Act 3 · 28 journal steps · starts around the Lower City
A mother swears her little girl vanished from a dockside tavern. The Flaming Fist can't seem to keep the story straight, and the tavern says the child never existed. Somebody is lying.
Act Three
A missing girl
Basilisk Gate, Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
Listen for raised voices at the Flaming Fist's barracks by Basilisk Gate.
Hint 2
A woman called Lora is arguing with the Fist's commander about her missing daughter, Vanra. Talk to her.
Hint 3
If you've been helping the hag survivors, Mayrina can also put you onto it once she's well again: she asks you to find the girl's mother. Reading an informant's report at the Blushing Mermaid, or wandering into the right part of its cellar, opens the quest too.
See also: Help the Hag Survivors, Help the Hag Survivors, where Mayrina's lead comes from
The quest only exists if you beat Auntie Ethel in Act 1, whether you killed her, spared her or knocked her out. Otherwise Lora and Vanra are at home together and nothing here happens.
The commander keeps losing track of the conversation. Is something wrong with him?
Hint 1
Forgetful isn't the same as uncaring. Pay attention to anything your characters notice about him.
Hint 2
A character with good Arcana may sense magic hanging around him. If so, you get the chance to look more closely.
Solution
A passive Arcana check (DC 15) notices the magic. That unlocks an active Arcana check (DC 18) to examine him; on a success you learn his memory has been tampered with. Knowing that also lets you show the same thing about the barman at the Blushing Mermaid later. Lora names the Blushing Mermaid and its barman as where to start, then goes home.
Act Three
Nobody remembers
The Blushing Mermaid, Lower City docks
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Nobody at the Blushing Mermaid will back up Lora's story. Who do I believe?
Hint 1
If one person's memory has been meddled with, ask yourself whose else might have been.
Hint 2
Bosun Gannet, the barman, says Lora caused a scene and was thrown out. If you spotted the commander's tampered memory at Basilisk Gate, you can show his has been tampered with too.
Hint 3
Don't just talk. Look at what's lying on the Captain's table.
Solution
Read the report on the Captain's table. It's an informant's note, and reading it also starts Help the Hag Survivors. Between the note, the barman's muddled memory and what's in the cellar, you'll have enough to put to Captain Grisly.
Captain Grisly has offered me a well-paid job. What happens if I take it?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about who benefits if Lora stops asking questions.
Hint 2
You can agree, refuse, or ask for time to think. Asking for time costs you nothing: the offer is still there when you come back.
Hint 3
Refusing outright brings matters to a head on the spot. Have a look around the cellar first if you want to know what you're dealing with.
Outcomes
Ask for time
Nothing changes. Talk to her again later to accept, refuse or confront her.
Accept
The contract is 3,000 gold, or 6,000 if a Rogue haggles it up. Nothing happens until you act on it.
Kill Lora and report back
Grisly drops her disguise: she is Auntie Ethel. Because Lora is dead, she offers you a deal (see the next section). Vanra, if later freed, goes home alone after a long rest.
Knock Lora out instead, or tell Grisly you can't do it
No deal is on offer: she reveals herself and the confrontation follows. A Lora left knocked out may vanish for good on a long rest.
Refuse
She reveals herself as Auntie Ethel straight away.
Missable Any fight with Lora, even a knock-out, turns her hostile for good, and you lose her reward, the Amulet of Windrider. Killing her also leaves Vanra an orphan.
What's in the tavern's cellar, and how do I get further in? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The stairs down are behind the doors next to the Captain's table. It's private property, so pick your moment.
Hint 2
The cellar looks ordinary. One of its walls isn't quite what it seems.
Hint 3
Behind it is a hidden room with a table of strange masks and some keys. Take the keys.
Missable Leave the masks alone. Once the cellar's owner is unmasked, anyone in your party wearing one falls under her control.
Solution
A passive Investigation check (DC 15) in the cellar reveals an illusory wall. The hidden room behind it holds a table of masks and two keys: one opens the side door (lock DC 15), the other a heavy chest (trapped, disarm DC 20, lock DC 20). Watch for gas-pit traps (disarm DC 15) and mines around the chest. The sliding door into the deeper lair is trapped (disarm DC 15) and locked (DC 20); its key lies on the far side. A lever inside opens a secret way out. Don't put on any of the masks.
Unconfirmed: whether you can walk through the illusory wall without passing the check, and what the masked people in the cellar do if you meet them before the confrontation. A small key near the stairs doesn't seem to open anything.
Act Three
Confronting the captain
The Blushing Mermaid
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've got evidence against Captain Grisly. What happens when I use it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Raise the note or the cellar with her. Attacking her, or her regulars, gets the same result less politely.
Hint 2
She's not who she says she is. Look at the company she keeps, too: her regulars aren't ordinary drinkers.
Hint 3
Captain Grisly is Auntie Ethel, back from Act 1, and she has swallowed Vanra to raise the girl as a hag. Hurting her now hurts Vanra.
Outcomes
Defy her
Six of her patrons turn out to be redcaps and attack, and Ethel teleports to her lair under the cellar. The real fight happens there.
Agree to leave her alone
The redcaps stay calm unless you attack them. She still waits in her lair, and you can still go after her.
Take her deal (only if Lora is dead)
She pays the 3,000 or 6,000 gold you agreed, keeps Vanra, and joins you as an ally for the final battle. Her masked victims turn friendly. A paladin may break their oath. You can change your mind later in her lair, which starts the fight and ends the alliance.
Missable Keep the deal into the endgame and Vanra stays inside Ethel: the girl isn't saved, and Ethel's Ring of Feywild Sparks never drops.
That Vanra is beyond saving if you keep the deal is inferred: no step frees her on that path. The deal fires the game's oath-breaking event; whether every paladin oath breaks isn't confirmed.
Act Three
A gentler way
Old Garlow's Place, Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Is there a safer way to get Vanra back than fighting for her? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Other people have survived this hag. They've been studying how to beat her.
Hint 2
The hag survivors keep a safe at Old Garlow's Place. Once Mayrina has asked you to find Lora, it's yours to open.
Hint 3
Inside is a recipe book, The Hag's Bane, and the rare ingredient it needs. You'll have to craft the result yourself.
Solution
Take Ashes of Dried Fey Flower from the safe and combine it, using alchemy, with any Fey essence (Acorn Truffle, Beholder Iris, Gremishka Tail, Timmask Spores, Nightlight Frond, Planetar Feather, Crystalline Lens, Swarming Toadstool, Sylvan Stone or Unicorn Horn all extract to one). The result is Hag's Bane, a throwable. Throw it at Ethel: hit or miss, she is left nauseous and brings Vanra up alive. The safe also holds A Hunter's Guide to Hags, which you'll want for the fight.
Missable There's only one Ashes of Dried Fey Flower, so you get one Hag's Bane. Don't waste it on anything else.
No lock was found on the safe, and it isn't confirmed whether taking from it early counts as stealing. Throwing Hag's Bane at Ethel while she's still disguised in the pub appears to free Vanra there and then, but that hasn't been checked in play.
Act Three
Under the tavern
Beneath the Blushing Mermaid
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've found who took Vanra. How do I get her out alive? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Vanra is inside Auntie Ethel. Whatever you do, don't kill Ethel while the girl is still in there.
Missable A killing blow on Ethel while Vanra is inside her kills Vanra. There's no undoing it.
Hint 2
There are two ways to get her out: make Ethel give her up, or take Ethel down without killing her.
Hint 3
Hag's Bane, the brew from the survivors' recipe, makes her bring Vanra up. Without it, knock Ethel out with non-lethal attacks and you'll get the chance to cut the girl free.
Solution
Before you start, take off any hag masks. Option one: throw Hag's Bane at Ethel; it works whether it hits or misses. Option two: switch to non-lethal attacks and knock her out; a prompt then lets you cut Vanra free, which kills Ethel. A killing blow while Vanra is inside kills the girl too. Once Vanra is out, you can fight without holding back.
How the knock-out interacts with Ethel being unkillable while she carries Vanra isn't confirmed, nor whether every lethal hit triggers Vanra's death. After you cut Vanra free, Ethel is expected to rise again at her Circle of Pearls if any of her mushrooms survive; not checked in play.
The fight below the tavern won't stay won. How do I finish it? unverified
Hint 1
Auntie Ethel isn't keeping herself alive. Look around the cavern, not at her.
Hint 2
Three glowing mushrooms, the Pearlspore Bells, keep her going. Destroy all three and she stays down.
Hint 3
Burn them first: a bell that's on fire, or under Searing Smite, can't heal itself and won't spray you with spores.
Solution
Each Pearlspore Bell has 55 HP and heals fully on its turn unless it is Burning or under Searing Smite. Hitting an unburnt one releases spores that stop you moving or acting. If Ethel falls while a bell stands, she rises at the Circle of Pearls with 100%, 80% or 60% HP, depending on how many bells are down. Once all three are gone and she drops, she's dead for good: her redcaps die with her, her masked victims, including the real Captain Quenora Grisly, are freed, and she drops a Ring of Feywild Sparks.
Burn-then-break is our reading of the bells' rules. On the harder combat setting the bells are tougher, boost her saves and explode in poison when destroyed.
Act Three
Going home
Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Vanra is free. What now? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Talk to her. She won't say much, but she knows where she wants to go.
Hint 2
Vanra runs home to her mother. Lora, if she was still at Basilisk Gate, heads home too.
Hint 3
Visit Lora at home for your thanks.
Solution
Speak to Vanra and she runs off home. Go to Lora's house in the Lower City and talk to her: she gives you the Amulet of Windrider, which grants Gaseous Form and Gust of Wind. If someone robbed her of it first, she apologises and you get nothing, though the quest still moves on. If the real Captain Quenora survived the fight and Ethel is truly dead, Quenora returns to the Blushing Mermaid after a long rest, and she and Bosun both thank you.
Missable No amulet if Lora is dead, hostile, or was robbed of it. Fighting her, telling her you've come to kill her, or letting the Basilisk Gate commander die before she goes home all turn her hostile for good. Telling her Vanra is dead sends her away for good.
If more than one ending condition applies at once (for example you never spoke to Lora but she's home), which journal entry shows hasn't been checked.
What if I leave this unfinished?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This one has a deadline.
Hint 2
The quest closes when the final push begins. Whatever state it's in then is how it ends.
Missable Once the endgame starts this quest closes as it stands. Free Vanra and collect Lora's reward before then.