Act 2 · 19 journal steps · starts around the Gauntlet of Shar
Raphael has a grudge against something lurking in the depths of the Gauntlet of Shar, and he'd like you to settle it for him. Whoever it is may have a few things to say about Raphael too.
Act Two
A familiar face at the graveyard
Reithwin graveyard
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
How does this quest start? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Keep an eye out for an old acquaintance near the mausoleum in Reithwin's graveyard.
Hint 2
Raphael waits there and talks to you when he spots you. His warning comes as a riddle, but you can press him for a straight answer.
Missable Raphael's graveyard talk, and with it his offer to read Astarion's scars, is gone once you enter the lair or if you attack him. Talk to him first if you want either.
Hint 3
If you skip him, the quest still starts once you reach the right part of the Gauntlet of Shar: follow the trail of blood to a lair full of bodies.
Solution
Talk to Raphael in the graveyard. A Persuasion check (DC 10) gets him to say plainly that an infernal creature is trapped below and he wants it dead. Insight (DC 10) after that gets him to admit it's personal. His advice: strike first and strike fast. If Astarion is with you, Raphael also offers to read Astarion's scars once the creature is dead.
Not confirmed: whether Raphael still turns up at the graveyard if you never met him at Last Light. The script sets the scene up either way.
Act Two
The lair
Gauntlet of Shar, the Chambers of Penance
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Something in the lair is luring me in. How do I avoid walking into a trap? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The creature you can see is bait. Watch where it runs.
Hint 2
A displacer beast, Nessa, leads you towards an ambush. Good Perception can spot what's waiting before it springs.
Hint 3
There are two Perception checks guarding the ambush: DC 15 on the lower approach and DC 10 on the upper one. Where you stand when the ambush fires matters too.
Solution
Approach on the lower floor. If you're standing on the upper floor when the ambush fires, there's no conversation at all: the devil, Yurgir, attacks at once. On the lower floor he stops to talk first, which is your only chance at a peaceful way through.
Missable Triggering the ambush from the upper floor skips the conversation with Yurgir, and with it every peaceful option. Come at it from below.
The DCs come from the trigger data (they point at the Act 1 table, despite their names) and haven't been seen in play.
The devil wants to talk. Do I have to fight him? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Let him talk. Ask what keeps him here.
Hint 2
Yurgir, an orthon, is bound by one of Raphael's contracts. It takes the form of a song, and its terms are worth listening to closely.
Hint 3
You can offer to do his job for him, or look for a loophole in the song's wording that gets him out of it another way.
Missable Any failed Persuasion check here starts the fight, and once combat starts there's no talking him down again. Save before you start arguing.
Hint 4
The song says no one who hears it may live. Ask yourself who else is listening.
Solution
Promise to help: Persuasion DC 16 (Rangers roll with advantage). He'll set you to finding the last name on his contract. Loophole: first notice the trick in the song. A Warlock spots it automatically, a Bard has a line of their own, anyone else needs a passive Insight of 14. Then argue it through: tell him to dismiss his followers (Persuasion DC 16, Bards with advantage) and he orders his eight merregons to kill themselves. If Nessa is part of the conversation, point out that she can hear too (DC 21, Rangers with advantage), and he kills her. Finally, tell him to die and come back free (DC 21, Barbarians with advantage). If Nessa wasn't part of the conversation, that last push is DC 30 instead (Barbarians and Bards with advantage). A Warlock with a fiend patron can skip straight from the loophole to the last step, at DC 21 with advantage.
Outcomes
Fight
Attacking, walking away, or failing any check starts the fight.
Promise to help
He holds back and gives you his search to finish. He warns that his friends will hunt you if you go back on it. A Paladin of Devotion breaks their oath by making this promise. If Astarion took Raphael's offer, he isn't pleased.
Talk him into his own death
His merregons, then possibly Nessa, then Yurgir himself die by his order. The quest ends there.
Missable A Paladin of Devotion who makes the promise breaks their oath.
That the DC 21 and DC 30 versions of the final push depend on whether Nessa is in the conversation is read from an engine flag whose line names her. Not confirmed in play, nor whether killing her beforehand forces the DC 30 line.
How do I beat Yurgir in a fight?
Hint 1
Raphael's advice is worth taking: hit hard, and hit first.
Hint 2
Yurgir starts invisible and fights at range, then wades into melee once he's hurt, once enough of his merregons fall, or after a few rounds.
Hint 3
Fire and poison are wasted on him, and he resists cold and non-magical weapons. Thin out his merregons, and keep your casters out of his reach later in the fight.
Solution
Yurgir has AC 14 and about 105 HP, and he's proficient in Dexterity, Constitution and Wisdom saves. He's immune to fire, poison, charm and burning, resists cold and non-magical bludgeoning, piercing and slashing, and has Magic Resistance and Devil's Sight. He opens invisible, laying clusters of mines. His second phase starts on his turn if he's below half HP, from round 4, or once four of his eight merregons are down. Below 20% HP he can explode once as a reaction, so don't crowd him. On the harder difficulty he gets Extra Attack and Alert, and in Honour mode a legendary action that tracks and blinds. Leaving combat resets him to his first phase.
See also: The Pale Elf, what killing him means for Astarion
Can I get Nessa, the displacer beast, on my side? unverified
Hint 1
Her loyalty isn't entirely natural. Think about what she's been fed.
Hint 2
She's kept docile with charmed spider meat. Clear the charm and she'll talk to you.
Solution
Remove her hidden charm (it counts as both a poison and a charm effect), then talk to her with Speak with Animals and pass a Persuasion check, DC 30. She'll then fight on your side against Yurgir. Yurgir's quartermaster merregon also trades, and after you probe its mind with an Intelligence check it can be asked for the charm potions, up to five.
That curing poison or charm removes her hidden status is inferred from its status groups, not seen in play.
There's a gem in the lair. Can I take it?
Hint 1
It belongs to Yurgir, for now.
Hint 2
Taking it while he still owns it is theft. Deal with him first, one way or another, and it's yours.
I promised to find Yurgir's last target. Where do I start? unverified
Hint 1
Yurgir, the orthon in the lair, tells you roughly where to look: close by, just below his chambers.
Hint 2
The dead in his lair know more than he does. So does an old ritual site nearby.
Hint 3
Pay attention to the local wildlife. Something about the rats here isn't right.
Solution
Any of three clues tells you who the target really is. Cast Speak with Dead on the heap of corpses in Yurgir's lair, ask what happened, then ask whether anyone got away. Or use the Broken Effigy in the ritual circle and pass a passive Arcana check (DC 14); the book beside it, One Becomes Many, only gives a hint. Or, with Speak with Animals, ask the envoy rat that comes to negotiate what kind of rat it is. The answer to all three: the last Dark Justiciar, Lyrthindor, survived by becoming the rats.
Not confirmed: whether the effigy's Arcana check fires when you walk past or only when you use it.
Act Two
A plague of rats
Gauntlet of Shar
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
The rats around here are acting oddly. What do they want? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Every rat you kill makes the rest more agitated. Kill enough and one of them comes to you.
Hint 2
The envoy rat wants to bargain. Speak with Animals helps a great deal here.
Missable The treasure is offered only with Speak with Animals, and only at the negotiation, before the rats turn hostile.
Hint 3
You can make peace, or keep killing. If you're working for Yurgir, the orthon, peace is not what his contract needs.
Solution
Kill three rats (or use the Broken Effigy in the ritual circle) and an envoy rat appears to negotiate. With Speak with Animals, ask what's in it for you: it offers the rats' hidden stash in exchange for their lives. Or just agree to a truce. Without the spell, an Animal Handling check (DC 21) reveals it wants peace, and holding up your hands seals the truce. The journal records the truce only if you've also found one of the clues: the ritual at the effigy, or the corpses' account in Yurgir's lair.
Outcomes
Truce, with the treasure
A map marker points to a loose brick in the Silent Library, which opens when you walk up to it. Inside: some gold and alchemy supplies. The rats leave you alone.
Truce, no treasure
The rats leave you alone.
Keep killing
They deliver an ultimatum, then turn hostile and attack in waves. What waits at the end is the only way to break Yurgir's contract.
Missable While a truce holds, the last Justiciar never shows, so you can't free Yurgir. His contract can then end only with his death or your leaving Act 2. If you want him free, don't take the truce.
Not confirmed: whether killing more rats after a truce restarts the escalation (the script suggests it does), and how the journal shows it if so.
I keep killing rats and more keep coming. When does it end?
Hint 1
There's a fixed number. The swarms that pour out of the holes don't count towards it.
Hint 2
Five waves come in all. Each new one arrives once enough of the current rats are dead.
Hint 3
After the final wave falls, the last Dark Justiciar, Lyrthindor, appears where the last rat died, and takes his own shape to fight.
Solution
There are 48 ultimatum rats in five waves of 12, 6, 6, 12 and 12. Waves arrive after roughly your 4th, 10th, 17th and 28th kills; Lyrthindor appears after the 48th. Pack rats from the five rat holes are just harassment. Lyrthindor has 112 HP and half plate, and casts with Wisdom. He can't be blinded, and once he drops below 60% HP he regains spell slots, so burst him down. He drops the Justiciar's Scimitar and Justiciar's Greatshield.
Act Two
Settling the contract
Gauntlet of Shar, the Chambers of Penance
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
The last Justiciar is dead. What now? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go back to Yurgir, the orthon in the lair. He'll already have noticed something has changed.
Hint 2
Tell him he's free. Someone else has an opinion about that.
Hint 3
Raphael shows up and argues that the deal broke when Yurgir handed the last kill to you. He doesn't let Yurgir go quietly.
Missable This ending needs Raphael. If Raphael can't come, for example because you attacked him, Yurgir just declares he'll go home in triumph and his contract isn't ended, so none of the Act 3 benefits follow.
Solution
Raphael binds Yurgir to a new contract and sends him to the House of Hope. Yurgir tells you to keep what he leaves behind, which frees the gem in his lair for you, then vanishes with his whole retinue. If you killed Lyrthindor before ever setting off the ambush, it never happens: walk in, ask Yurgir who he is, then tell him he's free.
The dialogue nodes and flags are confirmed. That this fallback line plays specifically when Raphael is absent is inferred.
Should I kill Yurgir or set him free? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about who you'd rather owe in Act 3.
Hint 2
Killing him gets you his loot and keeps Raphael happy. Freeing him makes a powerful friend.
Outcomes
Free him
Shadowheart's wound flares up afterwards. In Act 3 he may visit your camp one night (once you've heard Raphael's deal) and point you to a way into the House of Hope. There, he sides with you and Hope against Raphael, and can promise to fight for you at the very end. You never get his Hellfire Hand Crossbow, and Astarion loses Raphael's reading of his scars.
Kill him
He drops the Hellfire Hand Crossbow and Infernal Iron. If Astarion took Raphael's deal, Raphael visits camp one night to read the scars. At the House of Hope Yurgir isn't there to help you.
Talk him into suicide
He's gone, so no Act 3 ally.
Leave him be
Leaving Act 2 with him alive closes the quest unresolved. At the House of Hope he stays neutral to you and fights for Raphael.
Missable Yurgir's help in Act 3, his camp visit and his summon in the finale are lost for good if he dies or isn't freed before you leave Act 2. His crossbow is lost if you free him.
Not confirmed: whether a suicide still drops the crossbow and Infernal Iron, or counts as killing him for Astarion's scene. Also unchecked: whether, in the peaceful ending, his chest and the Infernal Iron can be looted, and whether that counts as theft.