Jaheira wants to check in on her Harpers in Baldur's Gate. What she finds there sends you after an old friend she has quietly been searching for, deep into the city's underworld.
Act Two
Jaheira's plans
Camp, after Moonrise
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
How does Jaheira's quest start?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It starts at the camp celebration after Ketheric falls. Jaheira has to be alive and with you by then.
Hint 2
When Jaheira talks to you at the celebration, ask her to join you properly. She'll name a Harper safe-house in Baldur's Gate.
Missable If you tell Jaheira to go her own way at the celebration, this quest never starts, and later on there's no way to save the person it leads you to. Recruit her if you want any of it.
Hint 3
The safe-house is under Danthelon's Dancing Axe, a weapon shop on Wyrm's Crossing. If you missed the talk, Jaheira brings it up again once you reach Rivington.
Talk to the shopkeeper, Danthelon, the dwarf behind the counter.
Hint 2
Bring Jaheira, or tell Danthelon that Jaheira sent you. He'll let you downstairs.
Solution
Danthelon hands over a Rusty Key to the basement door if he still has it. If not, he tells you to find your own way in, and two buttons on the wall open the back doors. Using them isn't a crime while the quest is running.
Any advice for the meeting in the basement? unverified
Hint 1
Go in with Jaheira, and listen closely to how the young Harper, Geraldus, greets her.
Hint 2
Geraldus is speaking in code, and he's terrified. A passive Insight check (DC 15) catches it, Jaheira's own coded replies give you more chances, and you can ask Jaheira what the phrase means.
Hint 3
The other four Harpers in the room are doppelgangers. Strike first and they're the ones caught by surprise. Miss every clue and it's your party that's surprised.
Solution
Four doppelgangers, level 8, about 52 hit points each, with two attacks a turn, good Dexterity saves and immunity to charm. Geraldus fights on your side, so keep him alive. Detect Thoughts on Geraldus, Jaheira or one of the fakes is another way to see through it, but a failed read on a doppelganger starts the fight at once. Without Jaheira, the lead doppelganger notices she isn't with you; pressing Geraldus makes him blurt out the truth. Looting the doppelgangers' bodies isn't a crime, and one of them carries written orders worth reading.
The Insight DC and surprise rules come from the scene's script. The Detect Thoughts rolls have no difficulty stored in the dialogue, so we don't know how hard they are.
The meeting in the basement is over. What now?
Hint 1
If Geraldus survived, talk to him before you do anything else.
Hint 2
Geraldus tells you what happened to the rest of his cell, and why: they'd been asking questions about someone. Then talk to Jaheira.
Hint 3
Jaheira finally explains. She has been searching for her old friend Minsc, who vanished fighting the cult beneath the city. Agree to help her find him.
Outcomes
Speak up for Geraldus
Jaheira wants to send him home. If you say the choice is his, or turn it back on her, he stays a Harper. If he survives the game, that opens an epilogue letter from him.
Agree with Jaheira
Geraldus retires to his mother's farm. No letter later.
Geraldus died
The quest still moves on: talk to Jaheira.
I went to the Lower City without visiting the safe-house. Is that a problem? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The quest carries on, but you've skipped part of it.
Hint 2
Once you leave Wyrm's Crossing behind, the safe-house scene is cleared away. Jaheira gets word of what happened there instead, and you can talk to her about it in the city.
Missable The safe-house scene, Geraldus and his epilogue letter are lost for good if you leave the Wyrm's Crossing area before dealing with the basement. Do it before you cross into the Lower City.
The scene is cleared when the Wyrm's Crossing level unloads. Which trips count (only the Lower City, or also camp and fast travel) isn't confirmed in play.
Act Three
Picking up the trail
Lower City, the Guildhall
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where do I start looking for Minsc in the city?
Hint 1
Once you're in the Lower City, ask Jaheira how you might find Minsc.
Hint 2
Jaheira knows the head of the thieves' guild, Nine-Fingers Keene. If anyone in the city knows something, Nine-Fingers does.
Hint 3
Go to the Guildhall with Jaheira and talk to Nine-Fingers. She knows more than she wants to say, and she has a trap waiting.
Outcomes
What Nine-Fingers reveals
The Stone Lord, the cult-backed gang boss eating into the Guild's territory, is Minsc. Nine-Fingers won't say where her trap is.
Nine-Fingers won't say where her trap is. How do I find out?
Hint 1
Look around the Guildhall. Plenty of people there know more than their boss would like.
Hint 2
Any one of three sources is enough: a letter in Nine-Fingers' office, the Guild's bursar Uktar, or a pair of halfling drinkers.
Hint 3
The trap is at the Counting House, the city's bank. The letter is from its Head Banker.
Solution
Read the letter from Rakath Glitterbeard in Nine-Fingers' office; or get Uktar talking (Persuasion, Intimidation or Deception, DC 18); or chat with the two halfling drinkers (History or Constitution, DC 15, and a passive Insight check at 18 helps).
The vault level needs a pass. The Head Clerk, Meadhoney, is the one to ask.
Hint 2
Head Clerk Meadhoney is worried about some recent visitors who went downstairs with the Head Banker. Watch out for the pressure plates before the vault checkpoint.
Hint 3
The lowest level ends at the Great Door, which can't be picked. The code is in a book of dwarven history in the Head Banker's office upstairs.
Solution
Get the pass from Head Clerk Meadhoney (Persuasion DC 15 or 18, Intimidation or Deception DC 10, or a passive Insight check at 10 helps), or open an account for 10,000 gold. The lobby guard can also be bribed. The plates before the checkpoint are a gas trap that a lever disarms. The Great Door code is 1356, entered on the nine pressure plates in front of it.
See also: Aid the Underduke, the Counting House in detail, including the plate order
The code 1356 is in the game files. How the plates map to digits is in a script we can't read, so the plate order on the linked page is inferred.
Act Three
The vault
The Counting House vault
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
The robbers got away. Did I do something wrong?
Hint 1
No. Nothing you say or do in that scene stops the escape.
Any one of three clues works: a note on one of the cultists, a dead cultist who answers Speak with Dead, or footprints on the floor (an easy passive Perception check, DC 10).
Hint 3
They all point down, into the sewers. The hideout is the Abandoned Cistern, and your journal updates when you enter the sewers.
A sluice gate blocks the way to the cistern. How do I open it? unverified
Hint 1
There's a note nearby for the sanitation workers. It explains the machinery.
Hint 2
Two valves, water and temperature, each with a gauge. The gate opens when both gauges sit at the middle mark at the same time.
Solution
Open the water valve for four turns, until it reaches the middle mark, then close it and open the temperature valve straight away. Two turns later both are at the middle and the gate opens. Fire on a valve raises its temperature, cold lowers it, and the release valve helps if one overloads. Or force the valve with Athletics (DC 25), or smash the gate.
Worked out from the gauge rules in the scripts, not tested in play.
I've reached the Stone Lord. What should I know before the fight? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Bring Jaheira, and don't rush in. The Stone Lord has a visitor, and you may want to watch.
Hint 2
Think about how this fight should end. Turn on non-lethal attacks before you start.
Hint 3
The Stone Lord is Minsc, under the Absolute's control. Knock him out rather than killing him, and do it during the fight.
Missable Killing Minsc loses him for good, and Jaheira leaves the party for good over it too. Turn on non-lethal attacks before the fight.
Solution
Minsc (level 12, very strong) fights alongside a doppelganger wearing Jaheira's face, the Zhentarim leader who came to collect a bribe, his gang and the sluice guards. Being knocked out never counts as a permanent defeat for Minsc, but a lethal blow kills him. With non-lethal attacks on, the hit that would drop him knocks him out instead. Once combat ends, a conversation to free him starts. If no one is close, Jaheira tells you to go to him, and you talk to him yourself.
If you attack before the Zhentarim leader arrives, it isn't confirmed that the journal still updates.
The Stone Lord is down. What now?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The one character who has to start this conversation is the one who has a tadpole. Without one, you can't even try.
Hint 2
You need the Emperor to shield Minsc, and it doesn't want to. Jaheira is the key.
Hint 3
With Jaheira there, back her when she threatens the Emperor. Side with the Emperor and Minsc fights you again.
Missable If the rescue fails, Minsc is lost as a companion, and Jaheira leaves for good if she's with you. Dark Urge characters who haven't resisted the Urge get extra kill options here, which are easy to pick by mistake. Paladins (except Oath of Vengeance) who choose to kill him break their oath.
Outcomes
Jaheira is there, and you back her
The Emperor gives in and Minsc is freed. The Insight checks on Jaheira only change how she reacts.
Jaheira is there, and you side with the Emperor
Jaheira asks to strike the killing blow herself, and Minsc fights again. He's lost, and Jaheira leaves the party for good.
Jaheira is alive and recruited, but not with you
Force the Emperor's hand with Intimidation or History (DC 15). Minsc then accuses you of killing Jaheira: show him an image of her alive, or tell him you saved her, and he's freed. Telling him it was a doppelganger fails, and he fights again.
Jaheira is dead or was never recruited
There are no options to save him. He fights again and can't be saved.
After the fight in the cistern, someone runs off. Where to? unverified
Hint 1
Minsc is looking for Boo, his hamster.
Hint 2
Boo is walled up in a side chamber of the hideout, the one with Minsc's keepsakes scattered around. Follow Minsc there.
Hint 3
There's an outer wall, and three small cells behind it. Only one of the cells holds Boo.
Solution
Any wall Minsc attacks breaks at once, and breaking the right cell, by anyone, frees Boo. The right cell is on the side of the chamber with the mailed fist and the mask. One wrong cell is on the far side, past the pair of wings, and the other is behind the turnip and the warhammer.
Which cell is right was worked out from object positions, not tested. Whether Minsc walks to the walls on his own, and whether freeing Boo yourself triggers the reunion, isn't confirmed.
Someone at the cistern wants to join me. Should I say yes? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about who else in your party cares about the answer.
Hint 2
Jaheira and Minsc are a package deal from here on.
Outcomes
Recruit Minsc
He joins with Boo, and Jaheira stays. Minsc has his own conversations from here on, and a part to play when things come to a head at the Guildhall.
Turn him down
Minsc leaves, and Jaheira leaves with him.
Later: lose either of them
If Jaheira leaves for good or dies, Minsc leaves too. Offering Minsc as the sacrifice at the Murder Tribunal also makes Jaheira leave.
Missable Declining Minsc costs you both him and Jaheira.