Acts 1–2 · 15 journal steps · starts around the Emerald Grove
A tiefling girl was caught stealing from the druids, and their leader is about to pass judgement. Her parents can't get past the guards. You probably can, and you'll need to choose your words with care.
Act One
Trouble at the inner gate
Emerald Grove, by the sacred pond
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
Head to the far end of the grove, where the stairs lead down past the sacred pond. Somebody there is making a lot of noise.
Hint 2
A tiefling couple, Locke and Komira, are arguing with the druid guards. Their daughter Arabella has been taken inside, and they can't follow.
Hint 3
Talk to Locke and Komira and offer to speak to the druids for them. If you skip them and walk into the druids' court anyway, the quest still starts there.
The druid guards won't let me through. How do I get in?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The guards are under orders, but not all of their orders are about keeping you out.
Hint 2
Stand your ground. Remind them who helped fight off the goblins, or start walking past. Another guard steps in before it comes to blows.
Hint 3
That third guard tells you their leader, Kagha, has asked to see you, and lets you through. No skill check is needed.
Solution
Push back in the conversation (take credit for the goblin fight, or move to walk past) and a third guard clears you to pass. Don't pick the option to attack the guards: that turns the whole grove's druids against you. Slipping past without permission counts as trespassing.
Missable Attacking the guards starts a fight with all the druids, and the trial is settled at once without you. Arabella does not survive it.
Is there another way into the druids' lair? unverified
Hint 1
The lair has a back door, though not an obvious one.
Hint 2
A tunnel near the goblin scouts' lookout posts leads to a hidden library at the back of the lair.
The tunnel and library are in the level scripts; that this is the route the developers meant, and whether you can use it at this point without trespassing, aren't confirmed in play.
Can I leave this for later?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The trial waits for you, but only while the grove stays as it is.
Hint 2
Anything that changes the grove's situation settles the trial straight away, with you nowhere near.
Missable If the grove's situation changes before you reach the court (a fight with the druids, all three goblin leaders dead, siding with the goblins, or the tieflings leaving), Arabella dies off-screen. That can't be undone.
Hint 3
Go straight to the court once you know about it. Don't finish off the goblin camp's leaders, side with the goblins, or start trouble with the druids first.
Act One
The trial
The druids' lair
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
What should I say to Kagha?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Saying nothing is a choice too, and a bad one. Watch the snake as much as the druid.
Hint 2
The opening questions don't change much. The real decision comes when Kagha gives her order: that's when a skill check can win the girl's release.
Hint 3
Persuasion or Nature at DC 12 works for most characters, and Druids do better. One failure isn't the end, but two are.
Solution
Your first round of questions just moves the scene on. When Kagha orders Arabella locked up, pass any one of these to free her:
- Persuasion (ask her to release the girl to you) or Nature (locking her up upsets nature's balance): DC 12. Tieflings face DC 18 for Persuasion and DC 15 for Nature.
- Druids: the same two arguments, or one quoting Silvanus, at DC 10 with advantage. A Druid who is also a Tiefling gets the Silvanus line at DC 15.
- Bard: Persuasion, DC 15. Monk: Persuasion, DC 10 with advantage. Lae'zel: Intimidation, DC 10.
- Paladin: Persuasion DC 10 lets you judge the case yourself. Choose mercy. Any form of locking her up, even briefly, gets her killed.
- A Druid who can speak with animals can ask Teela, the snake, to calm Kagha down. No roll needed. Other classes can try, but Teela won't listen.
- If you can read Kagha's mind, a success unlocks a plea for mercy with no roll. A failed read counts as a failed check.
If a check fails, see the next question.
Missable Arabella's life is decided here, once. She dies if you stay silent, fail two checks, take the attack options, give the Paladin verdict to lock her up, let Wyll back down, or (as the Dark Urge) give in to the urge to glance at the exit. Save before the trial.
Outcomes
She's freed
She runs back to her father. The tiefling thieves' hideout treats you as a friend, Gale is impressed, and she turns up again in Acts 2 and 3. It also keeps the 'no tiefling dies' achievement alive.
She dies
Her parents turn bitter, her later story never happens, and the 'no tiefling dies' achievement is lost.
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Not yet. Look closely at Teela.
Hint 2
After the first failure, an easy passive Nature check (DC 5) lets you notice the snake is about to strike.
Hint 3
If you notice, a new option appears: point out to Kagha that her snake is about to kill a child in front of her. It needs no roll and it works.
Solution
On the retry menu, take the no-roll option about Teela if it's there. Otherwise you also get Intimidation (she's stirring up the refugees) or Persuasion (let the girl spread word of Kagha's strength), each DC 10 with advantage; Tieflings take the Persuasion at DC 15. A second failure is fatal.
Missable A second failed check gets Arabella killed, for good.
The no-roll Teela option is read from the dialogue file, which jumps straight to her release; it hasn't been confirmed in play.
I'm a Barbarian. Is shouting at Kagha a good idea? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It can work, but it's the riskiest choice on the menu.
Hint 2
The Intimidation option is DC 15. If it fails, a hidden Wisdom save decides whether you keep your temper.
Missable Fail that hidden save and you lose your temper: the talk ends in a fight, and Arabella dies.
The hidden save is DC 10. It seems to be rolled at a disadvantage, and one version of the option seems tied to raging, but neither is confirmed.
Can I settle this by force? unverified
Hint 1
Once the conversation starts, you can't attack. And the snake is closer to the girl than you are.
Hint 2
What matters is who you hurt. Harming Teela settles things in Arabella's favour. Harming anyone else doesn't.
Outcomes
Hurt Teela before the talk starts
Arabella counts as freed, but the whole grove's druids turn on you.
Attack Kagha or anyone else
The trial ends, the druids fight you, and Teela kills Arabella.
Choose to attack from inside the conversation
Same as attacking Kagha: a druid fight, and Arabella dies.
From the trial's script. Not confirmed in play: whether an attack on Teela before the talk starts really saves her, and whether the in-conversation attack route kills her before the fight interrupts.
Is there anything else to do in the lair once the trial's over?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
That depends on how it went. If it went badly, Arabella may still have something to tell you.
Hint 2
Speak with Dead on her body works, and she knows where the tiefling thieves keep their stash.
Missable Her body is taken away once your whole party leaves the lair, so cast Speak with Dead before you go.
The trial's over. What do I tell Locke and Komira? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go back to the parents at the gate by the sacred pond. The guards won't stop you now.
Hint 2
If Arabella made it, she'll be with them. Talk to the family and Komira has something for you.
Missable Komira's Locket is handed over only in the reunion talk. If you've stolen it from her already, she gives you nothing.
Hint 3
If not, you can tell them the truth or not. Both close the quest with the same reward.
Outcomes
Arabella is with them
Locke thanks you, and Komira gives you her locket, an amulet that grants the Dancing Lights cantrip.
Tell them she died
They're devastated. The quest closes.
Lie, or say it's none of your business
Same reward, but they hold it against you in later greetings.
They see her body
They break down, and the journal records that they know.
If the grove's situation changes before you talk to the family, the reunion talk looks to be blocked, so the locket is probably lost unless you pickpocket it. Not confirmed in play.
The quest closed itself. What happened?
Hint 1
The grove moved on without you. The journal tidies up the ending.
Hint 2
This happens if the grove's situation changes before you report back, if one of the parents dies, if the tieflings are forced to leave, or if you move on to Act 2 with the quest still open.
Solution
Only the automatic ending where Arabella was saved gives the usual XP. The others close the quest with no reward, so report back in person if you can.