leaves your story for good. A blood sigil marks the spot.
Kill her yourself while awake, at any time
Counts the same as the night-time murder, though the dream visitor greets you a little differently afterwards.
You're dead when the night starts
Someone else does the killing for you. You miss a reward the following night (see the next question).
Who is the grinning little stranger in my dreams? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
He shows up the night after the bard's visit. Just rest again.
Missable This night is cancelled if Isobel at Last Light Inn is already dead or at Moonrise Towers, which only happens if you rush far into Act 2 first. It's forced on most Act 1 level changes.
Hint 2
He's Sceleritas Fel, a servant who knows far more about you than you do. He wants you back the way you were.
Hint 3
He brings a gift: The Deathstalker Mantle, a cloak that turns you Invisible for 2 turns when you kill an enemy (once per turn).
Missable You only get the cloak if you did the killing at camp yourself. If you were dead that night and he did it for you, he skips the gift.
Hint 4
Killing him is never a crime, and never sticks for long: he comes back at your next long rest, and keeps count.
If you killed the bard while awake, the journal step that fires reads as though he did the killing; which text you see in each case isn't confirmed in play.
Act Two
An order you didn't ask for
Shadow-Cursed Lands and Last Light Inn
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
My dream visitor wants someone dead. Do I have to do it? unverified
Hint 1
No. It's a real choice, and both roads go on.
Hint 2
On your first long rest in Act 2, Sceleritas Fel names the target: Isobel, the Selûnite cleric protecting Last Light Inn. He promises a reward.
Hint 3
Meet her in her room upstairs at the inn. You'll get the chance either to fight the impulse down, or to threaten her (she attacks).
Hint 4
Kill her and you're rewarded the next night. Spare her and you'll face a hard night of your own soon after (see the next question). Either way, he turns up again during the assault on Moonrise Towers if you haven't settled it.
Outcomes
Kill Isobel
You, or anyone in your party, can do it. Permanently killing the Nightsong before Isobel is taken to Moonrise counts too. Next night Sceleritas grants you the Slayer Form: a bonus action once per rest that turns you into a hulking killer with extra attacks, but no spells or talking. It's forced when you leave for Act 3.
Spare her
Resisting at the inn, Isobel reaching Moonrise, freeing the Nightsong or sending it to Moonrise, or telling Sceleritas no at the Moonrise assault all count. Your next Act 2 rest brings the night in the next question.
Someone else kills her
If Isobel is carried off and dies without you killing her, the journal notes it, but you get no reward.
Leave Act 2 with her alive
If you never settled it, the journal marks her as spared when you leave the act.
At the Moonrise assault
If Isobel is still at the inn and nothing is settled, Sceleritas appears and repeats the order. You can promise to go back and do it, defy him, or attack him.
What Isobel's death does to Last Light itself is covered by the Last Light quests; this page doesn't confirm those consequences.
A dream warns me something terrible will happen tonight. Can I stop it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Yes, but you have to act inside the dream, not after it.
Hint 2
Sceleritas Fel says that tonight you'll kill the companion you care about most. It only plays if that companion is in camp.
Hint 3
Don't go back to sleep and don't brush it off. Wake them up, and be honest about what's happening.
Missable Fail here and your favourite companion is dead for good, and the other origin companions in camp may leave hostile too.
Solution
Wake your companion with a Wisdom saving throw (DC 14), then tell them the truth. You spend the night tied up (any further Wisdom saves while bound, DC 18, just loop), and nobody dies. Lying to Sceleritas about who you love (Deception DC 21 or 18) only changes his lines, not the target.
Outcomes
Wake them and confess
Nobody dies. In Act 3 that companion gets their own lines at a big moment.
Go back to sleep, call it a dream, give in, or fail the save
They die and leave for good. Next morning the other origin companions in camp confront you. Unless a Deception check at DC 30 convinces them it was self-defence, they turn on you, fight, and leave for good. You still get the Slayer Form.
The target is your romance partner; failing that, whoever you're dating; failing that, whoever of Astarion, Karlach, Lae'zel, Shadowheart and Wyll approves of you most. Gale only counts once his orb problem is dealt with. Jaheira, Minsc, Halsin and Minthara never count.
Act Two
Strangers who know you
Moonrise Towers and the colony beneath it
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
People at Moonrise seem to know me. How do I find out more?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look around Moonrise Towers properly: the throne room, the guard rooms and the upper floor all have something for you.
Hint 2
In Ketheric's audience room, if he is executing goblin prisoners, speak up while it happens (for or against). He'll show he knows you.
Missable Ketheric's recognition only happens in the version of the scene where goblin prisoners are executed, not when Minthara is on trial. Keeping silent misses it too.
Hint 3
A cracked wall in a guard room hides a tentacle that tries to drag people in. Let it. The voice on the other side recognises you.
Missable Wriggle free or destroy the tentacle and you miss its scene.
Hint 4
Upstairs, in Balthazar's room, read the Clasped Book.
Solution
The tentacle offers a Dexterity check (DC 16, with advantage) and a Sleight of Hand check (DC 14) to escape. Fail them, skip them, or reach back in, and you're pulled through, which is what you want here.
Is there anything about me in the colony under Moonrise? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Yes, twice. Go to the barracks first, then the room where the tadpoles are put in.
Hint 2
In the barracks, a priestess of Myrkul (the Mistress of Souls) and her Skull Lashers recognise you before attacking.
Missable If the Mistress of Souls is already dead when you reach her, you get a short reflection but no journal entry.
Hint 3
In the tadpoling chamber, near Mizora's hidden chair, examine an old, cracked, dusty pod.
Solution
Looking over the pod involves a Charisma check (DC 10) and Investigation (DC 10).
Whether these Act 2 scenes can still be reached once you've left Act 2 isn't confirmed; assume not.
Act Three
Who you were
Your first Act 3 camp, and Rivington
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where are the answers about my past? unverified
Hint 1
Rest at your first camp in Act 3.
Hint 2
A dream at the farm camp lays it all out. If you never rest there, it catches up with you on the road towards Wyrm's Crossing instead, and leaves you dazed for a few seconds.
Hint 3
You're a child of Bhaal, the god of murder, and you once led his temple in Baldur's Gate, until Orin took your place.
Outcomes
You killed your favourite companion in Act 2
This is where the Slayer Form is granted (again).
The vision hit you on the road
A later night with Jaheira (and Minsc) can follow, where she offers to keep an eye on you. Send them away with Intimidation (DC 18) and they leave.
The exact spot of the roadside version near Wyrm's Crossing isn't confirmed.
More people from my past are in the city. Who should I talk to? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Two people who worked with you: one is very public, the other runs a shop.
Hint 2
At Gortash's coronation, he greets you as an old ally and tells you the two of you started all this.
Missable Gortash only says it while Orin is still alive.
Hint 3
At the Devil's Fee in the Lower City, Helsik admits she helped you and Gortash with a theft. She also gives you a hat that Sceleritas Fel will recognise.
Whether Gortash's line still fires with Orin already dead isn't confirmed. The hat gives Momentum at the start of combat and advantage on Concentration saves, and wearing it unlocks some extra lines.
Act Three
Orin's temple
Below the Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
My fight with Orin is different. How does it work?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You don't need the usual key: Sceleritas Fel waits at the temple door and lets you in. The rest of the approach is in Get Orin's Netherstone.
Hint 2
Orin has her own conversation with you, and the fight becomes a one-on-one duel while her cultists watch.
Hint 3
Keep your companions out of it. They can't join, and if they step into the arena, cast into it, or attack the watchers, it turns into the full ritual fight.
Hint 4
Don't leave the arena, don't hit the cultists yourself, and don't get downed or play dead: that counts as losing.
Missable Losing or walking out costs you the Slayer Form and the choice that comes after the fight, permanently.
Solution
You and Orin are placed in the arena; Orin can't fly. If you already have the Slayer Form you can choose to start in it. Orin only takes her own Slayer form if you don't have yours, or if you enrage her with a DC 25 taunt. Her conversation offers Deception, Persuasion, Religion and Intimidation, all at DC 25. Win, and stay for what follows.
Outcomes
Lose the duel, or leave after Orin dies but before the scene that follows
You're revived at 1 hit point, Dazed and Stunned. At your next Act 3 camp the Slayer Form is taken away for good (forced when you travel to Wyrm's Rock). At the very end you're treated like someone who accepted, but can still defy.
After the fight I have to decide who I am. What does each answer cost?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
There are really only two answers. Think about who's in your party before you give one.
Hint 2
Your father speaks to you in person. Accept him, or refuse.
Outcomes
Accept
You keep the Slayer Form and get Orin's Netherstone dagger. The cultists side with you, and Sceleritas Fel joins your camp (you can still choose to finish him off there). Jaheira and Minsc walk out, then come back hostile with the Harpers; with Minsc there, a Wisdom check at DC 25 lets you seize his mind and have him kill Jaheira. Wyll always leaves; Gale leaves below 20 approval, Karlach below 40.
Refuse
Bhaal takes the Slayer Form back and kills you. Withers raises you again. Sceleritas Fel dies on the altar for good (a copy of his hat is on the body). Later dialogue and the ending treat you as free.
Missable Accepting loses Jaheira, Minsc and Wyll for good, and possibly Gale and Karlach. Refusing loses the Slayer Form and Sceleritas for good.