Acts 1–3 · 47 journal steps · starts around the Wilderness
A sulking portrait painter is being held for ransom by smugglers, and swears his patron in Baldur's Gate will make it worth your while. What you do for him now decides who you find when you reach the city.
Act One
The painter in the smugglers' den
The Zhentarim hideout
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Who is the painter in the Zhentarim hideout? unverified
Hint 1
Go deep into the Zhentarim hideout and look for a man standing by a pair of unfinished paintings.
Hint 2
Oskar Fevras is a portrait painter the Zhentarim are holding until someone pays for him. Talk to him. He wants you to buy his freedom, and promises his patron in Baldur's Gate will repay you many times over.
Hint 3
If you turned him down, keep talking: he gives you another chance to agree. If his captor Brem has already offered you a portrait, you can ask Oskar about that too.
If you've lost the Zhentarim's shipment and are walking into their trap, Oskar is too frightened to chat. Insight DC 10 reads his fear, and Persuasion DC 15 gets him to warn you (Brem must be alive). The hideout's entrance name isn't confirmed for this page.
Brem wants a fortune for the painter. How else can I get Oskar out? unverified
Hint 1
Talk to Brem, the Zhentarim who stands a few paces from Oskar. Money isn't the only thing he responds to.
Hint 2
You can haggle the price down, or talk Brem into letting Oskar go for nothing.
Hint 3
Brem asks 1000 gold. One haggle attempt can bring that to 600. A good enough threat or argument frees Oskar outright. Fighting your way through the hideout also works, at a cost.
Solution
Haggle (one try): Persuasion DC 15, or Intimidation DC 20 (Barbarians with advantage) drops the price from 1000 to 600. To free Oskar without paying: Persuasion DC 20 (people will come looking for him), or Intimidation DC 20 (threaten a fight; a Barbarian's roar has advantage). Githyanki get an Intimidation DC 15 line with advantage, and Rogues and Bards a Persuasion DC 15 line with advantage (a dead artist's work sells for more). By force: every Zhentarim in the hideout has to be killed.
Outcomes
Pay Brem
Oskar is freed. In Act 3, his patron remembers that you paid for him.
Talk Brem round
Brem lets him go, and you keep your gold.
Kill the Zhentarim
Oskar is freed, but the whole hideout turns on you, which also affects your dealings with the Zhentarim elsewhere.
A Paladin's Persuasion DC 15 line leads on to the DC 20 Intimidation roll; which DC really applies isn't confirmed. The knock-on effect of killing the Zhentarim is inferred.
I freed Oskar. Is there anything else to do with him here?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Talk to Oskar once he's free. It's worth hearing his whole story before he goes.
Hint 2
Ask about his patron. Learning her name, Lady Jannath, makes it easier to pick up his trail in Baldur's Gate later.
Hint 3
He asks you for 200 gold for the road. Paying is optional, though some of your companions like it. Then he leaves for the city by the hideout's ladder.
Missable If you bought him, you get the chance to call him your slave. Press it and he storms off and this part of the quest closes. He still makes it to the city, though, so his Act 3 story still happens.
If you free him and leave the region without talking to him, he still heads for the city. Entertainers get an inspiration when he sets off.
What if I don't free Oskar?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Nothing stops you walking away. But his story in Baldur's Gate needs him to leave the hideout alive.
Hint 2
If you leave the region without freeing him, the quest closes. If he dies, it closes too.
Missable The whole Act 3 haunting, with its rewards and Oskar's portrait of you, is lost unless Oskar leaves the hideout alive. Free him before you leave Act 1.
Outcomes
Leave him with the Zhentarim
In Act 3 he's a bitter forger in the Zhentarim Guildhall, selling a fake portrait. Selling that fake to the Guildhall traders sours them on you, and the painting turns out to be worthless. His patron, Lady Jannath, holds an art exhibition in his name instead. Tell her he's a Zhentarim criminal and she gives up on him, and gives you her engagement ring.
He dies
Lady Jannath holds the exhibition, and you can break the news to her.
Act Three
A troubled household
Lower City, the Jannath Estate
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where does Oskar's story pick up in Baldur's Gate?
Hint 1
Oskar mentioned a patron in the city. Look for her house in the Lower City.
Hint 2
The Jannath Estate. You'll know it when furniture comes flying out of the door. The butler, Tarhun, is standing outside.
Hint 3
Ask Tarhun whom his lady married, or say you have business with Oskar. He won't stop you going in. Inside, things get strange.
There's a fight upstairs. How do I end it without killing Oskar?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Oskar isn't the one throwing things at you. He can't even act.
Hint 2
Something has hold of Oskar, and three invisible poltergeists in the bedroom are doing the damage. Lady Jannath asks you to subdue him, not hurt him.
Missable Don't kill Oskar, and don't leave the fight while the poltergeists live: either way he dies, Lady Jannath turns on you if you killed him, and the rest of the quest is lost.
Hint 3
Kill all three poltergeists and Oskar drops unconscious on his own. Or knock him out with non-lethal attacks. Or break the hold on him with magic.
Solution
Any of these stops the haunting: kill the three poltergeists (40 HP, AC 12 each; they resist non-magical weapons and most elements, and are immune to cold, necrotic and poison, so use radiant, force or magic weapons); knock Oskar out with non-lethal attacks; or cast Dispel Evil and Good or Protection from Evil and Good on him. Dispelling gives you a short talk with him and the key to his chest before he collapses. Otherwise, take the key from his unconscious body.
Lady Jannath wants to talk. What now?
Hint 1
Hear Lady Jannath out once Oskar is down. She knows more about you than you'd expect.
Hint 2
She says Oskar changed after the wedding and shut himself away in his atelier. It's on the top floor. She'll pay you to find out what happened.
Act Three
The atelier
The atelier, Jannath Estate
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
The atelier is full of portraits. What am I looking for? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look closely at the easel covered in paint.
Hint 2
The easel has a hidden mechanism. It wants a particular painting.
Missable Each wrong portrait on the easel summons a spirit, and that painting flies back burning and can't be taken any more.
Hint 3
Of all the faces in the room, only one belongs to the man who painted them.
Solution
Take Oskar's self-portrait (it hangs a couple of metres from the paint-spattered easel) and drop it on the easel. A wall slides open on a hidden cubby. Any other portrait on the easel summons a hostile spirit, and that portrait is then lost. Other ways in: a contractor's invoice on a lower floor near Lady Jannath's strongbox reveals the wall, and so does good passive Perception (DC 12) inside the atelier. You can also smash the wall.
The wall also has a DC 20 lock with no key; whether it can actually be picked isn't confirmed.
I can't damage the painting in the hidden room. What do I do?
Hint 1
Stop hitting it. Every blow brings another spirit to fight you.
Hint 2
It can't be harmed by ordinary means. Whoever cursed it may know what can.
Hint 3
The locked chest in the atelier holds the clue you need.
How do I open the locked chest in the atelier?
Hint 1
Its owner has the key.
Hint 2
Oskar carries it. If you dispelled his possession he gave it to you; otherwise loot it from him while he's unconscious. The lock can also be picked (DC 20).
Hint 3
Inside is a letter from a spirit medium, Mystic Carrion. Show it to Lady Jannath and she tells you where he lives.
The letter doubles as your invitation into Carrion's house, Philgrave's Mansion. Reading it before the bedroom scene is fine; the journal catches up afterwards.
Act Three
The spirit medium
Philgrave's Mansion
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Mystic Carrion has what I need. How do I get it from him? unverified
Hint 1
Bring the letter, and ask Mystic Carrion about Oskar.
Hint 2
Carrion admits Oskar came to him, and has the means to undo what happened. He'll part with it for a favour, or for a price.
Hint 3
The thing you need is the Torch of Revocation. Pay for it, run his errand, or find his client chest and help yourself.
Outcomes
Pay
3000 gold buys the Torch. If you ask whether you can just pay, you can then ask Lady Jannath to chip in (Medicine, Deception or Persuasion DC 18; a Paladin's line is DC 15).
Run his errand
Bring back his missing servant Thrumbo's body, or the heart jar from it. That's his own quest. Intimidation DC 20 over the heart can also get Oskar's fee refunded.
Steal it
The Torch and Carrion's client records are in his client chest (lock DC 25). Its key lies a few steps from where Carrion stands. Take it first and he refuses to deal, but you already have what you came for.
Fight him
He can't be killed for good, but you can loot the chest key from near him.
It isn't confirmed whether Lady Jannath's contribution actually lowers the price or hands you gold; nothing reads the flag it sets.
Act Three
Laying the past to rest
The Jannath Estate
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I have the Torch. What do I do with it? unverified
Hint 1
Go back to the hidden room in the atelier.
Hint 2
Equip the Torch of Revocation and use the painting, or hit it with the Torch.
Hint 3
What's freed from the painting goes looking for Oskar. Follow it to the bedroom.
Not confirmed whether hitting the painting with the Torch summons a spirit before the curse breaks. Using it with the Torch equipped is the safe way.
Something is waiting in the bedroom. Do I have to fight it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
No. You can talk.
Hint 2
The spirit is Kerri, the woman Oskar loved before Lady Jannath. You'll need two good rolls in a row to talk her down.
Hint 3
First round DC 15: firm Intimidation or gentle Persuasion both work, and several classes get advantage. Second round DC 18: Deception, Intimidation or Persuasion. Answers without a roll at that point start the fight.
Solution
Round one (DC 15, one try): Intimidation with advantage for Druids, Rangers, Wild Magic Sorcerers and evil Clerics; plain Intimidation; plain Persuasion; or Persuasion with advantage for the kind approach or a Monk. Round two (DC 18): Deception (with advantage on one line), Intimidation (Barbarians with advantage), Persuasion (Monks with advantage), or a Paladin's line. Fail either and she attacks. Blaming Mystic Carrion just goes round in circles. If it comes to a fight: Kerri has 84 HP and AC 12, can possess one of your party (Charisma save DC 15), and changes form below two-thirds health. Two Vengeful Souls and two Tormented Souls (48 HP each) join her, all with ghost resistances.
Outcomes
Talk her down
Kerri leaves in peace.
Fight her
Five enemies. Oskar cowers and Lady Jannath is out cold throughout.
Let her take Oskar
She kills him and vanishes, and you get her ring, After Death Do Us Part.
Missable Kerri's ring only comes from letting her kill Oskar, which loses you his ending and his portrait. Running from the fight may also cost both Oskar's and Lady Jannath's lives.
The rule for running from the fight looks inverted in the script, so it isn't clear you can lose them that way.
How do I get the best ending for Oskar and Lady Jannath? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
How the bedroom ends, and whether Lady Jannath comes through it, decides what happens next.
Hint 2
Talking the spirit down peacefully, with Lady Jannath alive and nearby, lets the couple make up without your help.
Hint 3
If you fought, Lady Jannath is furious with Oskar. Speak up for him, and he stays. Then he heads to the atelier to paint you.
Missable Oskar's portrait of you needs Lady Jannath alive and the couple back together. A split gets you her ring instead; her death, the sketchbook.
Outcomes
Spirit talked down, Jannath alive
They reconcile. Go up to the atelier and Oskar paints your portrait.
Spirit fought, you vouch for Oskar
Jannath forgives him (a Bard's Performance song at DC 18 also works, but failing it splits them). Portrait follows.
Spirit fought, you side against him, stay out of it or ask for a fee
They split. Jannath gives you her ring, Till Death Do Us Part, and Oskar leaves after your next long rest, still owing you a portrait. The quest closes.
Jannath died
Oskar is broken, and gives you his sketchbook instead.
The portrait
You choose its title, which becomes the item's name: Portrait of an Adventurer, Mighty Defender of the Arts, Ghost Whisperer, Skald Supreme (Bards only), Hero of Baldur's Gate, or Untitled.
No item handover for the sketchbook was found in the scripts. It's also unclear what happens if the spirit was talked down but Lady Jannath isn't close enough to join the talk. Entertainers get an inspiration for saving Oskar.