Astarion is charming, vain and very good at keeping secrets. Keep him close, and his past will follow you both all the way to a palace in Baldur's Gate.
Act One
Meeting Astarion
Near the crash site
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
A stranger asked for help, then pulled a knife on me. What now?
Hint 1
It's a test of nerve more than a fight. You have several ways out of it.
Hint 2
Break free, talk him down, or let the scene play out. Any of these ends with the two of you talking, and he'll offer to join you.
Solution
A passive Perception check (DC 15) spots the trap before it springs, and Insight DC 10 (Bards have advantage) reads him. To break free: Strength DC 10 to stand, Dexterity DC 10 to roll away (Monks have advantage), Strength DC 15 to twist his knife arm, or a cantrip attack if you're a Wizard, Sorcerer or Warlock. Travelling alone, Persuasion DC 10 also works. Then accept him into the party or invite him to camp.
What if he dies or leaves?
Hint 1
His quest ends if he dies for good, turns on you, or walks out because of something you did.
Hint 2
Even if he's gone, his story doesn't quite let you go. In Act 3, the person hunting him will still want him.
Act One
Something's off about him
Camp and the Wilderness
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I keep finding dead boars. What's killing them?
Hint 1
Look closely at the bodies. What's missing?
Hint 2
They've been drained of blood. You'll find out by whom soon enough, at camp.
Something woke me in the night at camp. What should I do?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This is a conversation, not a fight, unless you make it one. Hear him out before you act.
Hint 2
Astarion is a vampire spawn, and he's hungry. The person he's leaning over is whoever last recruited or invited him.
Hint 3
Letting him drink is safe if you stop him in time, and refusing is fine too. Attacking him, or telling him to go, can lose him for good.
Missable Staking him or telling him to leave ends his story. Let him feed or refuse him if you want to keep him.
Solution
To stop him early, Persuasion DC 5. Later in the scene it takes Persuasion DC 15, or Strength DC 7 to push him off. Reading his mind through the parasite is free for a True Soul, otherwise Wisdom DC 10. If this night never happens, the secret comes out anyway: a companion forces the issue on the way into the Shadow-Cursed Lands, or it surfaces when you reach Rivington.
Outcomes
Let him feed
He approves, and he gets his bite attack. (He gets it anyway once his nature is known.)
Refuse, or send him off to sulk
He stays, a little put out.
Stake him
A melee attack roll. A hit kills him for good; some outcomes have him flee and leave the party instead.
Tell him to leave
He leaves for good.
He wants to talk about his past. Is it worth asking?
Hint 1
Yes. Talk to him at camp once his secret is out.
Hint 2
He'll tell you who made him what he is, what his life was like since, and why the parasite matters so much to him. You can also lay down rules about who he feeds on.
Act One
The monster hunter
Near the Riverside Teahouse
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
A monster hunter on the road is asking about someone. What do I tell him?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Whether Astarion is standing next to you changes the whole conversation.
Hint 2
The hunter is a Gur called Gandrel, and his quarry is Astarion.
Hint 3
Without Astarion, you can find out who he's after and decide whether to tell him where you camp. With Astarion, you can hand him over, fight, or let Astarion deal with it.
Missable Handing Astarion over loses him as a companion and ends this quest.
Solution
Persuasion DC 15 gets the name of his quarry (Wyll gets an easier DC 10 option), or Intimidation DC 20 (Barbarians have advantage). With Astarion present there's also a hidden Insight DC 5.
Outcomes
Hand Astarion over
Gandrel leaves with him, and he's lost as a companion for good. You'll only see him again in Act 3, in his master's hands.
Tell him where you camp
He'll come for Astarion within a couple of nights. See the next question.
Keep your camp to yourself
Nothing more comes of it for now.
Fight, or let Astarion kill him
The hunter dies, and the threat to your camp with him.
I told the hunter where we camp. Was that a mistake?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It can be, but you have a little time to fix it.
Hint 2
Warn Astarion, or deal with the hunter yourself, before you rest more than a couple of nights.
Missable If Gandrel is alive and Astarion hasn't been warned, he's taken for good.
Solution
Tell Astarion about the hunter in conversation, and when the hunter turns up at night he kills him instead. Killing Gandrel first also cancels the visit. Do neither, and within two camp nights the hunter takes Astarion away.
Who sent the hunter?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The hunter can still answer questions after he's dead.
Hint 2
Cast Speak with Dead on his body, with Astarion doing the talking. Astarion also has his own theory, if you ask him afterwards.
Missable Only Astarion gets the name of the hunter's employer from the corpse. Ask with someone else, and you won't learn it.
Act One
His scars
Camp
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How do I get a look at the marks on his back?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
He has to trust you a great deal first.
Hint 2
There are two ways: a romantic night with him after the celebration at the grove, or a camp scene once he likes you a lot and you know about his master.
Missable The camp scene for reading the scars is skipped once you've taken on Raphael's errand in Act 2, so see them before then if you can.
Hint 3
The marks are writing. Whether anyone in the party recognises the script changes what you know next.
Act Two
Seeking answers
Shadow-Cursed Lands
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Who can tell him what the marks mean?
Hint 1
The script is Infernal. Who do you know who reads it?
Hint 2
Raphael. Astarion will ask to see him one night at camp in the Shadow-Cursed Lands.
Hint 3
Raphael visits Last Light Inn to play lanceboard with Mol. Bring Astarion, and he can put his questions to the devil there.
Solution
At the lanceboard game, a passive Insight check (DC 14) helps, Sleight of Hand DC 10 lets you jostle the board, and Clerics get a Wisdom DC 14 option. If Raphael leaves the inn before Astarion asks, catch him later at the Reithwin graveyard.
Where else can I find Raphael, and what does he want? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Devils don't explain things for free.
Hint 2
He's at the entrance to the Thorm Mausoleum in the Reithwin graveyard. He'll trade the meaning of the scars for a kill.
Missable If Raphael leaves both the inn and the mausoleum before he's made the offer, and the orthon is already dead or freed, Astarion won't learn the ritual from him in Act 2. He learns it in Baldur's Gate instead, so his story carries on.
Hint 3
His target is the orthon held in the Gauntlet of Shar, below the mausoleum.
Solution
Persuasion DC 10 or Insight DC 10 presses him for more detail. If he leaves without making the offer, tell Astarion at camp that Raphael wants something killed; while the orthon still lives, Raphael visits camp at night to make the deal.
What Raphael needs at the mausoleum before he leaves (for example, Astarion in the party) isn't confirmed.
Do I have to do what Raphael asks?
Hint 1
Not for the quest to continue, but it's the price of Raphael's answer.
Hint 2
The orthon is Yurgir, in his lair in the Gauntlet of Shar.
Outcomes
Kill Yurgir
Raphael comes to camp one night afterwards and explains the ritual the scars belong to.
Break Yurgir's contract instead
Raphael won't pay. Astarion pieces the meaning together in Baldur's Gate.
He's uneasy about returning to the city. Should I talk to him?
Hint 1
Yes. Talk to him at the first camp on the road, or once you reach Rivington.
Hint 2
He wants to talk about Cazador and the other spawn under his control. That conversation points you toward what comes next.
The Gur in Rivington recognise him. How do I stop this turning ugly?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Their leader, Ulma, has a grievance, and it isn't really with Astarion.
Hint 2
The Gur want their stolen children back. If Astarion agrees to help find them, there's no need to fight.
Solution
A passive Religion check (DC 15, Minsc DC 10) tells you more about the Gur. Have Astarion promise to save the children for a peaceful result.
Outcomes
Astarion agrees to help
Peace. Saving the Gur children becomes part of the palace quest.
Refuse and fight
The Gur attack. Ulma can die here.
Side with Ulma against Astarion
Astarion turns on you, and his quest ends.
Missable Siding with Ulma loses Astarion for good.
Where can I find out what Cazador is planning?
Hint 1
Other spawn have been seen around Wyrm's Crossing.
Hint 2
Visit Fraygo's Flophouse with Astarion. Two of Cazador's spawn, Dalyria and Petras, are there.
Solution
Persuasion DC 15 holds Astarion back. Either way, they tell you where Cazador's ritual will take place.
Act Three
Visitors in the night
Lower City camp
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
We were attacked during a long rest in the Lower City. What do I do? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You don't have to fight. They're spawn like him, and they can be talked round.
Missable Joking about handing him over ends a romance with him, unless you take it back with Persuasion DC 18.
Missable This night only comes before you enter the palace. Go in first and it never happens.
Hint 2
Keep Astarion on his feet. If he goes down in the fight, one of them carries him off.
Hint 3
If they do take him, he wakes up alone in the palace kennel. Get him out of that room.
Solution
To turn them: Persuasion DC 15, Deception DC 15, Persuasion DC 18 or Intimidation DC 10. If you know what the ritual is for, Persuasion DC 20 warns them they'll be sacrificed. They flee rather than die when badly hurt.
Whether it always comes on the first long rest in a Lower City camp, or other camp nights can push it back, isn't confirmed.
Act Three
The palace
Cazador's palace, Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I get down to where Cazador is?
Hint 1
The sealed door upstairs wants two things: something from the family, and the right words.
Hint 2
The Szarr family ring is in Godey's kennel, which is hidden by an illusion. Light both braziers, or bring Astarion near. The words come from a heavy book in the bedrooms.
Hint 3
Past the ballroom, a dais takes you down to the dungeon. Talk to the prisoners in the cells, and look for a skull holding a scroll in the crypt.
Solution
Read the Kozakuran dictionary (the Heavy Book in the bedrooms), then press the Szarr Family Ring into the hollow in the ballroom door. The ring alone isn't enough. Investigation DC 15 shows the hollow fits a signet; History DC 25 only names the language. Downstairs, Astarion meets Sebastian in the cells and learns that Cazador's staff opens them (passive Perception DC 15 spots the runes on the prisoners). Vellioth's skull in the crypt gives up the Black Mass Scroll on every branch, so you can't lose it.
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look at the floor around Cazador. Each spawn stands on a pentagram, and every empty one makes him stronger.
Hint 2
Stand your own people on the pentagrams. That takes the power from him and gives it to you.
Hint 3
The runes on the floor are a countdown. Beat him before they all light, or he finishes the ritual himself.
Missable If the countdown finishes, Astarion dies.
Solution
Cazador has 208 HP and can't die in the fight: at 0 HP he flees as mist to his sarcophagus. Each of the seven pentagrams he holds adds 1d10 necrotic to his attacks, 1 m of movement and 10 temporary HP. A party member standing on one takes its charge instead; three are special (one heals 3d8 a turn, one gives a bonus action, one +5 AC). Bat swarms join at the start of rounds 3 and 6. Companion Astarion must pass a Constitution save (DC 20) or be pinned to the circle, and Cazador can pull him in mid-fight too. Killing any spawn once the ritual has started stops it from completing. If you arrive without Astarion, Persuasion DC 20 gets Cazador to send you to fetch him.
Missable Killing a ritual spawn after the ritual starts takes away Astarion's own chance to ascend later.
Outcomes
Cazador completes the ritual
He ascends: full health, stronger attacks, extra AC, Fireball and heavy regeneration. Astarion is sacrificed and lost for good.
Kill one of the ritual spawn
Cazador can no longer ascend, but neither can Astarion afterwards.
The round on which Cazador ascends isn't confirmed; the game lights three rune indicators, but what triggers them wasn't found.
The fight is over. What happens now?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This is Astarion's decision as much as yours. Talk to him.
Hint 2
He can finish Cazador's ritual himself, or kill Cazador and stay as he is.
Missable Deal with Cazador before you go to the final battle, or this whole ending is lost.
Solution
Talking him out of ascending takes Persuasion DC 18, or Insight DC 20 (advantage if you're partnered with him) followed by Persuasion DC 15.
Outcomes
Let him ascend
He completes the ritual and becomes the Vampire Ascendant. Every prisoner in the cells and every ritual spawn dies, the Gur children included. Paladins break their oath. Some companions won't like it.
Talk him down
He stays a spawn, kills Cazador, and you decide the prisoners' fate: free them into the Underdark (breaks the Oath of the Ancients), destroy them (breaks Devotion), or leave them locked away (breaks Vengeance).
Refuse to help, without talking him down
He kills Cazador as a spawn, leaves the prisoners to rot and walks out of the party for good.
Try to stop him by force
He turns hostile.
Astarion isn't with you
You can kill Cazador at the sarcophagus and decide the prisoners' fate yourself.
Never finish it
Heading into the final battle with Cazador alive closes the quest unfinished.
Missable If anyone completes the ritual, all the prisoners and the Gur children die. Talk him down if you want to save them.