Gale of Waterdeep is a gifted wizard with impeccable manners and a problem he would rather not discuss. Help him with it, and his story runs from a stone circle by the crash site to the very end of the game.
Act One
A hand in the stone
Roadside Cliffs, near the crash site
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
There's a hand reaching out of a stone circle. What do I do?
Hint 1
Someone is stuck in the waypoint, and he would very much like to be let out.
Hint 2
Touch the circle and the hand appears. Take it and pull.
Hint 3
It's an easy roll. Once he's out, he introduces himself as Gale and offers to travel with you.
Solution
Strength DC 7 pulls him free, and a retry is Strength DC 12. Some classes get their own option instead: Wizards roll Intelligence DC 7, others Charisma or Wisdom DC 7, and Rogues Sleight of Hand DC 12. Don't attack him during the conversation, or he turns hostile.
What if Gale dies for good or leaves?
Hint 1
His quest ends if he dies permanently, turns hostile, or walks out because his approval of you sinks too low.
Hint 2
He can also leave over his own problem if you handle it badly. The questions below say where.
Act One
Gale's condition
Camp and on the road
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Gale wants a private word about something he needs. What's going on?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Keep Gale happy, or keep exploring. Either way he'll come to you.
Hint 2
Once his approval of you is high enough, or once you've seen enough of the region, he asks to talk alone. Listen to him.
Hint 3
He has something dangerous lodged in his chest, and he has to feed it magic items now and then to keep it calm. For the full story of how it got there, ask him about his past, or wait until he's eaten three items.
Outcomes
Read his mind with the tadpole
Wisdom DC 10, then DC 15 to see the orb's own memory. Telling him what you saw makes him threaten to leave.
Then calm him down
Persuasion DC 12 or Insight DC 12 keeps him with you.
Fail that roll, or say you want the thing far away from you
He leaves the party for good.
Missable If you peek with the tadpole and tell him, you can lose Gale permanently. Keep what you saw to yourself, or be ready to pass Persuasion or Insight DC 12.
He asks to talk once his approval of you reaches 20. If he hasn't by the time you've seen three of the main Act 1 areas, he raises it anyway when he first asks for an item.
Gale keeps asking for magic items. Which ones will do, and can I say no? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
He doesn't want gold or potions. He wants enchanted gear with real power in it.
Hint 2
Once he's explained his condition, items he can eat are marked for you in your inventory. Look for that marker before you sell or equip something.
Hint 3
When he asks, choose the option to give him an artefact, and hand over exactly one marked item. He asks three times in all.
Missable Feed him at least one item. Without one, the help he needs in Act 2 never arrives, and he leaves at the end of that act.
Solution
He accepts one item carrying his consumable-artefact tag per request; offer two and he'll ask for just one. Examples include the Sword of Justice, the Disintegrating Night Walkers, the Shadow of Menzoberranzan, the Amulet of Selûne's Chosen, the Staff of Arcane Blessing, the Hag's Ring, the Shortsword of First Blood, the Gloves of Power, the Ring of Colour Spray and the gear from the Adamantine Forge. Each one earns +10 approval. His first request comes after you've visited three of the main Act 1 areas (the Emerald Grove, the hag's lair, the Myconid Circle, the duergar camp, the goblin throne room, the Risen Road and the Blighted Village), and the next after two more. Arriving by waypoint doesn't count. In Act 2, reaching Reithwin and approaching Moonrise Towers bring the next request sooner.
Outcomes
Give him an item
His need is met for now, and the count starts again.
Put him off once
Fine, flat or with Persuasion DC 10. He'll remind you a little later.
Put him off a second time
Flat or with Persuasion DC 15. You're now on your last chance.
Refuse a third time, or open the trade and give him nothing
He leaves the party for good.
Tell him never
He leaves for good at once. A failed persuasion roll also counts as a refusal.
Missable Three refusals, an empty trade window after two, or a flat never, and Gale leaves permanently.
As far as the scripts show, an unfed companion Gale only nags and eventually leaves; nothing makes him explode from hunger alone. Not yet confirmed in play.
Act One
In Case of Death...
Wherever Gale fell
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Gale died, and an image of him started talking. What do I do? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Listen to the whole message. He planned for this, and the instructions matter.
Hint 2
There's a pouch in his inventory now. Open it the way the message told you, and nothing else.
Missable Pulling any other thread warns you first. If you keep pulling, the pouch, flute and letter are destroyed. Back off and use the purple thread.
Hint 3
Inside are a flute and a letter. Play the right tune, then give the right name to whatever answers it.
Missable Don't leave him dead for long. His body hurts anyone nearby, and after about three long rests the thing in his chest goes off and the game ends.
Solution
Talk to the pouch and pull the purple thread counter-clockwise; that option only appears once the projection has explained the protocol. On the flute, play individual notes: D, E, A, D. A wrong note resets the sequence, and the Performance ditty does nothing useful. A magma mephit appears: answer it with the name K'ha'ssji'trach'ash, then hand over Gale's letter. It becomes a Scroll of True Resurrection. Shortcut: dropping the letter into lava also turns it into the scroll. Or skip all this and revive him another way, with Withers, Revivify or a scroll.
The exact number of rests (two or three) isn't confirmed. The purple-thread option sits under a dialogue branch that reads as if it needs the protocol to be unknown; check it really appears after hearing the message. Whether the pouch still turns up if he first dies after Act 1 isn't confirmed either.
Act Two
An old friend
Mountain pass and the Shadow-Cursed Lands
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Is there any real help for Gale's condition?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Help comes looking for Gale, but only once he's eaten at least one magic item.
Missable No item eaten, no visitor. Without him, Gale leaves at the end of Act 2.
Hint 2
Keep Gale with you as you head into the Shadow-Cursed Lands. An old man is waiting where you come out of the mountain pass, or where the Underdark lift arrives.
Missable Get Elminster to camp before you enter the Colony beneath Moonrise. After that his visit can no longer happen.
Hint 3
Let him talk to Gale, then go back to camp. The conversation there settles Gale's condition, whatever you say.
Solution
The old man is Elminster. He waits on the Shadow-Cursed Lands side of the mountain trail, or at the top of the lift from the Underdark. If you pass him by, he visits during a camp night instead, as long as Gale has eaten an item, is with you, and you're in the Shadow-Cursed Lands or the creche. After the camp scene the orb is stable, the hunger stops, and Gale has a new spell that detonates it.
Missable Never cast Gale's new orb spell, except in the very last battle of the game. Anywhere else it ends the game.
Gale is saying his goodbyes. Can I stop him leaving?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This only happens if his condition was never dealt with.
Hint 2
If Elminster is in camp and alive, go and talk to him; Gale will only nudge you.
Hint 3
If not, it's too late. Gale leaves when Act 3 begins and leaves a letter behind.
Missable Gale is gone for good if his orb isn't stabilised by the end of Act 2. Feed him an item early in Act 1, and let Elminster reach camp.
Act Two
Balthazar's Experiment
Moonrise Towers
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
There's a strange ritual circle in a lab at Moonrise. What do I do with it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Bring Gale to look at it. He can tell you what it's for.
Hint 2
It's a shadow-magic circle meant to make something. The ingredients lie close by: look for a dead pixie and a broken moonlantern.
Hint 3
You can make the thing, or wreck the circle. Gale has an opinion about which.
Outcomes
Let Gale craft it
You get the Shadow Lantern. Gale is uneasy about it, and he won't get the blessing below.
Insist on crafting it yourself
Arcana DC 30, with advantage for Wizards and Shadowheart. Fail and the circle explodes.
Erase the sigils with Gale present
Gale gains Mystra's blessing: advantage on Concentration saves.
Erase it yourself without him
Gale only comments.
Leave it alone
Once Act 3 begins, the chance is gone.
Missable The circle is single use. Whatever you do with it is final, and leaving it untouched past the end of Act 2 loses both the lantern and the blessing.
Act Two
Beneath Moonrise
The Colony
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Gale wants to do something drastic in the Colony. How do I talk him out of it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This only comes up if his orb has been stabilised and he's in your active party.
Hint 2
There's no roll here. It's down to what you tell him.
Hint 3
Ask him to trust you, or tell him to stand down. If you're romancing him, that works too.
Missable Telling him to go ahead, or that there's no other choice, ends the game on the spot.
Act Three
Research in the city
Lower City: Sorcerous Sundries
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Gale asked me to find a book. Where do I start?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The city's best-known magic shop is the obvious place to ask.
Hint 2
At Sorcerous Sundries, ask Tolna, the bookseller, about Netherese crowns. She names the book, but it's locked away in the vault.
Missable If Tolna dies, her route is closed. The office lever and the tower button still work.
Hint 3
Talk Tolna into telling you how to reach the vault: the way in is through her office.
Solution
Tolna gives up the route on Persuasion DC 18 (DC 16 with advantage for Wizards on one branch), Intimidation DC 16 or 18, or Deception DC 18. In her office, pull the lever to light up a purple portal, and step through to the cellar. You can also skip Tolna: break into her office and pull the lever yourself, or use the button in Ramazith's Tower, which leads to the same cellar.
I'm in the cellar under Sorcerous Sundries. How do I reach the right vault? unverified
Hint 1
The doors teleport you, and most of them dump you back where you started. Read what's lying about first.
Hint 2
There's a note on Tolna's desk and a poem in the cellar. Between them they say which school of magic leads where, and that not everything here is visible.
Hint 3
Abjuration leads to the book you want. Go that way, use the plaque you find, and come back round.
Solution
From the hub: take the Silverhand door to the antechamber, then the Abjuration door to the west chamber. Use the plaque marked for Karsus there. Take the Wild or Demon door back to the hub, then open the Karsus Vault door. The Annals of Karsus are inside. (Evocation from the antechamber leads to the other vault instead; the Return doors always take you back to the hub.)
The door network is from the level data. Whether the vault doors stay locked until you use the plaques, whether there's a fire hazard on the way, and what exactly is invisible down there (See Invisibility should show it) aren't confirmed in play.
I have the book. Should I let Gale read it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Gale will ask for it once you're carrying it.
Hint 2
Give it to him, or let him read it. If someone else tries to read it in front of him, he steps in.
Outcomes
Let him read it
He learns what the crown is and how it was made, and the next part of his story begins.
Keep it from him
That thread ends there, and the endings where he takes the crown are closed off.
Missable If Gale never reads the book before the final battle, the endings tied to the crown are lost.
Act Three
A summons
Lower City: Stormshore Tabernacle
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Gale has been summoned to a temple. Where, and what should I say?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
After Gale reads the book, an old friend comes to find him, either outside Sorcerous Sundries or back at camp.
Hint 2
The message is from Mystra. Her statue is in the Stormshore Tabernacle in the Lower City.
Hint 3
Take Gale to the statue. Before he goes in, you can nudge his attitude. That nudge matters more than it looks.
Outcomes
Encourage him to seek her forgiveness
He promises Mystra the crown, receives her blessing, and at the end he will give it to her.
Encourage him to make her squirm
He leans further toward keeping the crown, and may challenge her outright.
Talk him out of going
Persuasion DC 30. The audience is lost.
Never go
The summons stays open until the endgame, then lapses.
Missable Steering him to seek forgiveness is the only way found that guarantees he gives the crown away at the end. Skip the audience, or block it, and that chance is gone.
Act Three
Gale's fate
The final battle
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
What decides what happens to Gale at the end? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Most of it is decided before the last fight, by what Gale read and who he spoke to in the city.
Hint 2
The book and the temple are the two that count. Without the book, the crown isn't on the table at all.
Hint 3
Gale starts the game leaning toward the crown. Unless something pulls him away from it, that's where he'll end up.
Outcomes
He promised Mystra the crown
He reforges it and gives it to her.
Still leaning toward it
He claims it and announces he'll become a god. Your answers only decide whether a partner goes with him or parts from him; no line changes his mind.
Neither
You can steer him toward Mystra, home to Waterdeep, or a celebration.
In a romance
If you accepted his earlier proposal at camp, you can go with him.
During the final fight
He can still detonate the orb against the final enemy, as a sacrifice.
Missable The crown endings need Gale to have read the book. The guaranteed hand-over to Mystra needs the temple audience. Do both before heading into the final battle.
His lean toward the crown is a hidden score that conversations nudge up or down. What exactly the end conversation offers when it has dropped low hasn't been checked in play.