Act 2 · 11 journal steps · starts around the Moonrise Towers
A drow commander from Act 1 has run out of favour with the Absolute, and Moonrise Towers is about to make an example of her. Whether she walks out of there, and in what state, is up to you.
Act Two
A trial in the throne hall
Moonrise Towers, throne hall
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
I never saw Minthara at Moonrise. Have I missed this? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This quest depends on how things ended with Minthara back in Act 1.
Hint 2
Minthara only turns up at Moonrise if she survived Act 1. Killing her ends it before it starts. Knocking her out doesn't.
Missable If Minthara is killed outright in Act 1, this quest never happens and she can't be recruited later. Knock her out instead.
Hint 3
With non-lethal attacks switched on, knock Minthara out at her post by the throne in the Shattered Sanctum, or leave Act 1 while she is still down. Either way she's taken off alive, and appears at Moonrise the first time you arrive there.
Needing non-lethal attacks for the knockout is the general game rule, not checked in these scripts. It's also unconfirmed whether a Minthara who joined you on the goblin route in Act 1 still ends up at the trial: nothing in the setup checks for that.
There's a trial in the throne hall. Can I change how it ends?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Listen in. Your tadpole gives you a few ways to lean on the people involved.
Hint 2
Minthara's sentence doesn't change with anything you say: every peaceful route ends with her taken down to the prison. The quest starts there.
Hint 3
The only way to stop it on the spot is violence, and that turns all of Moonrise against you.
Solution
Tadpole options, all Wisdom: force Minthara to own up to her failure (DC 14), calm Disciple Z'rell into mercy (DC 16), or push your will on Ketheric Thorm (DC 21, and all you learn is that he has no tadpole). These change how the court treats her, not the sentence.
Outcomes
Let the trial run its course
Minthara is marched down to the prison by two guards, and the quest moves below.
Attack
You become an outcast of Moonrise and a fight starts. Minthara sides with you; once she's out of combat she comes to find whoever started it and talks to them, which frees her.
Missable Attacking at the trial makes you an enemy of Moonrise Towers. Anything else you meant to do there peacefully gets much harder.
Guards are leading Minthara away. Can I step in?
Hint 1
Count the guards walking with Minthara.
Hint 2
There are only two of them. If both fall while she's still being escorted, she's free there and then.
Act Two
Down in the cells
Moonrise Towers prison
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Where did they take Minthara?
Hint 1
Down. Moonrise has a prison below the tower.
Hint 2
Minthara is held in the drow corner of the prison, with two gnome questioners, Sumera and Jasin, waiting for her.
Hint 3
Walk up to Minthara while both questioners are standing with her and the scene starts on its own.
How long do I have before it's too late for Minthara?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
There's no clock. Moonrise's own story is the deadline.
Hint 2
The quest closes when the battle for Moonrise Towers begins, or when you're carried from the roof to the next part of the story. Go to Minthara before you push the main plot that far.
Missable If the quest closes before you've freed Minthara, she ends up an enthralled servant of the Absolute. If you'd freed her but hadn't got her out yet, she dies. Either way she's lost as a companion.
Two questioners are working on Minthara. What can I do?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You can watch, join in, or put a stop to it. Showing an interest gets the questioners talking.
Hint 2
Ask what they're doing, or show some interest in Minthara's worth, and you can try to take over the job yourself.
Hint 3
To take over, either claim you've been told to handle her personally, or order them out of the way. Success lets you into her mind. Threatening them, or attacking, starts a fight instead.
Solution
Taking over: Deception DC 10 (you were told to deal with her yourself) or Intimidation DC 14 (order them aside). Fail, and they carry on, and Minthara turns on all of you. From there, comforting her or trying to stop them leads to a fight. Telling them to finish, or backing off, lets them finish the job.
Missable If you fail to take over and then tell the questioners to finish her, or just back away, her mind is erased and she can't be freed. Pick the fight instead.
Something stands between me and Minthara. How do I get past it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's a hard Wisdom check, but you can change the odds before you start.
Hint 2
How your night with Minthara went at the goblin party back in Act 1 matters here.
Hint 3
There's a way to skip the roll entirely, found elsewhere in Moonrise Towers. Look closely at the walls of the ground-floor guard room.
Solution
Wisdom DC 18 to push through. You roll with advantage if you spent a good night with Minthara at the goblin celebration, and with disadvantage if she sent you away. If you've already entered the void through the cracked wall in the ground-floor guard room (it takes a Perception check to spot), you can simply ask to pass, with no roll. Fail or retreat, and you're thrown out: she defies all of you, and you're back to the choices at her defiance.
Missable A failed push puts Minthara one step from erasure. If you don't then fight the questioners, she's lost.
I've reached Minthara. Which choice gets her out? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Two of your three options save her. One doesn't.
Hint 2
You can turn her against the questioners openly, or have her pretend to be broken so they let her go.
Outcomes
Fight them together
Minthara is free and fights beside you against Sumera and Jasin. She has no weapon.
Have her play broken
The questioners doubt it, and you get one check to convince them: Intimidation, Deception or Persuasion, each DC 18. Pass, and they go back to their posts as ordinary prison guards, and Minthara follows you as a silent thrall or hides to wait. Fail, and it's a fight.
Let them erase her
Minthara becomes a loyal thrall of the Absolute and stays in the prison. The quest ends there, and she can't be recruited. A paladin who chooses this breaks their oath.
Missable Erasing Minthara is permanent. Nothing frees her afterwards.
After the fight-together option, the journal skips the questioner-fight step and goes straight to the escape. Not confirmed in play. That she fights unarmed comes from her weapons being taken at setup.
How do I beat the questioners? unverified
Hint 1
There are only two of them, and neither is very tough. Watch out for who else is watching.
Hint 2
Sumera and Jasin are gnome warlocks with 59 hit points each. They hit with Repelling Blast, which knocks you back, and they carry a passive that punishes you for getting close.
Hint 3
A prison scrying eye floats just nearby. Deal with the eye early, and if Minthara is fighting with you, keep her out of trouble: she's unarmed.
Whether other prison guards join the fight isn't confirmed, and nor is the effect of Dreadful Word in play.
I had Minthara's mace. Where has it gone?
Hint 1
Moonrise confiscates things.
Hint 2
If anyone in your party (not your camp chest) carried Xyanyde when you reached Moonrise, it was moved to the prison's evidence chest. You can get it back from there for her.
Act Two
Getting out
Moonrise Towers
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Minthara is free. What now?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Talk to Minthara. If she can't see you after the fight, go to her.
Hint 2
She'll want out of the tower. You can have her follow you, or tell her to hide and wait.
Hint 3
While she follows, you can't fast travel or use waypoints, and she won't go upstairs, onto the roof, or into the tower's restricted areas. Try, and she drops back to wait for you. Go back and talk to her to pick her up again.
Outcomes
Tell Minthara to follow
She joins you as a follower. Head for the main gate.
Tell Minthara to wait
She hides until you come back for her.
Tell Minthara you came to kill her
She turns hostile.
Missable Turning on Minthara here means fighting her. If she dies, she's gone for good.
Guards keep stopping me with Minthara. How do I get past them?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Stay close to Minthara. Guards who see her on her own don't stop to chat.
Missable If a guard sees Minthara without you nearby (not within 10 m, or you're hidden from them), she becomes an open enemy of Moonrise and the guards attack her on sight. She can die before she reaches the gate.
Hint 2
The prison guards will question you if they see her with you, and two guards hold a checkpoint at the main gate. A good story gets you through each time.
Hint 3
Once you've talked your way past one of these checks, the rest of the guards leave you alone. A True Soul passes automatically.
Solution
Prison guards: Persuasion DC 14 (she's your servant), Intimidation DC 14 (suggest the guard could take her cell), Deception DC 16 (she's had her mind wiped), or Wisdom DC 14 with your tadpole if you aren't a True Soul. A True Soul can just deny there's a prisoner. Gate checkpoint: Persuasion, Intimidation or Deception, each DC 14. Fail any of them, or attack, and you fight those guards.
We made it out of the tower. What happens now? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Keep going past the main gate towards the bridge. Minthara stops to talk once you're both clear and nobody's fighting.
Hint 2
Your link through the Astral Prism shows her what the Absolute really is, and she asks if you have somewhere safe.
Hint 3
Tell her where your camp is if you want her as a companion.
Missable Minthara is only recruitable if you send her to camp here. Send her away and she doesn't come back in this act.
Outcomes
Invite Minthara to camp
She heads for your camp and becomes a possible companion.
Tell her she's on her own, then give in when she asks to come anyway
Same as inviting her: she goes to camp.
Tell her she's on her own, then threaten her or tell her to keep away
She leaves for good.
Tell her you only saved her to kill her
She turns hostile. Killing her ends the quest.
Missable A Minthara who isn't in your camp or party when Moonrise's story ends dies there.
See also: Rescue Wulbren, Rescue Wulbren: the prison boat
Leaving by the prison boat to Last Light seems to count too: the talk then waits until you can use the inn. That route isn't confirmed. That recruiting happens in camp afterwards is inferred, not checked, and so is 'for good' when you send her away: no script in this act brings her back, but that's an absence, not a rule.