Act 3 · 20 journal steps · starts around the Lower City
A handful of people who once fell into a hag's clutches have banded together in the Lower City. They want her found and finished, and finishing a hag properly is harder than it sounds.
Act Three
Taking up the hunt
Old Garlow's Place, Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
It follows on from Help the Hag Survivors. Finish that one first.
Hint 2
Once the trouble in the survivors' hideout at Old Garlow's Place is settled, they ask you to hunt down the hag behind it all. Say yes.
Hint 3
Even turning Mayrina down starts it; she just says she'll do the hunting herself. And if you end the hag for good before you ever took on Help the Hag Survivors, talking to any survivor afterwards opens this quest at the reporting stage.
None of this exists unless you beat Auntie Ethel back in Act 1: without that there are no survivors in the city to ask you.
The survivors want the hag found. Where do I even look?
Hint 1
You've probably already crossed her trail. Think about anyone in the city whose problem smells of hag magic.
Hint 2
The trail runs through another quest, Save Vanra: a frantic mother at Basilisk Gate, and an informant's report that points to the docks.
Hint 3
Go to the Blushing Mermaid on the docks and take a hard look at the captain who runs it. Not everyone there is what they seem.
Solution
Follow Save Vanra: Lora at Basilisk Gate, then the informant, then the Blushing Mermaid. 'Captain Grisly' is Auntie Ethel in disguise. Once she is unmasked she retreats to her lair in the cellar beneath the pub, and the fight happens there.
See also: Save Vanra, Save Vanra, the same trail and the same hag
Is there anything I should read before the showdown? unverified
Hint 1
The survivors have been studying their enemy. Look around their hideout.
Hint 2
Agreeing to the hunt unlocks the survivors' safe at Old Garlow's Place. Take what's inside.
Hint 3
Read A Hunter's Guide to Hags, all the way through. It tells you what keeps a hag coming back and how to stop it: her mushrooms have to burn.
Solution
The safe at Old Garlow's Place holds A Hunter's Guide to Hags, The Hag's Bane recipe and its ingredient. Read the guide before the fight; the journal then notes that her pearlspore bell mushrooms must be burned. A second copy is in the pocket of Tolna Tome-Monger at Sorcerous Sundries, if you missed the first. You can read it after the fight starts, too, but it's better to know beforehand.
Tolna's copy is pickpocketable; whether she will also sell it isn't confirmed.
Act Three
Confronting the hag
The docks
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I keep putting her down and she keeps getting back up. How do I end this? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
She isn't drawing her strength from herself. Look around the cavern, not at her.
Hint 2
Three big glowing fungi, the Pearlspore Bells, keep her alive. While any of them stands, she rises again at the Circle of Pearls.
Hint 3
The bells heal themselves fully on their turn unless they're on fire. Burn them, then break them, then deal with her.
Hint 4
Hitting a bell that isn't burning puffs out spores that leave you unable to move or act. Light it first, every time.
Solution
There are three Pearlspore Bells: one about 23 m west of the Circle of Pearls, one about 9 m east, and one about 30 m south-east. Each has 55 HP and regains all of it on its own turn unless it is Burning or under Searing Smite (either one stops the heal, then wears off). Damaging an unburnt bell releases pacifying spores. So set a bell alight, or Searing Smite it, and destroy it before its next turn. If Ethel drops while a bell still stands, she comes back at the Circle: at full HP with no bells down, 80% with one, 60% with two. Knocked out instead, a bell wakes her. She is gone for good only after all three bells are destroyed: bells first, then her. Before the fight, take off any hag masks your party is wearing, or she takes control of the wearer. Masked victims and Quenora fight on her side, and she conjures illusory copies of herself. Her true death drops a Ring of Feywild Sparks.
Missable If Vanra is still inside Ethel, a killing blow kills the child too. To save her, knock Ethel out and cut Vanra free, or use The Hag's Bane first (see Save Vanra).
See also: Save Vanra, saving Vanra in the same fight
Doing all 55 damage to an unburnt bell within one round should also work, but whether the heal lands on the bell's own turn hasn't been checked in play. On harder difficulty the bells are tougher, buff her saves and explode with poison when they die. Ethel's HP and AC here aren't confirmed.
Do I have to fight her at all? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Hags love a bargain. Listen to what she has to say once her disguise is gone.
Hint 2
She'll offer terms, but only if a certain worried mother is no longer around to object.
Hint 3
A deal means she keeps what she took, and you've broken your word to the survivors.
Outcomes
Fight
She retreats to her lair and the fight above follows. Kill her for good, report back, and the survivors reward you.
Make the deal (only possible if Lora is dead)
Ethel keeps Vanra and agrees to fight for you as an ally in the final battle; she also turns up in a letter in the epilogue. Paladins break their oath. If you carry the deal into the endgame, this quest closes without a reward.
Make the deal, then attack her anyway
Breaking the deal in her lair starts the fight as normal and she is no longer your ally.
Missable Keeping the deal costs you the Fey Semblance Amulet, the survivors' reward, and the Ring of Feywild Sparks from her true death.
That nothing else pays the amulet on the deal path is inferred: no step on that path carries a reward.
Act Three
Back to the survivors
Old Garlow's Place, Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
The hunt is over. Who do I tell?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go back to where you were given the job.
Missable Leaving for the endgame closes this quest. If you haven't reported back by then, the Fey Semblance Amulet is lost.
Hint 2
Head to Old Garlow's Place and talk to the survivors. Adrielle, Kled or the masked druid can hear the news.
Hint 3
If Mayrina is alive and in the city, the others send you to her: she's the one who closes the quest.
Solution
Return to Old Garlow's Place and tell a survivor the hag is truly dead. With Mayrina alive in the city, talk to her; otherwise Adrielle, Kled or the masked druid will do. The reward is the Fey Semblance Amulet (advantage on Intelligence, Wisdom and Charisma saves). If Help the Hag Survivors was still open when she died, that quest pays the reward instead.
Mayrina has a question about Connor. What should I say?
Hint 1
This only comes up if Connor came to the city with Mayrina.
Hint 2
With the hag gone, Mayrina realises what that means for him. It's your chance to talk her into letting him rest.
Outcomes
Persuade her to let him go (Persuasion DC 10)
Possible only while she still holds the wand, Bitter Divorce. On a success she destroys it and Connor dies for good.
Fail the check, or say something else
She keeps him as he is.
Every answer completes the quest and pays the reward.
Can this quest fail? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The survivors have to be alive, and still friendly, to hear your news.
Hint 2
If you made any kind of arrangement with the hag, think hard about whether to bring it up.
Outcomes
Tell Adrielle or Mayrina about your deal
They turn on you, the survivors become hostile and the quest ends. Paladins break their oath.
All the survivors die
The quest ends with nobody to report to.
Kill Mayrina
The quest has an ending where the survivors turn hostile for good, but it may not trigger when you kill her in the city.
Missable Any of these endings loses the Fey Semblance Amulet.
The rule for killing Mayrina appears to need a condition that's never true while she's in the city, so the survivors may stay friendly. Not confirmed in play.