Act 3 · 37 journal steps · starts around the Lower City
A spirit medium in a house with no front door wants a runaway servant brought home. The servant's friends know where he went, and each of them has an opinion about their old master.
Act Three
The house with no door
Lower City, by the City Beach
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
Philgrave's Mansion stands beside the City Beach waypoint. Its owner, a spirit medium called Mystic Carrion, is the one with the job.
Hint 2
Walk into Carrion's salon and he starts the conversation. Ask whether there's anything you can do for him, or, if you've read his letter to Oskar Fevras, how Oskar can be freed.
Hint 3
Mystic Carrion wants the body of a runaway servant, Thrumbo, brought back. Three other servants ran with him, and they're begging around the Lower City. The reward is an item of Carrion's choosing.
See also: Free the Artist, Free the Artist, which needs something Carrion owns
You can also stumble into the quest from the other end: finding Thrumbo, reading his hidden note in the mansion, or killing him all add it to your journal, even if you've never met Carrion.
There's no way into the mansion from the street. How do I get in? unverified
Hint 1
Look closely at the blank wall as you walk past. Not every wall is a wall.
Hint 2
A Perception check (DC 10) reveals a hidden door. It's magical, and it wants a password. Mystic Carrion wrote that password down for his clients.
Hint 3
Read one of Carrion's letters. One is in a locked chest in Oskar's atelier at the Jannath Estate; two more lie on burned corpses near the Guildhall hatch, close to the abandoned Beach House. Then speak the password at the door.
Solution
Carry the letter from Oskar's atelier and the door shows itself without a roll. Once any copy of the letter has been read, the password is offered as a choice at the door; the wrong guesses do nothing. Without a letter, a passive Arcana check (DC 15) only tells you the door is magical. You can also break the door, or use the lever about two metres from it. Upstairs, a different entrance is watched by a ghast doorman: the atelier letter gets you waved through, or pass Deception, Intimidation or Persuasion (DC 15). Fail, or attack, and the upper floor turns hostile.
Not confirmed whether the door lever can be reached from the street or only from inside the salon. Only the atelier letter works on the ghast; the two copies by the Guildhall only give you the password.
Mystic Carrion offered me a séance. Is that part of this?
Hint 1
Not this quest. It only comes up if you're carrying a certain book from Act 1.
Hint 2
If you have the Necromancy of Thay, Carrion will hold a séance about it for 1500 gold (1000 with the right line). It points you to where the book can be opened.
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Mystic Carrion's own house has a clue. The runaways left something behind upstairs.
Hint 2
A portrait on the upper floor, near one of the doors, hides a note from Thrumbo. Getting it out takes an Arcana check (DC 15).
Missable Failing the Arcana check at the portrait fills the area with magical darkness. Everyone within 9 m makes a Wisdom save (DC 10) and takes 4–32 psychic damage on a success, 8–64 on a failure. Move the rest of the party away before you try.
Hint 3
The note says the runaways planned to meet at the beach and leave by boat. The other route is to question the three runaways, who are begging around the Lower City.
Thrumbo's friends won't tell me anything. How do I get them talking? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
There are three of them, and each has a lead. They don't look like zombies at first glance; an Insight check (DC 15) sees through them.
Hint 2
Morbus is by the Lower City graveyard, playing hide and seek with a child. Sacrum begs near the Blood Merchant and the Beehive general store. Lumbar takes punches for coin near Heapside Barracks and the Stormshore Tabernacle.
Hint 3
Each one needs persuading, deceiving or scaring. Morbus is the easiest and Lumbar the hardest, and Lumbar only gives you one try.
Missable Fail Lumbar's DC 18 check and he never talks to you again. The other two runaways still know enough, so it's his lead you lose, not the quest.
Solution
Morbus: Persuasion DC 10, Deception DC 10 or Intimidation DC 7; Paladins and Bards get lines with advantage. Sacrum: Persuasion, Deception or Intimidation DC 15 (some classes get advantage), or bribe him. Lumbar: a thug is roughing him up when you arrive. Persuasion, Deception or Intimidation at DC 18. You only need one of the three leads; any of them points you at Thrumbo's hiding place.
The gold Sacrum wants as a bribe isn't confirmed (the data has more than one figure). That any single lead is enough to find Thrumbo is inferred: finding him has no other requirement.
Where is Thrumbo hiding?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The runaways meant to leave by sea. Search near the City Beach.
Hint 2
There's an abandoned house on the beach, the Beach House, next to the Guildhall entrance. Search the furniture.
Hint 3
Thrumbo is in a wardrobe there. Open it or break it, and once he's calmed down, let him talk. What he says about Mystic Carrion is worth hearing out.
Outcomes
Hear Thrumbo out and promise to help
He tells you how he and his friends ended up as Carrion's servants, and that Carrion can't be killed the ordinary way. He points you to a chamber under Carrion's salon, which starts End Mystic Carrion's Immortality.
Kill Thrumbo
You can carry his body to Carrion for the reward. The other three runaways, and the people around them, vanish from the city for good.
Missable Killing Thrumbo yourself permanently removes the other runaways and closes off the ending where they take over the mansion, along with the Crypt Lord Ring Thrumbo would give you. Hear him out before deciding.
Act Three
Settling up with Carrion
Philgrave's Mansion
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've found Thrumbo. What are my options with Mystic Carrion?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You don't have to do what you were hired to do. Think about what Thrumbo told you, and what Mystic Carrion actually wants.
Hint 2
Carrion cares less about Thrumbo than about something Thrumbo carries. Thrumbo's story, and a lair under the city, explain what.
Hint 3
You can deliver the body, deliver only what's inside it, or turn on Carrion. If you're here for Oskar, you can also just buy the Torch of Revocation for 3000 gold.
Outcomes
Hand over Thrumbo's body, heart and all
Carrion pays you with the Torch of Revocation. If you've already taken the Torch from his client chest, he notices and pays nothing.
Hand over the body after taking the heart out
Carrion sees through it and the fight starts.
Hand over the heart jar on its own
Carrion accepts it as payment. Push for more with Intimidation or Persuasion (DC 20) and you get the Torch plus 500 gold, or Oskar's fee back if you bought the Torch. Fail and he turns hostile.
Give the heart back after Thrumbo has given it up to you
Thrumbo finds out, flees for good, and all the runaways leave the city. Carrion keeps the heart in his basement.
Tell Carrion you let Thrumbo go, or that you've had a change of heart
He attacks. Every way of saying it leads to a fight.
Steal the Torch
It's in Carrion's locked client chest. Carrion carries the key.
Missable Taking the Torch from the chest before handing over the body costs you the reward, though you keep the Torch.
Missable Handing the heart back to Carrion after Thrumbo has trusted you with it loses Thrumbo, the other runaways, and the Crypt Lord Ring for good.
See also: Free the Artist, Free the Artist: why you might want the Torch
A Charlatan who takes the job and later turns on Carrion completes a background goal. The journal has an entry for the bonus payment, but nothing in this build shows it.
Act Three
What lies beneath the salon
Under Philgrave's Mansion and the sewers
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Thrumbo told me to look under the salon. How do I get down there?
Hint 1
Look at the floor of Mystic Carrion's salon, not the walls.
Hint 2
There's a hatch in the salon floor. It belongs to Mystic Carrion. Small creatures can also get in through holes in the walls.
Hint 3
Read the gilded book in the basement. It tells you Carrion once lived in an older lair under the city.
Casting Speak with Dead on a dead adventurer, Taron, in the older lair gives you the same lead as the book.
Where is the old lair? unverified
Hint 1
It's in the sewers.
Hint 2
Head for the Undercity Ruins waypoint. The lair's entrance is hidden beside it.
Hint 3
The entrance is an invisible door near the waypoint; search the walls around it. An escape door from the lair comes out nearby.
The entrance is placed next to the waypoint, but whether it needs a Perception check to spot isn't confirmed.
The old lair feels like a trap. What should I watch out for? unverified
Hint 1
The dead in here are only resting. Be careful what you touch.
Hint 2
Using, moving, looting or picking up anything in the lair, or attacking or casting at anything in it, raises the alarm. Undead party members, Astarion included, get a Wisdom save (DC 20) instead of setting it off outright.
Hint 3
When the alarm goes, the entrance locks, the guardians rise, and the lair is cursed: every spell you cast there hurts you.
Solution
The guardians are 5 mummies, 3 greater zombies and 9 crawling claws. The curse deals 2d6 necrotic per spell level to whoever casts a spell inside it (3d6 on Tactician, which also gives you disadvantage on all saving throws). Undead are exempt. Removing the curse with a party member's ability buys a few turns before it comes back. Fight with weapons, or send an undead character in to loot. The workshop is behind a stone door that needs the lair key; Mystic Carrion carries one.
That the guardians lie as corpses until the alarm, and that the curse returns after about three turns, are read from the script, not seen in play. A second copy of the key may lie by the workshop door. Whether that door can be picked is unknown.
What are these jars, and how many are there? unverified
Hint 1
Look for a stone tablet in the lair's workshop. It explains the jars better than we can without spoiling it.
Hint 2
There are four canopic jars, one for each of Mystic Carrion's preserved organs. Each one gives him a protection while it survives.
Hint 3
Two jars, the liver and the brain, are in the lair's workshop. The lungs are in the Mortuary basement by the Lower City graveyard. The tablet tells you where Carrion likes to hide the fourth.
Solution
Heart: he rises again after he's killed. Liver: while it's intact he isn't hurt more by fire; break it and he becomes vulnerable to fire. Brain: +3 to his spell save DC, and he can't be surprised. Lungs: he can't be silenced. Breaking a jar strips that protection.
Not confirmed whether the liver and brain jars sit loose in the workshop or in the chest there.
I can't find the last jar. Where is it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Read the tablet in the lair's workshop. Mystic Carrion hides his jars inside things that walk.
Hint 2
Think about which servant Carrion wanted back so badly.
Hint 3
The heart jar is inside Thrumbo. You can't pickpocket it.
Solution
Once you've read the tablet, tell Thrumbo what's inside him and he brings the jar up by himself. Killing him and looting it also works, but that costs you the other runaways and the ending where they take over the mansion.
Missable Killing Thrumbo for the heart permanently removes the other runaways, and with them the Crypt Lord Ring. Talking it out of him costs nothing.
How do I destroy the jars? unverified
Hint 1
Hitting them doesn't work. Think about what mummies fear.
Hint 2
Fire. The jars shrug off almost everything else, and anything that isn't fire bites back for a little necrotic damage.
Hint 3
Don't stand next to a jar when it breaks.
Solution
Burn the jar after putting it down somewhere away from the party, or throw it first. A destroyed jar explodes like a level-5 Fireball where it stood. Breaking the first jar turns all of Mystic Carrion's household hostile. The heart is the one that matters: with it gone, Carrion dies for good the next time he falls, and if he's already dead, breaking it finishes him.
How hard the explosion hits in practice hasn't been checked.
Act Three
Facing Mystic Carrion
Philgrave's Mansion
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I beat Mystic Carrion?
Hint 1
Count the coffins in the salon before you start anything.
Hint 2
Seven coffins line the salon, each with a mummy inside, and they all come out when the fight begins. Ghouls and ghasts join in too.
Hint 3
Mystic Carrion ignores ordinary weapons. Use magic weapons or spells, and break his jars first to strip his protections.
Solution
Carrion has 143 HP and AC 17. He's immune to non-magical bludgeoning, piercing and slashing, to necrotic and poison, and can't be charmed, frightened, poisoned or paralysed. He has Magic Resistance and resists turning. Destroy the liver jar and fire becomes your best weapon. On Honour mode he also has a legendary action that calls up spirits. Opening or breaking a coffin releases its mummy.
I've killed Mystic Carrion. Is it over? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Ask yourself where his heart is.
Hint 2
If the heart jar is still in one piece, Carrion won't stay down.
Hint 3
Destroy the heart jar before your next long rest. With the heart gone, he's dead for good.
Missable If you kill Carrion while the heart is still inside Thrumbo and then long rest, Thrumbo and all the runaways die. That loses their takeover of the mansion and the Crypt Lord Ring. Get the heart out first, or destroy it before you rest.
Outcomes
Heart already destroyed, or destroyed while he's dead
Mystic Carrion is finished for good.
Long rest while you carry the heart
He rises fully healed in his salon, takes the heart back to his basement, and leaves a threatening note in your pack.
Long rest while the heart is still in Thrumbo
Carrion rises and kills Thrumbo at the Beach House, then the other runaways, whose bodies end up in his basement. He boasts about it when you meet him again.
After he rises, the heart should be in his basement; that it reliably appears there, and can be broken without another fight, isn't confirmed. A Haunted One completes a background goal when Carrion is gone for good.
What happens to the mansion once Mystic Carrion is gone?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It depends on how you treated Thrumbo.
Hint 2
If Thrumbo is alive and you never betrayed him, the runaways move into the mansion. The undead staff stop fighting you and the street door is left open.
Missable The Crypt Lord Ring only exists if Thrumbo survives to the takeover. Losing him first, by killing him, betraying him, or letting Carrion rise while the heart is in him, loses the ring for good.
Hint 3
Talk to Thrumbo there. He takes over the shop, and gives you a gift.
Outcomes
Thrumbo alive and not betrayed
Thrumbo trades from the mansion and gives you the Crypt Lord Ring, which grants Create Undead.