A tiefling barbarian with a furnace where her heart should be, a price on her head and an old score to settle. Help her stay alive, and maybe find a way to let her get close to people again.
Act One
Meeting Karlach
Risen Road riverbank
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Where do I find Karlach?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Head along the Risen Road, towards Waukeen's Rest. Listen for someone who doesn't want to be found.
Hint 2
Karlach is waiting down by the river near the Risen Road. She's being hunted, and she'll assume you're one of the hunters.
Hint 3
Convince her you're not, and she'll join you. If you're not the party leader when you talk, or you walk away, she'll ask you to deal with her pursuers first and join later.
Solution
She can be met before or after you deal with the group at the tollhouse; the journal just notes which. Talk her down with Intimidation (DC 10) or Persuasion (DC 10). If your party has killed Dammon, the tiefling smith at the Emerald Grove, she accuses you of murder straight away: deny it with Deception (DC 15), or calm her with Persuasion (DC 10).
Outcomes
Reassure her
She joins you, or agrees to help and waits to be recruited.
Claim the bounty on her head, or lie badly
She turns on you and you fight her. The tollhouse group then wants her head instead.
Missable Turning her hostile here loses Karlach as a companion for good. Save before you talk to her.
What if she leaves or dies?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Her story ends if she dies for good, turns hostile, or leaves because she can't stand you any more.
Hint 2
Most of the ways to lose her are about loyalty: to her, and to the people she cares about.
Outcomes
Siding against her at the tollhouse
She leaves for good and turns hostile.
Leaving Act 1 with your promise about her hunters unkept
She leaves, unhappy with you.
Betraying the tieflings at the Emerald Grove
She leaves.
Low approval
She leaves, like any companion.
Throwing her out in Act 3
She leaves for good. See the Wyrm's Rock section.
Missable Every one of these is permanent: her companion quest and her heart quest both end.
Act One
The hunters
Tollhouse on the Risen Road
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Karlach wants me to deal with the people hunting her. Where are they?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
She points you at a group holed up nearby. Their side of the story is their own quest.
Hint 2
They're at the tollhouse up the road. Whatever they tell you, Karlach is watching what you do.
Hint 3
Once all three of them are permanently dealt with and Karlach is with you, this part is done and you're free to travel on with her.
Missable If you promised her, finish them before you head to the mountain pass or the Underdark exit into Act 2. Otherwise she leaves for good.
Outcomes
Deal with all three
Karlach is satisfied and her journal moves on to the long road ahead.
Side with their leader against her while she's in your party
She leaves for good and turns hostile.
Promise to deal with them, then leave Act 1 with them still alive
She leaves the party, angry. She does remind you before then.
Never recruit her and leave them be
She may take care of them herself, with fire.
See also: Hunt the Devil, the tollhouse group's side of things
Act One
A heart that burns
Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Karlach's engine runs too hot. Can anyone fix it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Ask her about it, at camp or on the road. She knows what she needs: someone who understands infernal machines.
Hint 2
Think of the smiths you've met. One of them works with unusual metal, and has more reason than most to know about devils.
Hint 3
Dammon, the tiefling weaponsmith at the Emerald Grove. Take Karlach to talk to him.
Missable Dammon is the only one who can do this. If he dies, or the tieflings turn on you, her heart quest is over.
Solution
Speak to Dammon with Karlach in the party. He recognises what's in her chest and offers to work on it if you bring him infernal iron.
Where do I find infernal iron? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It turns up where devils and their machines have been. Dammon can tell you if there's some in the area.
Hint 2
You may already have passed some on the ship you escaped from. In Act 1, look in places run by people with something to hide.
Hint 3
Act 1 has pieces in the goblin camp, the Zhentarim hideout, the Blighted Village and Grymforge.
Solution
Karlach needs two pieces in all, one for each stage of the work. Act 1: on the nautiloid's upper deck among the imps; in the goblin camp's shattered sanctum, in the throne room; near the back door and cells of the Zhentarim hideout; in the Blighted Village blacksmith's cellar, beside the masterwork forge; and from a duergar mason in Grymforge. Act 2: the Masons' Guild in Reithwin, and two in the Gauntlet of Shar. Act 3: a smugglers' weapons crate at the Grey Harbour docks, a dock warehouse basement by the sewer door, and inside the Iron Throne.
Missable The nautiloid piece is gone once you leave the ship. Dammon will also make armour out of infernal iron, one piece at a time. There's plenty to go round, but keep two for Karlach.
Whether the Grymforge piece can be picked up as loot, or only comes as the mason's gift, isn't confirmed.
I gave Dammon the iron. Why isn't she fixed?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
In Act 1 he can only do part of the job.
Hint 2
The first stage takes the edge off. For the rest, Dammon tells her to look him up again later.
Hint 3
When the tieflings leave the grove, he goes with them. Follow their trail into Act 2.
Missable Dammon has to survive the trip. If the tieflings are still in the grove when Act 2 begins, or don't make it to their next refuge, he's gone and the heart quest ends.
Outcomes
First stage done
Karlach gets Heart of Iron: Advantage on saves against being Charmed.
Let Karlach use soul coins herself. After she has used ten of them, she unlocks a new power and wants to talk about it.
Act Two
Finding Dammon again
Last Light Inn
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Where did Dammon go? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
He went wherever the tieflings went.
Hint 2
Look for him among the refugees at Last Light Inn, in the Shadow-Cursed Lands.
Missable If Dammon falls to the shadow curse at Last Light, he won't reach Baldur's Gate.
Hint 3
If Karlach hasn't had any work done yet, bring him a piece of iron now. After he works on her here, you'll need a long rest before he's ready for the next stage.
Solution
If he did the first stage in Act 1, he's ready for the second straight away. If he did it at Last Light, take a long rest and talk to him again. Act 2 iron: the Masons' Guild in Reithwin; in the Gauntlet of Shar, near the necromancer's research and the treasure-room door, and in a devil's lair.
Which tiefling rescue paths actually get Dammon to Last Light alive hasn't been checked in play.
What does the second stage need?
Hint 1
The same thing as the first.
Hint 2
One more piece of infernal iron. Hand it over with Karlach present.
Outcomes
Second stage done
Karlach gets Heart Ablaze: immune to being Charmed, and she can touch people without burning them. That opens up a lot of her romance.
And then
Dammon has to tell her the truth: the engine will still burn her out, unless she goes back to Avernus.
Act Two
A face from the past
Beneath Moonrise Towers
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Karlach is shaken after the meeting under Moonrise. Should I talk to her?
Hint 1
Yes. She recognised someone.
Hint 2
Have her with you for that scene, then talk to her in the party or at camp.
Hint 3
She'll tell you about the man who sold her to the Hells, and that she means to make him pay.
Solution
The man is Gortash. If she reads his letter in Ketheric's bedroom in Moonrise Towers, she has something to say about that too.
Act Three
Dammon's new forge
Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where is Dammon in Baldur's Gate?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
He's set up shop in the Lower City.
Hint 2
Look near the Lower City graveyard for a smithy with an infernal theme.
Hint 3
Bring Karlach and whatever iron you have. Same rules as before: one piece per stage, and a long rest between stages if he did the first one here.
Missable Finish both stages before you head into the final battle. Once you reach it, the heart quest closes for good.
Solution
Act 3 iron: a smugglers' weapons crate at the Grey Harbour docks; a dock warehouse basement next to the sewer door; and inside the Iron Throne.
Act Three
Settling the score
Wyrm's Rock
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I get to Gortash?
Hint 1
He's about to be made Archduke, and everyone in Wyrm's Crossing has heard.
Hint 2
The guards at Wyrm's Rock can tell you where the coronation is held. So can a certain devil you may already know.
At the coronation, Karlach can't hold back. What do I do? unverified
Hint 1
She's waited years for this. You'll get one chance to talk her round.
Hint 2
Give her a reason that matters to her: the guards, or why he might be worth more alive for now. Being close to her helps.
Solution
Persuasion (DC 18) calms her. If Duke Ravengard isn't in the room, Intimidation (DC 18) works too. If you're in a relationship with her, you can calm her without a roll. Wyll can help as well: playing as Wyll, or backing him up when he speaks.
Outcomes
Calm her
She holds back, and the talk with Gortash goes on.
Let her loose, or fail the roll
Either the fight starts there and then, or the Steel Watch drags her away to a cell under Wyrm's Rock.
Which way a failed roll goes depends on two unnamed flags. It looks tied to Duke Ravengard being present; not confirmed in play.
Karlach was taken away. Where is she? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Wyrm's Rock has a prison, and she's in it.
Hint 2
The keys are kept near the guards at the prison entrance. Or pick the lock.
Hint 3
Expect the guards to object when you open her cell. Then talk to her, and mean it.
Solution
Her cell door takes the prison key, or a DC 15 lockpick. Two keys sit by the guards' stools near the entrance. Reconcile with her and she rejoins you, or goes to camp if the party is full.
Outcomes
Make peace
She rejoins you.
Throw her out
She says she'll wait a little. You can still win her back until your whole party leaves the prison. After that, she goes after Gortash alone, and if he's still alive, he kills her.
Leave her locked in
She stays where she is until the end.
Missable Throwing her out, or leaving her in the cell, loses Karlach for good.
Whether the guards carry the keys or they just sit on the stools, and whether the cell fight always happens, aren't confirmed. Her dying to Gortash off-screen is from the script and hasn't been seen in play.
After the fight with Gortash, what does Karlach need?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Have her with you for the fight. Afterwards, she has unfinished business with what's left of him.
Hint 2
Go to his body with Karlach and loot it. She'll have her moment.
Missable If his body falls into a chasm, or Karlach is in camp or in prison, the scene over the body doesn't happen; you get a shorter talk later instead.
Outcomes
Her scene over the body
She learns that revenge didn't fix anything. If the heart work isn't done, the journal points you back to Dammon.
Act Three
Last things
Before the final battle
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Is there anything left to do for her before the end?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Two things: her heart, and her old enemy.
Hint 2
Both stages of Dammon's work, and Gortash dead. Her journal closes when you reach the final battle, and records how far you got.
Missable Anything unfinished when you reach the final battle stays unfinished.