Act 1 · 15 journal steps · starts around the Wilderness
Waukeen's Rest is on fire, and someone upstairs can't get out. A short rescue against the clock, with a quieter story waiting once the smoke clears.
Act One
The burning inn
Waukeen's Rest, upper floor
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Someone is shouting for help upstairs. How do I reach him? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go up to the top floor of the inn and follow the voice. Listen to what your party says about the doors on the landing.
Hint 2
One door is giving off heat. Opening or smashing a hot door when the floor starts to go lets the fire out in a burst.
Hint 3
Benryn is pinned under fallen beams in a room on the top floor. The moment you step up to his room, open a door or break the beams, the floor starts collapsing and fires spring up around the room. From then on, work quickly.
Missable Benryn is on a timer. Once anyone in your party has been inside the inn area, the inn burns down for good when the whole party leaves the surroundings, when you long rest, or when you leave the region. If he is still pinned then, he dies. Free him before you do any of those.
Solution
The burst is a 6 m cone from the doorway: Strength save DC 18, or 1d6 thunder and 2d6 fire and a 12 m shove (half the fire damage on a save). It comes from the main room door if that door is open when the collapse starts, and from any door that has been destroyed. Your best bet is to walk into the room area without opening or smashing that door.
Exactly which door you have to pass, and whether opening the main door is itself enough to set off the burst, isn't confirmed in play. Opening any of the three doors on that floor does start the collapse.
The beams are too heavy. How do I free him? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Click the beams or Benryn to talk to him. The game drops into turn-based mode when you do.
Hint 2
You can't start the conversation while you or Benryn are burning or standing in fire. Then you just get a plain Strength roll. Put the flames out or step off them first if you want all the options.
Hint 3
In the conversation you can lift the beams with brute strength or look for leverage. Or skip the talking and break the beams with weapons.
Solution
Lift: Strength DC 10 (Barbarians get advantage). Leverage: Investigation DC 15. Out of conversation, using the beams is a plain Strength DC 10 roll, and a companion who isn't a player character always gets that roll. Breaking the beams also works: they have 30 HP, and destroying them frees him. Keep area attacks away from him. Whoever fails in conversation is out of the running and only gets a cough or a complaint from then on.
Outcomes
A Barbarian fails the first lift and tries again harder
Strength DC 15. Pass and he's free. Fail and the beams crush him.
A Bard pretends the beam is too heavy (Performance DC 12)
You can then genuinely try, or lie that it's hopeless (Deception DC 12) and pump him for news of his wife before walking off. That leaves him pinned, and you learn about the dowry early.
Leave him
That character gives up on him. If nobody frees him before the inn burns down, he dies in the fire. If your party sees him dead, a Haunted One character gets their inspiration.
Missable A failed Barbarian retry kills Benryn on the spot, and with him the rest of the quest. If you'd rather not gamble, let someone else lift or just break the beams.
Not confirmed in play: whether a second party member can start the conversation and try again after the first one fails (the data tracks failure per character), and whether the Bard's 'actually try' roll is DC 12 or the DC 15 retry, and if it can kill him.
He's free. How do I get him out of the building? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Stay in his room after the beams come off. Benryn will want a word.
Hint 2
He asks whether to follow you. Either way he's heading for the street outside.
Hint 3
He's safe once he reaches the open ground by the Flaming Fist's fountain outside and someone in your party can see him there.
Outcomes
Tell him to follow you
He joins you as a follower while you're inside. He leaves the party on his own once he's out of the building. Using a waypoint or going to camp asks if you want to drop him.
Tell him he's on his own
He makes his own way out. Both choices give the same experience.
Nobody is in his room when he's freed
He goes alone. The same happens if the door next to the beams was destroyed before he was freed.
Missable Getting him to safety completes the Folk Hero inspiration (rescuing Florrick in the same inn also counts). The follow-or-not choice is one-time only.
He doesn't heal while inside the inn, so leaving him to cross the fire alone is probably riskier; that's inferred, not tested. Pointing him at the door instead of answering just gets a complaint; what happens after that isn't confirmed.
Act One
Someone missing
Outside Waukeen's Rest
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Benryn is safe, but he keeps calling for someone. Who? unverified
Hint 1
Talk to Benryn outside and ask who he's looking for, and what she looks like.
Hint 2
She's Miri, his wife: brown hair, green blouse. Look around the burned buildings just south of the inn, up off the ground.
Hint 3
You'll find her body on an upper level there. Looting it, or asking her who she is or how she died with Speak with Dead, marks her as found.
Hint 4
Go back and tell Benryn you found her. He goes to her himself, and the quest moves on the moment he sees her.
Outcomes
Tell him she must be dead
He refuses to believe it and keeps searching.
Tell him you found her
He heads for her body. Once there, you can ask how they were separated, comfort him or needle him, and a non-evil Cleric can pray for her. She followed Gond; saying Gond doesn't exist makes him angry.
If you move her body before he gets there, he says she's gone and may still be alive. Whether he then gets stuck isn't confirmed, so leave her where she lies.
Act One
The missing dowry
The barn behind the inn
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Benryn mentioned a dowry. Where is it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Benryn only knows part of the story. The rest is with the person who was carrying it.
Hint 2
Once he's with his wife's body, ask him about the quarrel he mentions. Then cast Speak with Dead on her and spend a question on her valuables or her sister's dowry.
Missable Speak with Dead only allows a few questions per cast. Use one on the dowry. If Benryn is beside you, he may ask you to put his question for her, which also works.
Hint 3
She says it's hidden in a barn. Benryn, if he's standing by, guesses the empty buildings behind the inn.
Hint 4
Search the haystack in the barn about 20 m west of the inn, close to the hideout entrance behind it.
Solution
Interacting with the haystack makes a hidden Perception check, DC 15, once per character. If you've already heard the location from Miri, it passes automatically. A small jewel chest is pulled out of the hay; the Dowry Ring is inside, with some other valuables.
Missable Each character gets only one try at the haystack. If everyone fails without having heard the location from Miri first, the ring may be lost. Talk to her before you touch the hay.
Not confirmed: whether the ring is really lost if every roll fails, or whether learning the location later allows a fresh try. Also, the data hides Miri's dowry questions from a half-elf speaker; a half-elf can still get there through Benryn's question when he's present.
I have the ring. What should I do with it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Benryn needs to be alive, out of the inn, and to have seen his wife's body before he'll take it.
Hint 2
Talk to him by her body, or use Speak with Dead on her while he's standing there. Both conversations let you hand it over or keep it.
Outcomes
Give it back
He thanks you and asks for some time alone with her. The quest ends, and companions react.
Keep it as payment for saving him
He curses you, and a companion has something to say. Lae'zel, Shadowheart or Astarion may make a callous remark; otherwise Gale, Karlach or Wyll take you to task. The quest ends with the same experience as returning it. The ring is a plain gold ring.
Say you don't have it any more
The quest stays open, and he begs you to get it back.
Missable Angering Benryn (keeping the ring, refusing to ask Miri his question, denying Gond, or telling him you've done enough) turns him cold, but you can still hand the ring over afterwards.
Missable The quest closes when you pass Act 2's point of no return, so settle it before you leave Act 1 for good.
That the plain gold ring has no magic is inferred from its stats. Which companions approve or disapprove of each choice hasn't been confirmed in play.