You clawed your way out of Avernus with an infernal engine where your heart should be and hunters close behind. Your own story is about keeping that engine from burning you up, and settling an old score with the man who sent you there.
Act One
Out of the Hells
Nautiloid and the crash site
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does my story start? Do I need to do anything?
Hint 1
No. Your journal opens on its own on the nautiloid, and moves on once you reach solid ground after the crash.
Hint 2
There's no recruiting to do: the riverbank where a companion Karlach would hide is empty. None of the ways a companion Karlach can be lost apply to you either.
Act One
The hunters
Tollhouse on the Risen Road
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
There's a group on the Risen Road looking for me. What do I do about them? unverified
Hint 1
They've set up at the old tollhouse up the road. Their leader, Anders, will want a word when he sees you.
Hint 2
Whatever you say, this ends in a fight. The only question is how much you get out of Anders before it starts.
Hint 3
Listen closely to his story. If it doesn't add up, press him on who really sent him.
Hint 4
Once all three of them are permanently down, this part is done and your journal turns to the road ahead.
Solution
Passive Insight (DC 7) or passive Religion (DC 7) lets you see through his cover story. Then Intimidation (DC 7) or Persuasion (DC 7) makes him admit who he works for. Failing only skips the reveal. If you're in the tollhouse when the last of them falls, your temper gets the better of you and the place goes up in flames, with a few moments of your own thoughts either side.
Outcomes
Talk to Anders yourself
Always a fight. There's no siding with him and no promise to keep, so nothing here can cost you a companion.
Let someone else in the party hear his pitch first, with you out of range
He tells them about the devil he's hunting. Your journal notes it, but the party doesn't take on his hunt.
See also: Hunt the Devil, the tollhouse group's side of things
Whether another party member can actually hear Anders out before you're spotted, and whether "Hunt the Devil" then appears only once the fight starts, hasn't been checked in play.
Act One
A heart that burns
Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
My engine runs too hot. Can anyone fix it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Someone who works with unusual metal might know what's in your chest. Think about smiths.
Hint 2
There's a tiefling weaponsmith at the Emerald Grove. Go and talk to him.
Hint 3
Dammon recognises the engine the moment he sees you, and offers to work on it if you bring him infernal iron. That's what opens your heart quest.
Missable Dammon is the only one who can do this. If he dies, or the tieflings turn on you, your heart quest is over.
If you first meet Dammon in Act 2 or 3 instead, the heart quest still opens, but the main journal's note about it may never appear. Not checked in play.
Where's the iron, and why doesn't one piece fix me?
Hint 1
This plays the same as with a companion Karlach: same iron, same two stages, and Dammon leaves with the tieflings.
See also: Our Fiery Friend, where the iron is, and what each stage does
Soul coins make me feel something. What's going on?
Hint 1
Your engine has opinions about them. The first coin you pick up yourself gets a moment of your own.
Hint 2
Use them. After you've used ten soul coins, a new power wakes up.
Solution
Use ten soul coins as Karlach and you get a short scene alone with your thoughts, which unlocks the power. It has one Intimidation, Persuasion or Deception check (DC 14), but that only decides how smoothly you rein the heat back in. You get the power either way.
Act Two
Finding Dammon again
Last Light Inn
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Where did Dammon go?
Hint 1
Same as with a companion Karlach: he went where the tieflings went, and the rules for each stage haven't changed.
My engine is acting up at camp. Is something wrong?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's a dream of your own, not a conversation. It's telling you to get the work on your heart finished.
Hint 2
It can come once you've reached the creche or the Shadow-Cursed Lands. Dammon's second stage is the answer to it.
Missable Getting the second stage done before the dream plays means you won't see it. It's only a scene; nothing else depends on it.
What does the second stage need?
Hint 1
One more piece of infernal iron, as for a companion Karlach.
Hint 2
Afterwards you get a quiet moment to yourself, as soon as you're free to talk.
See also: Our Fiery Friend, what the second stage gives you, and what Dammon tells you
Act Two
A face from the past
Beneath Moonrise Towers
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
I recognised someone under Moonrise. What now?
Hint 1
Your journal takes note on its own; you're always there for that scene.
Hint 2
There's no companion to tell this time. Once the fight at Moonrise is over, you get a moment alone with what you saw.
Solution
It's Gortash, the man who sold you to the Hells. After the battle with Ketheric your own short scene plays, and from then on your journal is set on finding him.
Act Three
Dammon's new forge
Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where is Dammon in Baldur's Gate?
Hint 1
Same as with a companion Karlach: he has a smithy in the Lower City, and the same rules apply.
See also: Our Fiery Friend, finding his forge and the Act 3 iron
Act Three
Settling the score
Wyrm's Rock
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I get to Gortash?
Hint 1
Same as with a companion Karlach: he's about to be crowned, and the guards at Wyrm's Rock know where.
I'm face to face with Gortash at last. What happens? unverified
Hint 1
He knows exactly who you are, and you get your own words for him. Nobody has to talk you down this time.
Hint 2
The coronation runs as it would for anyone. You won't be dragged off to a cell, whatever you say.
Hint 3
He wants a private word afterwards, and again if you visit his office. What he says there depends on what you've done to his plans in the city.
Solution
After the coronation he keeps it short and points you at Orin. In his office his greeting changes if you've wrecked the Iron Throne or the Steel Watch, if you've come without Orin's stone, or if you've killed Orin and carry both stones. Insight (DC 15, offered twice) and a tadpole option to read his thoughts (a plain Intelligence roll) tell you more about what he's after, but don't change where the talk ends up.
Outcomes
Hand him the Netherstones
You agree to meet him beneath the city. That's the same deal with Gortash any party can make, but here it's you giving up your own grudge.
Refuse
The fight starts.
That the Insight and tadpole rolls don't affect the ending, and that handing over the stones plays out like the usual alliance with Gortash, are inferred from the scripts, not seen in play.
After the fight with Gortash, is there anything left for me to do? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Not quite. You have unfinished business with what's left of him.
Hint 2
Go to his body and loot it yourself, as Karlach. It has to be you.
Missable If someone else in the party loots him first, or his body is lost, your scene over it doesn't play. Have Karlach do the looting.
Outcomes
Your scene over the body
You find that revenge didn't fix anything. If the heart work isn't done, the journal points you back to Dammon.
Whether you still get the scene by looting him after a companion already has isn't confirmed, nor exactly when the journal moves on if nobody does.
Act Three
Last things
Before the final battle
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Is there anything left to do before the end?
Hint 1
Same as with a companion Karlach: your heart, and your old enemy.