Wyll is a hero of the Sword Coast with a warlock's pact and a bounty on a devil's head. His story runs the length of the game, and ends with him deciding who he really wants to be.
Act One
The Blade of Frontiers
Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Where do I find Wyll?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
He's in the thick of the goblin attack at the Emerald Grove gate when you first arrive.
Hint 2
After the fight, look for Wyll inside the grove. He's teaching the tiefling children to fight. Talk to him and he'll offer to join you.
Missable Wyll leaves for good, without a word, if you reach the Shadow-Cursed Lands or Rosymorn Monastery while he isn't in your team, or if Karlach is defeated before either of them has joined you. Siding with the goblins against the grove also drives him away.
Hint 3
There are no checks to pass. You can take him along straight away or send him to camp.
Outcomes
You recruited Karlach before Wyll
Wyll leaves the grove and turns up at your camp one night to confront her. You can talk it out and recruit him there, let him walk away, or watch it turn into a fight that can kill Karlach.
You're playing as Karlach
Wyll threatens you in the grove, and the same camp confrontation follows later.
What if Wyll dies or leaves?
Hint 1
Wyll's quest ends if he dies for good, turns hostile, or leaves because he disapproves of you too strongly.
Hint 2
He cares about the tiefling refugees. Harming them costs his approval, and helping the goblins raid the grove makes him leave.
Outcomes
Someone else kills the Grand Duke
If a party member other than Wyll kills Ulder Ravengard after he's been saved, Wyll leaves hostile.
You reach the final assault with the quest still open
The journal notes it, and the epilogue settles Wyll's fate from the choices you made along the way.
Act One
The hunt for Karlach
The road to the Risen Road
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Where is the devil Wyll is hunting?
Hint 1
Wyll isn't the only one after her.
Hint 2
A band of paladins of Tyr is on the same hunt. Agree to help them and they'll point you towards her.
Hint 3
Karlach is out past the Emerald Grove, by the Risen Road, not far from the tollhouse the paladins are watching.
Wyll wants Karlach dead. Do I have to go along with it?
Hint 1
Bring Wyll along. The meeting goes very differently with him there.
Hint 2
Hear Karlach out before anyone draws a weapon. There's more to her story than Wyll was told.
Hint 3
You can talk Wyll down, or side with him and fight her.
Solution
With Wyll present, meeting Karlach starts the confrontation. Normally she's calm and a shared vision shows her past; after that you argue Wyll down. The passive Perception check (DC 10) leads to the same place whether it passes or fails. If you helped the goblins massacre the grove, Karlach is hostile at once: calm her with Persuasion DC 10 or Intimidation DC 10, or Deception DC 15 if Dammon is dead for good.
Outcomes
Talk Wyll down
Karlach lives and can join you. Wyll's patron won't be pleased, and he'll pay for it soon.
Fight her
Karlach dies. Wyll's patron rewards him.
Recruit Karlach without Wyll there
Wyll reacts when he sees her in your party, and the confrontation happens at camp one night instead.
After the hunt, Wyll seems on edge. What happens next? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Talk to Wyll once the business with Karlach is settled. He's expecting to answer for it.
Hint 2
Then take a long rest. His patron, Mizora, pays a visit to camp that night.
Outcomes
Karlach was spared
Mizora punishes Wyll by giving him a devil's horns. Much later this opens a path for him that he wouldn't otherwise have.
Karlach was killed
Mizora rewards Wyll with the Infernal Robe: +1 AC, fire resistance, and a warm Fire Shield as a bonus action.
Missable The Infernal Robe comes only if Karlach is dead before this night. Sparing her rules it out for good.
If Karlach is knocked out for good rather than killed or spared, the scene still plays, but which way it goes isn't confirmed.
Act One
The Grand Duke
Waukeen's Rest
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does “The Grand Duke” begin?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look for smoke on the road through the wilderness. An inn is on fire, and the Flaming Fist outside think someone important is inside.
Hint 2
Help them get into Waukeen's Rest. Counsellor Florrick is locked in a room upstairs, and she knows what really happened to Grand Duke Ulder Ravengard.
Missable The inn burns down when everyone leaves the area after someone's been inside, when you long rest, or when you leave the region. If Florrick is still locked in, she dies, and you lose her later appearances too. Get her out and talk to her before you go.
Hint 3
Keep talking to Wyll at camp, too. He has his own reasons to care about the Duke.
Outcomes
Agree to search for the Duke
Florrick heads off, and you'll meet her again later.
Tell her he's at Moonrise Towers
You need to have learned that first. She warns you about the road there.
Refuse
Wyll objects. The quest carries on either way, but an Oath of the Crown paladin breaks their oath.
Take Wyll into Moonrise Towers. If you rest at an Act 2 camp first, the scene happens there instead.
Hint 2
Mizora wants Wyll to free something valuable to her master, Zariel, that the cult is holding.
Hint 3
It's under the Towers, in the mind flayer colony. Getting there is part of the main story.
Outcomes
Push back on the pact now
During this first scene you can try to bargain Wyll's pact down, with Intimidation, History or Performance at DC 14. You get a second chance later, at a harder DC.
I've found what the cult is holding. How do I get it out?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Search the colony's tadpoling area for a sealed pod.
Hint 2
The pod's control panel has two illithid devices. They do very different things, so read them before you touch either.
Missable The left-hand device kills Mizora, and Wyll with her, for good. Use the right-hand one.
Hint 3
Talk before you open it. It's a good moment to bargain over Wyll's pact, and afterwards you can ask for a reward.
Missable You get one try at the reward. Fail the Persuasion check and the Infernal Rapier is gone.
Solution
Use the right-hand device, the one that releases. The left-hand device destroys whatever's inside. A passive Arcana DC 10 reads the symbols, and it's automatic if you deciphered that sigil on the nautiloid. Or kick the pod open with Strength DC 14 (barbarians skip the roll). Before opening, Intimidation, Performance or History DC 16 (the History route has you recite a banishing phrase) gets a promise to end the pact, though not for six months. After she's free, one Persuasion DC 14 attempt earns the Infernal Rapier (DC 16 if you're playing as Wyll).
Missable Free her before the confrontation at the end of Act 2. If Wyll is with you and she's still in the pod when you get there, he dies, and the rest of his quest goes with him.
Outcomes
Free her, no bargain
Mizora is released and Wyll's pact stands as before.
Free her after a bargain
She agrees to end the pact, but only in six months.
Win the reward haggle
The Infernal Rapier: a very rare +2 rapier that can summon a cambion once per rest.
Use the wrong device, or leave her
Mizora dies, and Wyll dies with her.
Act Three
Into the city
Wyrm's Rock
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
We've reached Baldur's Gate. What does Wyll's patron want now?
Hint 1
Bring Wyll into Wyrm's Rock fortress. Mizora is waiting inside, near the mess hall.
Hint 2
If you meet her before the coronation, she sends you upstairs to it. Go and see it through.
Hint 3
Talk to her again after the ceremony. She'll head off to your camp to discuss terms.
Outcomes
Gortash is still standing after the ceremony
The Grand Duke is taken away to Gortash's prison, the Iron Throne.
Gortash falls at the ceremony, or the Iron Throne is already gone
The Duke is killed. Mizora can still bring him back if Wyll takes her offer.
If the fortress goes on alert before you meet her, Mizora moves to a fallback spot nearby.
Act Three
Terms
Your camp
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Mizora has come to camp with an offer. What should Wyll choose?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Rest with Wyll in the party after meeting Mizora at Wyrm's Rock. Her scene plays that night.
Missable Have this scene before you go to the Iron Throne. If Wyll is with you and the pact hasn't been settled, the Duke is already dead when you arrive.
Hint 2
It's a hard bargain over Wyll's father, Grand Duke Ulder Ravengard. There's no option that costs nothing.
Hint 3
Wyll can bind himself to Mizora for good, or break free and take his chances with his father's life.
Outcomes
Eternal pact, Duke alive
Mizora tells you he's in the Iron Throne, and protects him there. She also fights alongside you at the end. Wyll stays bound to Zariel.
Eternal pact, Duke dead
Mizora raises him on the spot, and he joins your camp.
Break the pact, Duke alive
Wyll is free. In the Iron Throne, Mizora turns on the Duke and you'll have to keep him alive yourself.
Break the pact, Duke dead
Wyll is free, and the Duke stays dead.
Missable With the pact broken, if Wyll is with you at the end and the Duke is neither dead nor in your camp, the epilogue kills him.
If Grand Duke Ulder Ravengard is in your camp, talk to him with Wyll. He has the book, and a request about a dragon.
Hint 3
If he isn't, someone from his circle will come looking for Wyll in the Lower City, carrying it.
Hint 4
Read the book. It starts the Wyrmway sub-quest and points you to Wyrm's Rock Prison.
We've been stopped in the Lower City by the Duke's people. Can I talk my way out? unverified
Hint 1
They blame Wyll for what happened to the Duke. Find the argument that fits how it happened.
Hint 2
Whether the Duke can still be saved, who killed him, and what Mizora did all give you different openings.
Solution
Any one of these works: Persuasion DC 18 if the Duke isn't dead (he can still be saved); Deception DC 18 if he died at the coronation (blame Gortash); Persuasion DC 15 if he's dead and Mizora turned on you in the Iron Throne; History DC 15 about the fall of Elturel; or a tadpole probe, a contested Intelligence roll. A failed check starts the fight. Talk them down and they hand over “The Legend of Ansur”.
Outcomes
Florrick leads them
Only if she escaped the Wyrm's Rock prison. Otherwise Cordula Eltan leads them, by the Basilisk Gate. Either way two thugs, Wanda Tullermoor and Pollo the Muscle, come along.
The ambush only happens if Wyll broke the pact and the Duke is gone. That the book can be looted from the leader's body is inferred from where the script puts it.
Act Three
The Wyrmway
The Wyrmway, under Wyrm's Rock Prison
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where is the way into the Wyrmway? unverified
Hint 1
Search near the entrance of Wyrm's Rock Prison. Someone with sharp eyes will notice a space behind one wall.
Hint 2
That wall has a dragon torch on either side. The book hints at what lights them.
Hint 3
Hit the torches with lightning, using Shocking Grasp or Witch Bolt for example. Inside, the statue of Balduran asks whether you're worthy. Say you are, and the gate opens.
That lightning on the torches opens the wall is from the scripts; whether one torch or both is needed isn't confirmed. Arcana or History DC 15 at the statue only add lore.
How do I solve the lanceboard? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's a chess puzzle: mate in two. You play white, and moves are made by targeting tiles with each piece's move spell.
Hint 2
Three gems are your lives. Each wrong move costs one and resets the board, and a third mistake fails the trial.
Missable Three wrong moves fail this trial, and failing any trial breaks all four. See the last question in this section.
Hint 3
Bring Gale. He can read the position, and the next correct move is then marked on the board.
Solution
There are three layouts. Which one you get is fixed when you arrive. If white has a rook, a queen and three pawns (queen on f6): queen to h8, then after black's reply, queen to d8. If white has a bishop and the queen on a6: queen takes h6, then queen takes g7. If white has a rook, a knight and the queen on d7: rook to g8, black's bishop takes it, then queen to g7. You can also skip the chess: smash the black king. It has 50 HP and only lightning (double damage) and thunder hurt it. Do it in one go, as a hit that leaves it standing counts as a wrong move and heals it.
Computed as forced mates from the script's layouts. Squares assume files a-h run left to right from your side, as Gale's hints suggest; that isn't confirmed in play.
How do I pass the trial with the paintings? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look at all six paintings in order. They tell one story, and the frame at the end is empty.
Hint 2
Three loose paintings could fill it. The statue wants justice balanced, not just punishment or just mercy.
Missable The wrong painting fails this trial at once, and failing any trial breaks all four.
Hint 3
A shadowy judge stands over the frame, and while he's near you can't move the paintings. Get rid of him first.
Solution
Put 'The Cell' in the empty frame. To clear the judge, push him out of his spot (Shove, Thunderwave or a repelling Eldritch Blast) or end his aura with Remove Curse. He can't be damaged. 'The Hanging' or 'Freedom' in the frame fails the trial, and so does destroying 'The Cell'.
The judge leaves if he's moved out of his spot or loses his aura; which spells do that is inferred. Whether 'The Cell' should be dropped into the frame or combined with it isn't confirmed.
How do I pass the trial with the three advisors?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Read everything you can about the three of them before acting. There's one book in the room.
Hint 2
The other three books are carried by birds. Talk to a bird to try to snatch one (Sleight of Hand DC 15, once per character), or stop it moving and it drops the book. Slowing or chilling it gives you advantage.
Hint 3
You're asked to strike down the advisor who would ruin the city when the war ends. Whose ideas would do that?
Missable Strike the wrong advisor and the trial fails at once, and with it all four.
Solution
Kill Suelto, and only Suelto. The other two vanish once he dies. Killing Amaps or Stedd fails the trial.
How do I pass the torch trial? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Take the torch from the statue. Whoever holds it becomes every enemy's favourite target, and can't hide or turn invisible.
Hint 2
Keep the torch, stay inside the test area, and stay on your feet until the time runs out.
Missable Dropping the torch, stepping out or going down fails this trial, and with it all four.
Solution
Hold out for a 24-second timer, about four rounds. Two elementals (one air, one water) arrive at the start and two more in round 2, then pairs of air and water myrmidons in rounds 3 and 4. Unequipping the torch, leaving the area or going down fails the trial. Pick a sturdy torchbearer and keep them healed.
The timer value is from the script; that it comes to four rounds isn't confirmed.
What happens once the trials are done, or if I fail one? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Each trial you pass lights a statue on the central dais.
Hint 2
Fail any one trial and every statue breaks, even ones you'd already passed, and a crowd of skeletons rises to fight.
Missable A clean run of all four trials gives extra experience. One failure loses it for good.
Hint 3
Either way the central doors open, and the way down to the lair stays open.
After four successes the doors are opened by item scripts, which haven't been checked; the skeletons stay peaceful.
What's waiting at the bottom of the Wyrmway?
Hint 1
The legend promised a great dragon. Walk in ready for a fight.
Hint 2
There's no talking your way out of this one. Prepare for lightning, lots of it.
Hint 3
The dragon Ansur is long dead, but that doesn't stop him. He rises as a skeletal dragon, with two skeleton helpers.
Solution
Ansur has 400 HP and AC 19. He's immune to poison and resists necrotic damage, and can't be charmed, frightened, paralysed or knocked prone. Hit his legs, head and tail separately while he's on the ground. If he starts his turn in the air he unleashes a huge lightning blast (18d10, 40 m radius, halved on a save) that knocks you down; after that, lightning strikes hit up to two of you every round. His breath does 12d6 lightning. Lightning resistance pays off. On Honour mode he survives his first death with 100 temporary hit points. When he falls, take the Helm of Balduran from the bones; moving it opens the way out.
Outcomes
The Duke is in your camp
Go back and tell him what happened.
The Duke is dead
The Wyrmway is done; Wyll's last talk is with you.
Act Three
Who Wyll becomes
Your camp
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
The Wyrmway is done. What's left for Wyll?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go back to camp and talk it over.
Hint 2
If Grand Duke Ulder Ravengard is in your camp, tell him about Ansur with Wyll there. If not, talk to Wyll himself.
Hint 3
Wyll decides what he'll be from now on. Help him think it through.
Outcomes
Grand Duke
Wyll takes up his father's office. There's a selfless way to get there and a power-hungry one, and your companions notice which.
Blade of Frontiers
He keeps his old name and his old road.
Blade of Avernus
Only possible if Mizora gave him horns back in Act 1.
Missable The Blade of Avernus path needs Karlach to have been spared in Act 1. If she died, it's not available.
If you never have this talk, the epilogue picks one of these endings for you.