Act 3 · 36 journal steps · starts around the Rivington
A priest is dead, a refugee has been blamed, and the city's investigator has closed the case. The temple's rector thinks she's wrong, and the trail starts right under her floor.
Act Three
A temple in mourning
Open Hand Temple, Rivington
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
Walk into the Open Hand Temple in Rivington and listen to the argument in the main hall.
Hint 2
The rector, Yannis, is arguing with Investigator Valeria about who killed Father Lorgan. Once Valeria storms off, offer Yannis your help.
Hint 3
If you turned Yannis down or walked off, talk to her again later and offer to clear the refugee's name. You can also stumble into the quest without her, by finding the crime scene first or by reading a certain list in the Lower City.
Who at the temple knows anything useful?
Hint 1
Talk to the staff, but get Yannis's blessing first. Without it, some of them won't answer an investigator's questions.
Hint 2
Sister Rose is in the infirmary with Father Lorgan's body. Ask her about his wounds.
Hint 3
Brother Donnick, in the kitchen, can tell you where both bodies are and where the attack really happened.
Solution
Rose: Lorgan's hand was cut off while he was alive, and there was a paralytic on the wound. Donnick: Lorgan lies in the infirmary, the refugee Brilgor was buried out back, and the attack happened in the cellar under the kitchen. The cellar hatch is right beside Donnick, and the cemetery key lies close by in the kitchen. Once Yannis has asked for your help, looting Lorgan's body no longer counts as theft.
Act Three
Asking the dead
Infirmary, cemetery and dormitory
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Can Father Lorgan tell me anything himself?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Being dead doesn't stop a good witness. Bring Speak with Dead, from the spell, a scroll or an amulet.
Hint 2
You only get five questions per corpse, so spend them on the murder: who, how, where, and what he was up to.
Missable Five questions per body, and no second chance. If you waste them, the same facts are still out there: Lorgan's diary, Brilgor's corpse, and Donnick for the cellar.
Hint 3
Ask who killed him, how he died, where he was attacked, and what he was doing (then why he was hiding Brilgor).
Where is Brilgor, and how do I get to him?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Donnick knows where they put him. Look out the back of the temple.
Hint 2
He's buried in the cemetery behind the temple. Its door is locked, and you'll need something to dig with.
Hint 3
Unlock the cemetery door, dig up his grave, open the coffin and cast Speak with Dead on him.
Solution
The cemetery door is DC 10, or use the key from Donnick's kitchen. A shovel lies near the grave. Good questions for Brilgor: who killed him, how he died, and where he died. Asking where he died opens a follow-up about finding the tunnels: ask it, and he tells you how the secret way in works, which also reveals what you need to find in the cellar.
Missable The tunnel answer needs two of his five questions (where he died, then how to find the tunnels). Ask those before you run out.
Is there anything in Father Lorgan's room? unverified
Hint 1
The priests sleep in a dormitory with a chest each. Lorgan's is the interesting one.
Hint 2
His chest is locked, and it's deeper than it looks.
Hint 3
Open it with someone observant. A false bottom hides his private confessions.
Solution
Lorgan's chest is DC 15, or use Lorgan's Chest Key. The first time each character opens it, they get a passive Investigation check (DC 10) to find the false bottom. If nobody spots it, smash the chest and the diary drops on the floor. Reading it explains what Lorgan was hiding and reveals the hidden switches in the cellar.
Where Lorgan's Chest Key is (on his body, on the key row by the staff chests, or both) isn't confirmed in play.
Act Three
The cellar wall
Temple cellar
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I'm in the cellar and it's just a cellar. Where did the attack happen? unverified
Hint 1
The walls here hide more than wine. Look closely at the decorations.
Hint 2
There are two heraldic signs on the same wall, quite far apart. They're hidden until you spot them, or until you learn the secret from Brilgor or Lorgan's diary.
Hint 3
Each sign slides aside to reveal a button. The wall only opens while both buttons are pressed.
Solution
Find the two Heraldic Signs (Perception DC 10 each, about 19 m apart along one wall; Brilgor's tunnel answer or Lorgan's diary reveals both). Use each sign to expose a button, then press both so both are on at the same time. The stone wall slides open. Turning either button off closes it again. A lever nearby also opens and closes the wall.
Which side of the wall the lever is on isn't confirmed; it may only be usable from the tunnels.
Act Three
Under the temple
Caves under the temple
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
There's someone in the caves. How do I handle them?
Hint 1
Hang back and listen before they see you. What they say is worth hearing.
Hint 2
They aren't what they seem, and they turn hostile the moment they spot you. There are three of them.
Hint 3
They're doppelgangers: quick, tough and hard to pin down with Dexterity saves. Open the fight on your terms and use spells that target other saves.
Solution
Zomm, Rudd and Muzz have about 52 HP each and fight as one group. Zomm carries a Thunderwave scroll and Rudd two Arrows of Detonation, so expect them to use those. Their idle chatter mentions a flophouse and who gets the best weapons. Mind the two gas traps further along the tunnels.
What should I take from the crime scene?
Hint 1
Whoever these were, they were looking for something the killer dropped. Search the ground near where they stood.
Hint 2
The murder weapon is tucked into a hollow a few metres from them. One of them is carrying a key.
Hint 3
Take the dagger and the key from the leader, Zomm. Read what the others carry too.
Solution
The dagger, Stillmaker, sits in a hidden hole (Perception DC 5). The Flowery Key is on Zomm. Muzz carries a field report about the killer's organisation, and the staged body nearby holds a note you'll want for the Lower City. If you came in without Yannis, once you hold the dagger and key and the three are dead, go upstairs and talk to someone at the temple.
They open onto the riverside, close to Fraygo's Flophouse.
The second cave mouth is in the level data; that it's meant as a way in, and when its boulders roll, isn't confirmed in play.
Act Three
Following the trail
Temple and caves
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I know it wasn't Brilgor. Who actually did it?
Hint 1
The dead have described the killer, but nobody has named him yet. Ask someone who worked with him.
Hint 2
Speak with Dead on Zomm, the doppelganger who carried the key. Ask whether he killed Lorgan, or what he was doing down there.
Hint 3
He names the killer: Dolor. A body in the flophouse can confirm it too.
I've got a key with flowers on it. Where does it go?
Hint 1
Ask its last owner. Being dead won't stop him answering.
Hint 2
Speak with Dead on Zomm and ask about the key. Or look around Rivington for a building decorated with the same flowers.
Hint 3
It's from Fraygo's Flophouse, next to the temple. The guests' room keys look just like it.
Solution
If you found the caves before talking to Yannis, take Yannis's request now: with the key in hand, the journal catches up. You can also report your findings to her. Once you've told her what the dead said, she just urges you to take it to Valeria.
Act Three
The room at the top
Fraygo's Flophouse
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I'm in the flophouse. Which room does the key open?
Hint 1
Go up. The room you want doesn't have an ordinary door.
Hint 2
On the top floor, a locked wardrobe is the real way in.
Hint 3
Use the Flowery Key on the wardrobe and you're taken through to the room beyond. Read everything in there, especially a bloodstained sheet of parchment.
Solution
The wardrobe and the room's door are both DC 25 and both open with the Flowery Key; unlocking one unlocks the other. Inside is the killer's lair: plans of the temple, torn orders, notes and a list of targets. That list is the evidence you need for Valeria.
There's blood by the bed. What happened here?
Hint 1
Look under the bed.
Hint 2
Investigation (DC 10) on the blood finds what's underneath. Rangers can use Survival (DC 7). Or just smash the bed.
Hint 3
It's a woman's body. Speak with Dead on her: she knows the killer better than anyone.
Solution
She's Ffion Goldgrind. Ask who her son is, what he looks like, and who he meant to kill next. She confirms the killer and his next target.
Valeria won't take me seriously. What does she need?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
She's drinking at Sharess' Caress. Get past her toast and she'll hear you out, but she's hard to impress.
Hint 2
Testimony from corpses doesn't count with her. She wants physical proof, and then a reason.
Hint 3
Show her the murder weapon, then give her a motive you can back up with something written down.
Solution
The toast is a Performance check (DC 15), but it's flavour only: answer it with a remark about the case to reach the evidence questions. Corpse testimony, Ffion's body and the doppelgangers are all dismissed. Show her Stillmaker, and when she asks why, say it was for Bhaal and point to the target list from the flophouse. Any other motive is rejected.
Missable The dagger only works as evidence while Dolor is alive. The target list works either way, so keep it.
Outcomes
Convince her
She accepts your case and sends you to Constable Devella at the Elfsong Tavern in the Lower City, which carries the hunt on. She also hands over her Lower City Pass, and the temple reopens its doors to refugees.
Dolor is already dead
Tell Yannis the Bhaalist did it and the temple reopens. Valeria will then only accept the target list as evidence.
Missable She hands over the Lower City Pass only if she still has it. It can be pickpocketed from her, and that loses it as a reward.
I never got round to Valeria. Can this still end another way?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Valeria doesn't stay at Sharess' Caress forever. Events in the Lower City can move her.
Hint 2
If you clash with the killer in the Lower City, she may end up somewhere far less pleasant, and need rescuing.
Hint 3
Keep her alive. If she dies for good, nobody can clear Brilgor's name.
Outcomes
Free her at the Murder Tribunal
Fighting Dolor in the Lower City sends Valeria to the Murder Tribunal. Free her there and she admits Brilgor was innocent, which closes the quest, as long as you learned about the murder at the temple. If she walks out afterwards, she can join you as an ally for the final battle.
She dies
The quest fails. That includes letting her be sacrificed at the Tribunal.
Leave it too long
If you start the final assault with the quest still open, it ends unresolved.
Missable Valeria's death fails the quest for good, and starting the final assault ends it unsolved. Clear Brilgor's name before either happens.