Act 1 · 17 journal steps · starts around the Emerald Grove
The tiefling children in the Emerald Grove's refugee camp are more enterprising than they look. Follow the trail and you'll meet their leader, a girl who turns up again long after you've left the Grove.
Act One
The ring stall
Emerald Grove, tiefling refugee camp
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does this quest start?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Do some business with the tiefling boy selling rings in the refugee camp. Keep an eye on who else is standing nearby.
Hint 2
The boy, Mattis, has a partner. While you browse his wares, the girl beside him, Silfy, goes through your pockets.
Hint 3
When you close the trade window, you roll Perception (DC 10). Pass and you catch Silfy in the act. Fail and she robs you; a passive Perception check (DC 5) afterwards decides whether you notice your bag is lighter. Noticing starts the quest.
Missable If Silfy is caught, she never picks a pocket again. That's harmless if she hadn't robbed you yet, but the theft itself is the usual way into the quest, so if you want the full story, let it happen.
Solution
Trade with Mattis through his dialogue. If you fail the DC 10 Perception check, Silfy takes one random item from your bags worth 30 gold or more (never anything equipped or a story item), plus gold: all of it if you carry 21 to 35, exactly 35 if you carry more, none if you carry 20 or less. If you miss the theft completely, trade with Mattis again: if Silfy is caught on a later attempt and you go easy on her, she owns up to the earlier theft, which also starts the quest.
Walking into the gang's hideout for the first time also logs a journal step, even with nothing stolen. Whether that alone shows the quest in your journal isn't confirmed in play.
I caught a girl with her hand in my pocket. What now?
Hint 1
How you treat her travels fast. The rest of her gang will hear about it.
Hint 2
Silfy is a child working for someone older. An Insight check (DC 5) tells you she's genuinely upset.
Hint 3
Being kind to her, or impressed by her skill, wins over her whole gang. Grabbing her shakes loose what she's carrying, but her leader won't forgive it easily.
Outcomes
Go easy on her
Mol's gang treats you as a friend. If Silfy had robbed you earlier, she admits it, and later you get your things back without paying.
Send her away
Nothing special happens. She stops stealing from you.
Grab her
Athletics DC 15 (DC 10 if you read her mind first). On a success, everything she's carrying spills on the ground along with a few gold. Either way, Mol will confront you about it when you meet.
Is there anything to the ring seller's coin trick?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look closely at the ring he hands you. Does it look magical to you?
Hint 2
The whole act is a distraction. If you see through it in conversation, he gives up on you.
Hint 3
After a couple of coin flips, tell Mattis the markings on the ring mean nothing. When he tries a sad story instead, call it a con, name the con, and let him keep his ring.
Solution
Talk to Mattis and let him flip the coin twice. Tell him the runes on the ring are nonsense (Sorcerers and Rogues get their own lines for this). He switches to a hard-luck story: call it a scam, pick the option that names exactly which scam he's running, then tell him to take his ring back. The quest closes as a success, and he won't try anything on you again. There are also flourishes during the trick: a Rogue can make the ring vanish (Sleight of Hand DC 10, with advantage), anyone can try to copy the trick (Sleight of Hand DC 15), and a Bard can do it with Performance (DC 10). These count towards the Entertainer background's inspiration.
Outcomes
Call out the con
The quest ends at once, with nothing stolen. Mattis refuses to trade with you afterwards, but his stock is junk rings worth a few gold, so you lose nothing.
Keep his ring
He takes it badly and Mol will hear about it. If you later carry the ring unequipped, Silfy lifts it back.
Pocket the ring before the trick, then own up
He laughs it off, counts you as a friend, tells you where to find his boss and wanders off to the hideout. Urchins get background credit for this.
Give the ring back with an apology later
That also wins the gang over.
Missable Calling out the con closes the quest straight away, so you never meet Mol through it. You can still find her hideout and do business with her, for example the idol job.
Act One
Where did my things go?
Emerald Grove, tiefling refugee camp
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I've been robbed. Who has my things?
Hint 1
The two children at the ring stall know more than they let on. Ask each of them.
Hint 2
Silfy, the girl, works for someone. Mattis, the boy, knows where that someone can be found.
Hint 3
Tell Mattis you were robbed. He denies everything but points you at Mol, their leader, and the crack in the rock beside his stall. Or lean on Silfy: an Intimidation check (DC 10) gets Mol's name out of her before she runs.
Solution
Mattis tells you about Mol and her hideout entrance in one go. Silfy only gives you the name: Intimidation DC 10 (Barbarians roll with advantage), or DC 5 if you have the right kind of fearsome look, or a Rogue's Deception at DC 5. Otherwise she runs off to ask her boss. Your stolen goods and gold are now in a chest in the gang's hideout.
The crack by the stall is too small for me. How else do I get in? unverified
Hint 1
There's a bigger way in, but it's hidden, and a boy who doesn't speak is standing near it.
Hint 2
Find Doni, the boy who only grunts, a little way from the stall. Talk to him and pay attention to what he's doing.
Hint 3
Either turn your back on Doni and then look for where he went, or watch his miming and win him over, and he'll show you a hidden hatch into the hideout.
Solution
Small characters can squeeze through the crack beside Mattis's stall. Everyone else uses the hatch near Doni. Option 1: tell Doni you'll turn around; a passive Perception check (DC 10) lets you see him slip into the rocks, then Investigation (DC 10, Rangers and Rogues with advantage) finds the hatch and it opens. Option 2: on a later talk, Insight (DC 10) shows he's miming opening something; then Persuasion (DC 10), reading his mind, or offering him gold gets him to open it for you. Once anyone is inside, they can pull the rope switch to open the hatch for the rest of the party. The hatch can't be broken.
Not confirmed: whether shrinking (Enlarge/Reduce) or a small wild shape counts as small enough for the crack. Halflings and gnomes should fit.
Act One
Mol's hideout
Mol's hideout
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
A kid in the hideout is counting down at me. What happens if I stay? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Uninvited grown-ups aren't welcome. Treat the count as a real deadline.
Hint 2
Leave by the small exit or the hatch ladder before the count ends, and it resets. Coming back starts it again.
Hint 3
If you're still inside at the end, the kids grab what's in their stash and scatter, and the adults in the camp come after you for threatening children. Avoid that by being on friendly terms with the gang, or by getting your business with Mol done first.
Missable When the kids scatter, they take the stash with them, including the item Silfy stole from you. Leave before the count ends if you still want it back.
Solution
Mol only counts you down if her gang isn't friendly to you and you didn't arrive with a reason to be there. Committing any crime in the hideout other than theft also turns the kids against you instantly. If the count runs out, tiefling adults from the camp confront you. You can talk your way out with a Rogue's Intimidation (DC 15, Barbarians with advantage), Deception (DC 20), a Bard's Deception (DC 12), a Wizard's Performance (DC 12) or a Paladin's Persuasion (DC 15, not Oathbreakers). Bribes don't work. Fail and it's a fight or prison.
Not confirmed in play: whether you can still pickpocket or loot your item from the fleeing children, how long each beat of the count lasts, and whether the quest then stays open until the Grove changes or you leave the act.
Mol is angry with me before I've even asked for my things. Can I calm her down?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
She's heard something about how you've treated one of her kids.
Hint 2
Keeping Mattis's ring, grabbing or scaring Silfy, or letting someone hit another of her kids, Meli, all count against you. Apologising sincerely helps.
Hint 3
Persuasion (DC 15) or reading her mind, then an apology, settles it. A drow can threaten her instead. If the Persuasion fails, any good deed you've done for her gang buys you one more chance.
Outcomes
Talk her round
Things go back to normal and you can ask for your belongings.
Fail with no good deeds to your name
She turns on you: the kids flee with the stash and the quest ends badly.
Mock or threaten her
Same as failing: the gang turns hostile.
Missable Once the gang turns hostile, Mol's friendship is gone, and with it her warmer greetings in later acts. Good deeds that count: freeing Arabella, helping Meli, owning up to or returning Mattis's ring, going easy on Silfy, saving Mirkon from the harpies.
How do I get my belongings back from Mol? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Mol does have your things, and she's a businesswoman. How friendly her gang feels towards you changes the price.
Hint 2
If you've done her kids a kindness, she hands everything back for free. If not, she wants a fee.
Hint 3
Pay, argue, threaten, or go round her and help yourself from the gang's stash chest.
Solution
Ask Mol about your belongings. If her gang counts you as friends, she returns them free. Otherwise she names a fee: pay it, or try Persuasion (DC 15; a failure raises the fee by 20 and she asks again), or Intimidation (DC 15, Barbarians with advantage; a failure turns the gang hostile). Either way you get a Pickpocket's Bag with your item and the stolen gold. Picking it up ends the quest. You can also take your things from the stash chest yourself; it's theft from Mol, but it works if nobody's angry yet. If anything is missing from the chest when she hands the bag over, she adds a note, and if you'd paid, 50 gold to make up for it.
Outcomes
Already friends with the gang
Everything back, free, and you stay friends.
Pay the fee
Your goods back, and Mol now counts you as a friend.
Persuade her
Your goods back for free, and she counts you as a friend.
Intimidate her
On a success you get your goods but not her friendship. On a failure the gang turns hostile and flees with the stash.
Walk away
She keeps your things for now and lets you leave without trouble this time.
Get them back without being friends
She may teach you the gang's hand signal (Intelligence DC 5). Show it to Mattis or Silfy and they leave you alone.
Take them from the stash chest
Criminals get background credit for lifting from the stash unnoticed.
Missable A failed Intimidation turns the gang hostile: the kids run off with the stash, and Mol's friendship is lost for good. So does turning down her offer to join the gang when she hands your goods back. Save before you try to scare her.
The exact fee isn't confirmed. The script sets it to the total value of what was stolen, but also defines 40 and 50 gold amounts for the same conversation, and which one appears on the button hasn't been checked in play.
Is it worth staying on Mol's good side?
Hint 1
You haven't seen the last of her.
Hint 2
Mol turns up again later in your journey, and remembers how you treated her gang.
Hint 3
Befriend her by being kind to her kids, paying or persuading her over your goods, saving Mirkon, freeing Arabella, handing her the druids' idol, or putting money into her little guild.
Outcomes
Friends with the gang
Mol remembers it: what she says to you changes at your camp celebration, at the Last Light Inn checkpoint in Act 2, and in the Baldur's Gate guildhall in Act 3.
Invest in her guild
Only offered if she never robbed you. It makes her a friend; Urchins get background credit. No repayment later in the game was found.
Hostile
No fight with the children themselves: they flee, and the camp's adults deal with you.
The quest closed before I got my things back. Why?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This quest only lives as long as the Grove carries on as normal.
Hint 2
If things at the Grove change for the tiefling refugees, or you move on to Act 2, the quest closes unfinished.
Missable Get your belongings from Mol while the Grove is still calm. The stash chest stays put afterwards, so you may still be able to loot it, but Mol's help is gone.