Act 1 · 11 journal steps · starts around the Emerald Grove
A grieving adventurer and a light-fingered tiefling boy both want the same cheap trinket. How you settle it decides who thanks you, and who remembers you.
Act One
A quarrel over a locket
Emerald Grove courtyard
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does this quest start? I can't find it in my journal. unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's tied to the adventurers who fight beside you at the Grove gate. One of them needs to make it inside alive.
Missable If Barth dies in the gate fight, none of this happens.
Hint 2
Once they're in, the half-elf Barth goes looking for a tiefling boy, Meli, who he's sure has his locket. Listen for raised voices in the courtyard near Auntie Ethel's stall.
Hint 3
The journal entry only appears after the argument, and only if Meli walks away with the locket while you haven't taken his side against Barth. If the argument ends any other way, there may be no entry at all.
What exactly sets the argument off (walking past, or time after Barth arrives) is in scripts we couldn't read. Talking to either of them beforehand gets you nothing useful.
Barth and the tiefling boy Meli are about to come to blows. What should I do?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You can take either side, stay out of it, or end it before it starts. Each one goes down differently with Mol's gang of tiefling children.
Hint 2
Standing back and watching is a choice too, and not a neutral one.
Missable Letting Barth hit Meli is remembered by Mol, and you can't undo it. It can turn her gang against you.
Hint 3
Backing Barth and then asking Meli why he took it gives the kindest result. Backing Meli and facing Barth down lets the boy keep it, but leaves Barth bitter.
Solution
Defending Meli: Persuasion DC 10 to shame Barth (not Paladins), Intimidation DC 10 to threaten him (Barbarians roll with advantage), Persuasion DC 10 for Tieflings, Intimidation DC 5 for Neutral or Good Paladins. Backing Barth: Persuasion DC 5 to ask Meli why he took it, Persuasion DC 5 for Tieflings, Intimidation DC 15 (Barbarians with advantage), Persuasion DC 15 with advantage for Monks. If Arabella has died, an extra Intimidation DC 5 line opens up.
Outcomes
Back Barth, then ask Meli why
Meli admits it reminded him of his late mother. Barth relents and lets him keep it. Both thank you, and the quest never enters your journal.
Back Barth and make Meli give it up
Barth gets his locket back and that's the end of it. Meli remembers you as the one who made him hand it over.
Defend Meli and win the check
Barth storms off and Meli leaves with the locket. Mol later counts it in your favour. Barth stays sour with you, and there's no journal entry unless you later get hold of the locket.
Defend Meli and fail
Barth hits the boy anyway, or Meli shouts for the guard. On one failed branch Barth takes the locket back by force.
Stay out of it
Barth hits Meli and takes the locket if the boy has it. Mol hears about it and holds it against you.
Hand Barth the locket yourself
If you already have it, you can end the whole thing on the spot. Barth thanks you, and the boy is impressed rather than angry.
Missable Urchins get one of two inspirations here: for facing Barth down on Meli's behalf, or for getting Meli to explain himself. Facing Barth down ends the argument, so you can only get one per playthrough.
Can I get the locket before the argument even starts? unverified
Hint 1
The argument has an option for when you're already holding the locket.
Hint 2
Light fingers might get it off Meli first.
The dialogue has a hand-it-over option if you hold the locket, and a branch where Meli no longer has it. Whether and when you can actually pickpocket it beforehand isn't confirmed. If Meli doesn't have it when Barth confronts him, the argument goes badly.
A tiefling guard has got involved. How do I calm things down?
Hint 1
The guard is Ikaron. He only joins if Meli shouts for help and he's close by.
Hint 2
Ikaron will listen to you, but you need to pass a check. Decide first whether you want Meli to keep the locket or give it back.
Hint 3
Failing the check, or telling Ikaron there's no locket at all, ends with Ikaron flattening Barth.
Solution
If Meli called for help: Persuasion DC 15 (or DC 10 as a Tiefling) gets Ikaron to let Meli go with the locket. Deception DC 15 (not for Oath of the Crown Paladins) or Intimidation DC 15 (Barbarians with advantage) makes Ikaron order Meli to return it; Oath of the Crown Paladins get that result without a roll. If Barth already hit Meli, Ikaron is angry at you both: Persuasion DC 15 (Crown Paladins with advantage; Tieflings get a DC 10 roll first) ends it with a warning.
Outcomes
Ikaron lets Meli go
Meli runs off with the locket and the quest starts.
Ikaron makes Meli return it
Barth gets the locket back on the spot.
You fail, or back the tiefling side outright
Ikaron knocks Barth out for a few seconds and Meli escapes with the locket. Barth comes to and wants a word with you. Claiming there's no locket, or saying your money's on the tiefling, also angers Barth, and then no journal entry appears.
You fail the Intimidation
Ikaron calls the tieflings to arms, and they turn on you for a while.
Act One
Following the locket
Emerald Grove, the tiefling children's hideout
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Meli got away with Barth's locket. Where did it go? unverified
Hint 1
Meli doesn't keep his loot on him for long. He belongs to Mol's gang.
Hint 2
He runs straight back to the gang's hideout and drops it in their stash.
Hint 3
Either pickpocket the locket from Meli before he gets there, or take it from the Thieves' Stash chest inside the hideout. The chest isn't locked, but taking from it counts as stealing from Mol.
If Meli was allowed to keep the locket, he probably still takes it to the stash, but that isn't confirmed. Even if you took Meli's side and the quest never started, picking the locket up later opens it, and you can still return it.
Act One
Settling up with Barth
Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I have the locket. What do I do with it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Talk to Barth with the locket in your pack.
Hint 2
Barth will offer a reward if you ask, and a sharp-tongued Rogue can talk it up. The locket itself is worthless to anyone else.
Hint 3
You can also ask Barth where the locket came from. The answer is a surprise, but it changes nothing.
Solution
Give it freely, and Barth still pays something if he can. Ask what it's worth and he offers 25 gold. A Rogue can try Persuasion DC 15 to get 50 gold, all he has; a failed roll falls back to 25. Reading his mind with Detect Thoughts opens a line that gets the 50 gold without a roll. Asking about the locket's history takes Persuasion DC 15 (or Detect Thoughts, then Persuasion DC 10).
Outcomes
Give it back, with or without the reward
Barth is grateful and the quest closes.
Keep it after hearing his offer
Barth turns hostile and you'll have to fight him. The quest closes without a return.
Fail a mind-read on Barth
Barth turns hostile.
Missable Keeping the locket loses Barth's reward and thanks for good.
If you've already stolen Barth's gold, the reward line seems to end in thanks only. Which companions react to the reward talk isn't confirmed.
The quest closed before I could finish it. What happened? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This quest only lives while the Grove is at peace, and while Barth is alive.
Hint 2
Big changes in the Grove close it. So does leaving Act 1 with it still open.
Missable Finish this before the Grove changes or you leave Act 1. After either, the locket can't be returned.
Hint 3
It ends if Barth is killed for good, if the Grove leaves its peaceful state (the gates lock down, the tieflings move on, or the Grove is attacked), or when you leave for Act 2.
Players who never met Barth may still see a closed entry when the Grove changes or Act 1 ends; that isn't confirmed.