Act 1 · 15 journal steps · starts around the Emerald Grove
A tiefling girl with a gang of pickpockets wants you to lift something from under the druids' noses. It's a small job with a long reach.
Act One
A job for the gang
Emerald Grove, Mol's hideout
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does this quest start?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The tiefling children in the Grove have a hideout of their own. Their leader is always on the lookout for help.
Hint 2
Find Mol in the kids' hideout, in the tiefling caves. Ask if there's anything you can do for her.
Missable Mol only offers the job while the druids' ritual is still running. If the druids have already been dealt with peacefully, or a fight with them has broken out, she has nothing for you. Visit her early.
Hint 3
She wants the wooden idol the druids are chanting around at the Sacred Pond. Agree to try, and the quest starts. If you already have the idol on you, the journal notes that too.
Outcomes
Agree
The quest starts. You can haggle for a cut of the eventual sale, but nothing later seems to come of it.
Refuse
Mol mocks you, and the job is off the table for good.
Missable Refusing closes the offer permanently: she won't ask again.
You can't get the job if Mol's gang is already hostile to you. Her reasons for wanting the idol change depending on what happened to Arabella.
Act One
Under the druids' noses
Emerald Grove, the Sacred Pond
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
The idol is surrounded by chanting druids. How do I get it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about when you take it, not just how. Right now the idol is the centre of a ritual the druids care about very much.
Hint 2
While the ritual runs, there's no quiet way to do this. Sneaking, invisibility or a distraction won't keep the druids from noticing it's gone.
Hint 3
Taking the idol now starts a battle across the whole Grove, druids against tieflings. Save first, and decide whose side you're on before you touch it.
Missable Taking the idol during the ritual turns every druid hostile, along with the pond's trader Arron and Nettie. Their conversations, trades and anything else they'd give you are lost. If you want them, wait until the ritual has stopped.
Hint 4
If you'd rather avoid that, wait. Once the ritual has stopped for some other reason, taking the idol is an ordinary theft.
Outcomes
Take it during the ritual
The druids notice within moments, and every druid and druid animal in the Grove turns hostile. Rath and his wolf fight with the tieflings unless you've attacked them. Wyll, if he isn't with you yet, fights for the tieflings too. The druids are wiped out if the tieflings win, and the pond turns poisonous afterwards.
Wait for the ritual to stop
The ritual stops if Kagha is exposed, or once the goblin camp's leaders are dead. After that, taking the idol starts no battle. See the next question.
That a completely unseen theft still starts the fight comes from a developer comment in the script, not from play. Losing the druids' other quests and trades is inferred from who joins the fight. What wiping out the druids means for Halsin later isn't checked here.
The ritual has stopped. Can I still take the idol?
Hint 1
Yes, and it's much safer now. It's still theft, though, so mind who's watching.
Hint 2
If a druid sees you go for it, you're stopped and warned. Back down and you're let off once. Try again and it's a fight.
Hint 3
If nobody sees, you get away with it at first, but the druids may come asking questions.
Solution
Take the idol out of sight of the druids. If you're questioned later, you can return it and apologise (it goes back to the pond, and you're watched from then on), bluff with Deception (DC 15), or threaten with Intimidation (DC 15; Barbarians roll with advantage). A failed check means a fight. Once you hold the idol with Mol's job accepted, the journal moves on.
Act One
Trouble in the Grove
Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
The Grove has turned into a battlefield. How do I get through it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Stay and fight. This one doesn't pause while you're away.
Missable Leaving the Grove or taking a long rest mid-battle hands the druids an automatic win. Every tiefling who was fighting or hiding in the prison dies (the children survive), and you can no longer give Mol the idol. Finish the fight in one go.
Hint 2
The fighting is split across the Grove: the tiefling cave entrance, the ramp down to the druids, the tiefling quarters where Kagha's group attacks, and the prison cave.
Hint 3
The non-fighters hide in the prison behind a locked door, and any druid who wins elsewhere heads there to break it down. Keep an eye on the prison.
Hint 4
It's over when every druid and druid animal is down. Zevlor (or Asharak, if Zevlor has fallen) comes to find you.
If the tieflings win, the next long rest heals all of them. Sazza, the goblin in the prison cage, is killed by the first refugee to reach the prison if she's still there. Karlach's moment with Dammon plays differently, and an unrecruited Shadowheart nearby runs off. Wyll joins through a different conversation after the fight.
Act One
Settling up with Mol
Emerald Grove, Mol's hideout
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I have the idol. How do I give it to Mol? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go back to Mol in the kids' hideout, with the idol on you.
Hint 2
The character who talks to Mol should carry the idol. Once it's missing from the pond, she'll ask about it.
Hint 3
Hand it over, keep it, or lie to her. The choice is yours, and Mol remembers it.
Missable Refusing, or lying successfully, closes the quest: you can't change your mind and give it to her later. If you want Mol on your side in Acts 2 and 3, hand it over.
Outcomes
Give it to her
Experience, and the gang counts you as a friend. She says she'll make it up to you in Baldur's Gate: in practice that means Mol can vouch for you at Last Light Inn in Act 2, and she greets you warmly in Act 3. There's no item reward. Urchins also get an inspiration for it.
Lie that you never took it, or lost it
Deception, DC 15. Success: she believes you, you keep the idol, and the quest closes. Failure: she calls you a liar, and you still choose between giving it and refusing.
Refuse outright
Experience, you keep the idol, and the gang no longer counts you as a friend. You lose her help in the later acts.
Steal it back afterwards
If you lift the idol off Mol after giving it to her, she grumbles about a thief and wishes she could recruit them.
Whether another party member's inventory, or camp storage, counts as having the idol for this conversation isn't confirmed. Have the talker carry it. Turning Mol's gang hostile also ends the quest.
There has been a battle in the Grove. Can I still give Mol the idol? unverified
Hint 1
Yes. Go straight to the hideout. Mol asks about it the first time you see her after the fight.
Hint 2
Ask once only. After that first visit she just tells you to clear off.
Hint 3
Here, refusing or lying doesn't close the quest. You can still give her the idol later at your camp's celebration, or during a goblin raid on the Grove.
Solution
Talk to Mol in the hideout straight after the battle and give her the idol. A lie here is Deception, DC 15. At the camp celebration the same lie is DC 14.
That a later handover at the camp celebration still works after refusing here, and that the quest then closes when you leave the region, aren't confirmed in play.
I put off giving Mol the idol. Is it too late? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Mol won't wait around forever. The handover is tied to the Grove as it is now.
Hint 2
If the tieflings move on, or the Grove changes for good, the chance goes with them. So does leaving this region.
Missable The handover is lost for good if the tieflings leave the Grove, the druids seal the Grove, the Grove is left with too few tieflings, or you leave the main Act 1 map (including heading on to Act 2). Give Mol the idol before you move on.
Hint 3
If you're celebrating at camp with the tieflings, look for Mol there: she can take the idol at the party.
Whether the journal still adds these closing entries after you've already given or kept the idol isn't confirmed.
Act One
Under siege
Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
The Grove is under attack and I still have the idol. What now?
Hint 1
Mol has more pressing worries for now. Deal with the raid first.
Hint 2
Once the raid's leaders are dead, or the Grove has held, find Mol at her spot during the attack and she'll take the idol.
Hint 3
If you've sided with the goblins, the deal with Mol is finished.
Outcomes
Defend the Grove and win
The journal notes the raid is over, and you can give Mol the idol (or refuse, or lie with Deception at DC 15).
Join the raiders
The quest closes for you. If you pick the idol up afterwards without having held it before, Gale can mention it at the raiders' celebration.
Idol still at the pond
When the raid begins, the idol is moved to a spot just inside the entrance to the druids' lair.