Act 3 · 12 journal steps · starts around the Wyrm's Rock
The postmaster in Wyrm's Crossing is losing pigeons, and the letters they carry. He wants one of them back very badly, and he's more nervous about it than a few lost birds would explain.
Act Three
A nervous postmaster
Sword Coast Couriers post house, Wyrm's Crossing
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Visit the post house in Wyrm's Crossing and chat with the postmaster, Danzo. He's putting on a brave face.
Missable The quest can be switched off before you arrive. If the creature behind it died for good in an earlier act, Danzo never mentions missing letters and there's nothing to find.
Hint 2
Don't let Danzo stop at the sales pitch. Ask about the shop's motto, tell him to drop the act, or ask why he's so cheerful, and he'll admit his pigeons and their letters keep going missing.
Hint 3
If you picked up a letter from a dead courier in the Act 1 forest, hand it to Danzo. It belonged to one of his couriers, and it gets him talking about the missing letters too.
Danzo seems worried about more than pigeons. Can I get more out of him?
Hint 1
Watch Danzo's face when he talks about the birds. A good passive Insight notices something.
Hint 2
If you spot it, you can ask Danzo to level with you. He admits one of the missing letters is his own private post.
Hint 3
On that branch only, you can ask for expenses up front.
Solution
Passive Insight DC 15 unlocks the 'level with me' option. After that, a Persuasion check (DC 18) for money up front gets you a small sum before you start. If you fail, Danzo refuses the advance but still gives you the job. Either way he wants the letters back unopened.
Act Three
Following the feathers
Post house roof and coop
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where have the pigeons gone? unverified
Hint 1
Whatever is taking the birds isn't doing it politely. Look up, not around the counter.
Hint 2
There's a trail on the post house roof. Walk along it and your party will pick it up.
Hint 3
The trail is dragged west, towards the Open Hand Temple. Follow it across to the temple roof.
Solution
Walk over the blood on the post house roof. A passive Nature check (DC 7) at one end and a passive Investigation check (DC 7) at the other confirm the trail and add the journal entry. It leads west to the Open Hand Temple roof.
The scripts don't show the climbing route up to the post house roof or across to the temple roof. Whether crossing the trail before talking to Danzo opens the journal on its own is also unconfirmed.
Can the surviving pigeons tell me anything?
Hint 1
You'll need a way to talk to animals.
Hint 2
With Speak with Animals, go up to the coop and talk to the bird who's clearly in charge, Commander Lightfeather. He treats you like a new recruit.
Hint 3
Ask Commander Lightfeather about his missing officers, or argue with him about being only a pigeon. He points you west, to the roof with the big stone hand, and warns of a lookout in the bell tower.
This is optional. It gives XP and the same direction as the blood trail.
Act Three
The culprit
Open Hand Temple roof
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've found who's been eating the pigeons. Now what? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's not a monster, exactly. Look closely before you do anything, and think about who in your party might know it.
Hint 2
It's a tressym, a winged cat, sitting on a nest of stolen mail with a ring she's rather fond of. She's Tara, Gale's familiar. Bring Gale and the meeting goes very differently.
Hint 3
Without Gale you can talk to Tara properly only with Speak with Animals. Otherwise you're dealing with an animal: grab the ring, startle her, or leave her be. Every route ends with her flying off, and then the nest is free to take.
Missable The Ring of Blink is lost for good if Tara flies off before giving it to you: a failed grab, scaring her, leaving, a Fireball, or stealing from her. Without the ring she never turns up as a trader in the Lower City either. Bringing Gale guarantees it.
Solution
Without Speak with Animals: a passive Perception check (DC 15), or Animal Handling (DC 15) if that fails, lets you spot the ring and letters. Then take the ring gently (Animal Handling DC 15), lunge for it (Acrobatics DC 20), or scare her (Performance DC 15, no ring either way). With Speak with Animals: ask for the ring (Persuasion DC 15) or lunge (Acrobatics DC 15). You can also get her to own up about the pigeons (Intimidation, Persuasion or Deception, DC 15) and then talk her out of eating more (same skills, DC 15). Failing a confrontation roll makes her teleport and cast Fireball at whoever spoke, so spread the party out on the roof first. With Gale in the party, she always hands him the ring, and a Persuasion or Deception check (DC 15) stops her hunting, which Gale approves of.
Outcomes
Gale is in the party
A private reunion replaces the usual scene. Tara always gives Gale the Ring of Blink. Talking her out of the pigeons earns Gale's approval; a failed Intimidation gets a Fireball.
Get the ring (gentle grab, lunge, or asking nicely)
You get the Ring of Blink, and Tara flies off. Later she sets up as a trader in the Lower City (see below).
Scare her, fail a grab, or leave her be
Tara flies off with the ring, and it's gone.
Talk her out of hunting pigeons
She leaves the city's pigeons alone and flies off.
Wish her a good meal, or fail to persuade her
She keeps eating. At your next long rest, the last two pigeons in the coop vanish.
Fail a confrontation roll, or steal from her nest while she's watching
She teleports, casts Fireball at the offender and flies away. No ring.
Kill her
If she's been recognised as Gale's, Gale disapproves strongly (unless you are Gale).
Unconfirmed: whether sneaking the letters away always triggers the Fireball, and whether killing Tara lets you loot the ring.
Where did the ring-holder go afterwards?
Hint 1
If you came away with the ring, keep an eye out for a familiar winged face in the Lower City.
Hint 2
After the next long rest or trip into the Lower City, Tara sets up near the Devil's Fee, and later near Highberry's house. She'll swap a magic hat, then a pair of magic shoes, for anything of value.
Act Three
Return to sender
Open Hand Temple roof and post house
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I have the letters. Should I open them? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Danzo asked for them sealed. Ask yourself why he cared so much.
Hint 2
Using the bundle opens it, and the three letters go into your pack. One of them is Danzo's own, and it's addressed to the Zhentarim.
Hint 3
Opening and reading Danzo's letter is the only way to the bigger payout. Keeping it sealed gets you the small, honest fee.
Missable Destroying the letters, sealed or opened, ends the quest as a failure and gets you thrown out of the post house.
Which version of Danzo's letter you get depends on what happened to the Zhentarim chest in Act 1. One version mentions an Iron Flask; which outcome gives which isn't confirmed. That destroying a sealed bundle also counts is inferred.
How do I get the best deal from Danzo? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
What you get depends on whether the seal is intact, and whether you've read what's inside.
Hint 2
Hand back a sealed bundle and Danzo pays a small fee. Opened letters change the conversation: he assumes you know his business, and starts talking about what your silence costs.
Hint 3
Read Danzo's letter first. Then you can lean on him with Deception, Intimidation or Persuasion. Win and he pays about double; lose and he turns on you.
Missable Once you hand over the sealed bundle, the bigger payout is gone. A failed blackmail roll, keeping the letters or saying they're destroyed all lose Danzo as a shopkeeper for good.
Solution
Sealed: he pays a small fee. Trying to push the price up (Persuasion DC 18) doesn't actually get more. Opened but not read: Intimidation or Persuasion DC 20 for the big payout, or say you're not here to blackmail him for a small gift. Read: Deception, Intimidation or Persuasion DC 18 for the big payout (about twice the small fee), or accept his finder's fee for the small one. The quest closes unfinished if you start the endgame first.
Outcomes
Hand over the sealed bundle
Small fee. Danzo goes back to business as usual.
Blackmail him after reading, and win
The bigger payout. A companion reacts to the shakedown.
Blackmail him after reading, and lose
Danzo turns hostile and you have a fight on your hands. No reward.
Fail the hush-money roll on an opened, unread letter
Danzo refuses and orders you out, and won't talk to you again.
Keep the letters
No reward, and Danzo closes his shop to you. No fight.
Tell him they were destroyed
He throws you out with nothing.
Unconfirmed: whether a failed hush-money roll on the unread branch ever closes the journal, whether the post house guards join a fight with Danzo, and the exact gold at typical Act 3 levels. Killing Danzo looks like it never gives its own journal entry.