Act 3 · 99 journal steps · starts around the Lower City
One of the three Netherstones is in the hands of someone who doesn't want to be found. A string of grisly murders across Baldur's Gate is the only trail, and you can follow it as a detective, or as something much worse.
Act Three
A name and nothing else
Rivington and the Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I need to find Orin. Where do I even start?
Hint 1
Nobody hands you her address. Follow the bodies: Baldur's Gate has a murder problem, and it isn't random.
Hint 2
There are killings in both Rivington and the Lower City. Some of the corpses have been arranged on purpose, with a note left beside them. Read those notes.
Hint 3
The quickest thread is the murder at the Open Hand Temple in Rivington. It leads to a killer's room and a list of names written in blood.
Hint 4
Other ways in: Constable Gauntlet Devella at the Elfsong Tavern is investigating a murder of her own, Gortash drops a hint at his coronation, and the city's gazette covers the killings. Any of them puts you on the trail.
A stranger in Rivington said something odd and then vanished. What was that?
Hint 1
Think about who might want a close look at you without being seen.
Hint 2
That wasn't the person you thought it was.
Hint 3
It was Orin herself, wearing someone else's face. She can do this up to twice in Rivington, picking from people like a journalist, a smith, a Flaming Fist guard and others.
Outcomes
What happened to the real person
They're dead. You'll find their body later, laid out in Orin's temple.
Nothing in the research shows a way to stop the impersonations once Orin has picked someone. They end when Gortash warns you about her, or when you open her temple.
Act Three
The bloodstained list
Sharess' Caress and the Elfsong Tavern
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've found a list of names. Who should I take it to?
Hint 1
Someone official is already working on these murders. Two people, in fact.
Hint 2
Valeria, the investigator at Sharess' Caress in Rivington, wants hard evidence. The list is exactly that.
Hint 3
Either way, the trail ends up with Constable Gauntlet Devella in a private room at the Elfsong Tavern in the Lower City. Show her the list.
Solution
Copies of the list turn up in the killer's room in Fraygo's Flophouse, in the homes of two people on it, and on the leader of a cultist ambush in a Lower City park. Valeria sends you to Devella once she's convinced. If you skip Valeria, take the list straight to Devella.
Devella doesn't want my help. How do I win her over? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
She's proud and careful. Give her a reason to think you're useful.
Hint 2
Show her you know the case, or that you know your stuff as an investigator.
Hint 3
Talk her round and she hands you the Map of Murder, which points you at the staged corpses around the city. The map is also lying in her room, if you'd rather help yourself.
Missable Keep Devella alive. Killing her ends her part in the investigation and loses the reward she offers later.
Solution
Persuasion DC 15 or Investigation DC 15 does it (some classes get an easier DC 10 line, and a Paladin of the Crown gets advantage). A Deception DC 15 bluff about your training works too. Taking or reading the map without her blessing still updates the journal.
What exactly the Map of Murder marks isn't confirmed in play.
Act Three
The names on the list
Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Some people on the list are already dead. Is there anything to learn from them?
Hint 1
Visit their homes. The dead can still talk, with the right spell.
Hint 2
Franc Peartree and Alexander Rainforest were killed at home. Speak with Dead on either one.
Hint 3
Both describe their killer as a short man dressed in red. Remember him.
Solution
There's a rat in Alexander's cellar that saw the killer too, if you can speak with animals. It doesn't add to the journal.
Can I save the people on the list who are still alive?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go and warn them. Your map marks them while you're in the Lower City.
Hint 2
Chef Roveer works in the Elfsong's kitchen. Nesha Leesha drinks at the Blushing Mermaid. Figaro Pennygood runs a cosmetics shop.
Hint 3
There's a fourth name, Cora Highberry. Her turn comes at a wine festival outside her house.
Outcomes
Warn them
Roveer and Figaro take note. Nesha needs a Persuasion DC 15 check, and if she believes you she leaves for good.
Kill one yourself
The journal counts it as a failure, and the killers notice. It's the first step down the assassin's road.
Missable Once warned, Nesha disappears permanently.
Act Three
A wine festival
Highberry's House
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
What's going on at the wine festival outside the Highberrys' house?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Cora Highberry is on the list. A party on her doorstep is not a coincidence.
Missable Once you've walked into the festival, a long rest with Dolor still there kills both Highberrys. Deal with him before you rest.
Hint 2
Look closely at the wine merchant, and don't drink anything he pours.
Hint 3
The merchant, Master Meztli, is the killer from the list in disguise, and the wine is drugged.
Solution
His real name is Dolor. Call him out in conversation: a passive Medicine DC 18 lets you smell the poison (Barbarians get a Perception DC 10 line instead), or name him as Dolor if the Open Hand Temple case told you. The wine itself, Karabasan's Gift, has an Investigation DC 15 check. Attacking works too. His helpers are doppelgangers who all take his face once the fight starts, and he tries to escape with Misty Step.
Outcomes
Expose him or attack him
The Highberrys survive. Dolor either dies here or flees to Figaro's shop, and he may kill Cora on his way out.
Drink the wine
Everyone who drinks is paralysed, and Dolor drops the act.
Walk away
After your next long rest, Cora and Roger Highberry are found butchered and staged. Dolor then moves on to Figaro.
Take Cora's hand yourself
That cancels Dolor's plan here, and he goes after Figaro instead.
The killer got away from the festival. Where has he gone?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Check the list. Who's left?
Hint 2
Figaro Pennygood's cosmetics shop.
Hint 3
Open the shop door and you walk in on Dolor gloating over a paralysed Figaro. Step in, or stay hidden and watch.
Solution
Interrupting starts the fight. Staying hidden takes Stealth DC 15 and lets Dolor finish Figaro. If Figaro was already dead, search his body: there's a note on it from the person behind all this. Devella turns up after the fight and later waits for you at Basilisk Gate.
Missable Watch the scene play out and Figaro dies. Interrupt if you want him alive.
Knocking Dolor out at the festival or the shop doesn't stick: he wakes up somewhere else entirely.
Dolor's dealt with. What did he leave behind?
Hint 1
Search him thoroughly. He was carrying instructions, and trophies.
Hint 2
A note, Dirge of the Unholy Assassin, holds a password. A pouch holds severed hands.
Hint 3
The password opens a door at Candulhallow's Tombstones in the Lower City. The hands are proof of murder, and someone down there will want to see one.
Solution
The pouch holds the hands of Duke Stelmane, Father Lorgan, Alexander and Franc, plus Figaro's or Cora's if he got that far. You can pickpocket the note and the pouch while he's alive, or take them from his body. Speak with Dead on him also gives up the password. If he's only knocked out, a long rest leaves his belongings in a pile.
Act Three
The other side of the list
Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Can I join the killers instead of stopping them? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You can. Start working through the list yourself.
Hint 2
Kill one of the living names and someone friendly comes looking for you. Don't be hidden, and don't be indoors at one of the victims' haunts.
Missable Hands only drop while you know the list. Kill someone on it before you've read it and you get no hand from them.
Hint 3
Kill a second and he comes back with a password, a note and a key to Candulhallow's Tombstones.
Solution
Valid kills are Cora, Figaro, Nesha and Roveer, or Devella or Valeria. The recruiter won't approach you while you're hidden or inside Highberry's House, Figaro's shop, the Elfsong, the Blushing Mermaid or Basilisk Gate. If he misses you, a second one tries when you fast travel or return to camp. Victims killed after you've learned the list drop a severed hand: keep it.
From the script, the court below only checks that you carry one valid hand, not that you made two kills. Not confirmed in play.
A bloodstained letter in camp mentions Gortash's hand. What's that for?
Hint 1
The letter tells you where to go, and how to get in.
Hint 2
It gives you the password for Candulhallow's Tombstones. Gortash's hand is your proof of a kill.
Hint 3
You get his hand automatically when you take his Netherstone.
Act Three
The gravestone shop
Candulhallow's Tombstones
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I'm in Candulhallow's Tombstones. Where's the way down?
Hint 1
The shop's front door is locked. Pick it, or use the key if you were given one.
Hint 2
Inside, one of the bookcases moves. Look for the button that opens it, and what's covering it.
Hint 3
A painting hangs over the button. Move it out of the way, press the button, and the bookcase slides aside to reveal a door.
Solution
The front door is lock DC 10. Move, pick up or destroy the painting, then press the button. At the door behind the bookcase, give the password: Sicarius. History or Investigation DC 20 there only tells you about the door; without the password it stays shut.
Act Three
The court below
Beneath the tombstone shop
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Armoured guards below won't let me pass. What do they want? unverified
Hint 1
They want proof that you belong here.
Hint 2
Proof of a murder. One you committed, or claim to have.
Hint 3
Show the leader a severed hand of someone on their list.
Solution
Accepted hands: Gortash, Duke Stelmane, Father Lorgan, Alexander, Franc, Cora, Figaro, Nesha, Roveer, the hand of Dribbles the clown from the Circus, and Gale's hand for a Dark Urge who took it in Act 1. With no hand, Persuasion DC 18 buys you time (Bards and the Dark Urge can use Performance DC 18 with advantage); otherwise they attack. The courtroom door beyond is DC 20 and opens by itself once you're let through.
Outcomes
Dolor is still alive
If you've killed a second name on the list, he shows up here claiming the honour. Fight him, let it play out, or talk him into attacking the court with you (Persuasion DC 20 or DC 25 depending on class; Fighters Persuasion DC 20, Barbarians Intimidation DC 20). If he does turn on the court, he's struck dead on the spot.
That one hand is enough without any kills of your own, the clown's hand included, isn't confirmed in play.
The judge asks how my victim died. What should I say?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This court admires its own kind. Answer like one of them.
Hint 2
Honest, modest or vague answers go badly. Revel in it.
Hint 3
If you really killed the owner of that hand, gloat and it's accepted. If you didn't, you'll have to lie.
Solution
Any of the gleeful answers works for someone you killed yourself. For a hand from Dolor's pouch or the clown, it's Deception DC 20 (DC 10 for the Dark Urge). Saying it happened in combat, that the details don't matter, or that you didn't do it, starts the fight.
Missable You get one trial. After the ghost has been called up, the judge won't hear you again.
The court has its eye on one of my companions. What are my options?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The judge, Sarevok, has an old grudge, and it's with Jaheira and Minsc.
Hint 2
You can hand them over, refuse, or make them look like they've given up.
Outcomes
Offer them
Jaheira and Minsc leave the party for good and turn on you. Killing them counts as the offering.
Make them kneel
Intimidation DC 20, or a Performance DC 20 act (Dark Urge: Intimidation DC 18). They play along and the trial carries on with both alive.
Refuse
The whole court attacks.
Missable Offering Jaheira and Minsc loses them permanently.
The court is ready to accept me. Is there a catch?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
There's always a catch. Look in the room behind the court before you agree to anything.
Hint 2
Someone you've met is chained up in there.
Hint 3
To become one of them, you have to kill Valeria and bathe in her blood.
Outcomes
Kill Valeria
Sarevok gives you an Amulet of Bhaal and tells you where Orin's temple is. You become an Unholy Assassin (with an achievement), a ghostly merchant opens shop, and the Bhaalist cultists in the sewers leave you alone. A Paladin who kills her, or an Oath of the Crown Paladin who accepts the title, breaks their oath.
Free her
Picking her chains (DC 15), casting Knock or attacking them counts as betrayal, and the court attacks.
Missable Valeria dies for good if you take the baptism, and that fails the Open Hand Temple case. A Paladin's oath breaks too.
Focus. The court gets stronger as it loses members.
Hint 2
Every ghost that falls before Sarevok makes him more dangerous. Go for him first.
Hint 3
When Sarevok dies, the ghosts fade and his oath-bound death knights die with him.
Solution
Each ghost that dies first feeds Sarevok: Amelyssan makes his hits heal him, Illasera gives him permanent Haste and immunity to paralysis, restraint and slowing, Sendai adds +6 AC and mirror images, and the merchant ghost makes his hits roll maximum damage. After four attacks he can unleash a flurry of 5d10 slashing strikes. Burst him down before that.
The court is dealt with. Where do I go from here?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Search the courtroom and Sarevok's body. Then check the room behind the court.
Hint 2
You need two things: directions, and something that opens the door at the end of them.
Hint 3
Sarevok wears an Amulet of Bhaal, and a map lies by his chair. Valeria is chained up in the abattoir behind the court, and if you free her she tells you the way.
Missable If you tell Valeria to leave, she goes without giving directions; read Sarevok's map instead. Devella's reward is lost if she's dead.
Solution
The Abattoir Key is on the courtroom floor (or pick the lock, DC 20). Valeria's chains are DC 15. The amulet is what opens Orin's temple, so take it. Afterwards, tell Devella at Basilisk Gate that Sarevok is dead for a reward.
Someone at camp isn't where they should be. What's going on? unverified
Hint 1
Gortash warned you someone had got into your camp.
Hint 2
Orin has taken them, and she wants something from you in exchange.
Hint 3
She wants Gortash dead. You can agree or refuse.
Outcomes
Who she takes
Your romance partner if it's Lae'zel, Halsin, Gale or Minthara, otherwise one of them resting in camp, otherwise Yenna. It happens on a camp night in Act 3, or earlier in the Lower City sewers and Undercity.
Agree
Bloodstained letters follow you as you move against Gortash, and at the temple Orin may honour the deal if he's dead.
Refuse
She threatens her captive the moment you meet her at the temple.
Abductions stop once Orin's temple door is opened, so reaching the temple before Gortash warns you should spare your companions; Yenna is put on the altar instead. That inference isn't confirmed in play.
I keep finding bloody letters in camp. What do they want?
Hint 1
They're from Orin, and they turn up as you make progress against Gortash.
Hint 2
One comes after you fight a Steel Watcher, one after the Foundry falls, and one after Gortash dies.
Hint 3
The last one sends you to Candulhallow's Tombstones with a password, and Gortash's hand as your proof. From there, the court below can point you to Orin.
A door in the ruins has a talking skull. How do I get past? unverified
Hint 1
The skull wants to see the right credentials. If you don't have them, look at what's hanging nearby.
Hint 2
An Amulet of Bhaal gets you through. Without one, think about what this door is fed with.
Hint 3
Hit one of the hanging corpses beside it. Their blood runs onto the skull, and the door opens.
Solution
Show the skull an Amulet of Bhaal and either be an Unholy Assassin or claim you slaughtered the Tribunal; no check needed. The Dark Urge also gets through. Otherwise, strike a corpse so its blood pools under the skull.
Whether this door is the only way to the temple isn't confirmed.
The bridge ahead looks trapped. How do I cross it safely?
Hint 1
Keep an eye out on the way. Cultists lie in ambush in the Undercity, and the bridge is rigged.
Hint 2
There are three sets of gas traps along the bridge, and the last one is fire.
Hint 3
Disarming only some of them isn't enough: if the fire trap goes off, the others re-arm. Disarm or avoid every one.
Solution
Spotting the ambushes takes Perception DC 18. If you're an Unholy Assassin, the sewer cultists stay neutral.
I've found a huge sealed door. How do I open it?
Hint 1
Study the door. A Religion check (DC 18) tells you whose temple this is.
Hint 2
It's Bhaal's temple, and it only opens for his own.
Hint 3
Press an Amulet of Bhaal to it. If you're the Dark Urge, your butler opens it for you.
Solution
Sarevok wears the amulet and gives it to you if you take the baptism; otherwise take it from his body. Opening the door ends any further abductions and impersonations, and Orin is waiting inside.
See also: The Urge, the Dark Urge's own path through the temple
Act Three
Orin
Temple of Bhaal
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
There's someone on the altar. Can I get them off it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The altar has a lock.
Hint 2
You can pick it if you're very good, or take the key from the person who has it.
Hint 3
Unlock the altar before you start talking to Orin and you free the captive straight away, though Orin joins you at once.
Missable If the fight starts and you leave the temple without having freed the captive, they count as dead. A companion who dies here is gone for good.
Solution
The altar is lock DC 25. The Altar Key is in Orin's inventory.
Whether you can pickpocket the Altar Key from Orin isn't confirmed.
How do I get through the conversation with Orin without anyone dying?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Free them first if you can (see the question about the altar). Then mind what you say.
Hint 2
Never tell Orin you don't care about them.
Hint 3
Every check Orin offers is DC 25, and with Gortash alive a failed one costs the captive's life. Some lore makes those talks go your way.
Solution
Speak with Dead on Orin's mother, whose body lies in the temple, and read a page in the desk in the Tribunal prison office. What you learn unlocks lines that shake Orin's confidence. Afterwards, talk to the freed captive, or just leave or rest, and they go home.
Outcomes
Gortash is dead and you kept her deal
Orin may keep her side of the bargain. Persuasion DC 25 with advantage if you remind her you killed him.
Gortash is alive
Deception, Persuasion and Intimidation are all DC 25. Fail and she kills the captive.
Say you don't care, or tell her to go ahead
She kills them.
Unsettle her
The lore lines reveal that Sarevok ordered her mother to kill her, and that he's her father as well as her grandfather. Succeed and Bhaal forces her into her Slayer form.
Missable A companion Orin kills here is lost for good. Free them from the altar first and the in-conversation kill can't happen.
How do I beat Orin?
Hint 1
She isn't fighting alone. Look at what the cultists around the room are doing.
Hint 2
Six Reapers are channelling power into her. While they do, she shrugs off a hit completely every turn.
Hint 3
Shut the Reapers down. Silence, stun, frighten, knock prone or knock out every one of them and the ritual ends.
Solution
Each turn the ritual gives Orin a fresh stack of a buff that absorbs one hit each (7 stacks, 12 on Tactician and Honour). A Reaper stops channelling if silenced, unconscious, incapacitated, frightened, fleeing, petrified, stunned or prone. When all six stop, Orin enters a second phase with blood skeletons. Banishing her also ends the ritual. Watch for her big attack after five strikes: seven hits of 3d10. She can also gain 25 temporary hit points.
Orin's dead. Where's the Netherstone?
Hint 1
Look at her weapons.
Hint 2
Pick up her dagger. The stone is set in its pommel, and you get both the Netherstone and the plain blade.