Acts 1–3 · 97 journal steps · playing as Shadowheart
You wake on a nautiloid holding a relic you're sworn to deliver, with gaps in your memory you'd rather not look at. Your own story runs from a cursed temple to the heart of Baldur's Gate, and this time every choice in it is yours.
Act One
Waking up
Nautiloid
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does my story start? Do I need to do anything?
Hint 1
No. Your quest opens on its own once you've come round in your pod on the nautiloid.
Hint 2
There's no recruiting to do, and none of the ways a companion Shadowheart can be lost apply to you. The artefact is with you from the start, which also opens the artefact quest.
Carry on with the main story. Your journal picks up anything anyone lets slip about the relic you carry.
Hint 2
The cult's leaders at the goblin camp know more than they say. Talk to them, and listen in on what they're up to. Something also tries to speak to you near the camp.
Hint 3
Two more come later: a githyanki patrol on the plains that's looking for something, and what you see inside the artefact at the githyanki creche.
Solution
Each of these adds an entry: learning at the goblin camp (from Minthara, or from the goblin leaders' scrying) that the cult wants a weapon; the voice of the Absolute near the goblin camp; the githyanki patrol at the plains chokepoint mentioning the weapon; and finishing the conversation inside the astral prison at the Rosymorn creche.
Act One
What you're hiding
Camp and on the road
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
My hand keeps burning. What sets it off?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's not a conversation this time. You notice it for yourself, so pay attention to Selûne.
Hint 2
In the blighted village, read the priestess's journal, or walk past the defaced statue. If you get to camp before either, a dream may bring it up instead.
Missable The camp dream about the wound plays only if the village hasn't already taught you about it. Miss it and you lose the dream; the journal just reads a little differently.
Hint 3
Reaching the Underdark or the plains also sets it off, but that one doesn't add a journal entry.
When does the journal note that the party knows my faith?
Hint 1
Whenever they find out, from whatever source. You don't need a set conversation for it.
Hint 2
It can come as late as Act 2, at the Gauntlet of Shar.
Lae'zel wants the artefact. How do I keep the peace?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's the same camp-night showdown as when you travel with Shadowheart, but you're the one in it, and only Lae'zel can come off worst.
Outcomes
Calm things down
Lae'zel stays.
Let it come to blows
Lae'zel may die or leave. You don't.
Missable Lae'zel can be lost for good here. Talk it down if you want to keep her.
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
There's a rare mushroom in the Underdark said to restore what's been forgotten.
Hint 2
It's a Noblestalk. You don't need talking into it: pick one and eat it yourself.
Missable Noblestalk grows only in the Underdark. The memory it gives you starts “A Familiar Face”, which matters in Act 3.
Act One
The Dark Justiciar trail
Emerald Grove, goblin camp, Underdark, Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does “The Chosen of Shar” begin? unverified
Hint 1
It starts with the first clue you find. There's no conversation to have first.
Hint 2
Clues are anything to do with the Dark Justiciars: art, idols, the dead, and what others know about them.
Hint 3
Murals in the druids' lair at the Emerald Grove; the ruined Selûnite temple under the goblin camp; an Idol of Shar in the Underdark; Halsin, once you've rescued him; and two that only you notice: dead Justiciars in Grymforge, and a view of their temple from the broken bridge there.
After a second clue you should get a moment of reflection of your own; that it comes on the second clue specifically is inferred from rule order.
Where is the Dark Justiciars' temple?
Hint 1
This plays as it does with Shadowheart as a companion: the way on from Grymforge is broken, so you'll go overland.
The voice entry comes from a reaction by whoever stands nearest when the voice first speaks. Whether you still get it when someone else is nearer isn't confirmed; keep close to be safe.
How do I get into the Silent Library's secret room?
Hint 1
It's the same puzzle as with a companion Shadowheart. The spear inside is for you.
This time nobody decides for you. You pick every line.
Hint 2
Whatever you choose sets the course of your story for the rest of the game. Take your time.
Outcomes
Kill the Nightsong
You stay on Shar's path, and Act 3 follows it.
Free the Nightsong
When you leave the prison, Shar pulls you aside to deal with you herself. You come round, knocked out, at the mausoleum entrance, set against her for good. If you're dead when the party leaves, you're revived first.
Let Balthazar take the Nightsong
She's taken to Moonrise Towers, and your journal records it. Leaving the prison should bring Shar's wrath down on you as well.
That surrendering the Nightsong also triggers Shar's wrath is inferred: the rule only checks that you aren't on Shar's path.
What comes after the Shadowfell?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Rest at camp. What happens there depends on what you chose at the cage.
Hint 2
If the Nightsong is free, she comes to see you at camp, and something you'd forgotten about wolves comes back. If you stayed with Shar, a night of your own can come at camp from now into Act 3, and beating Ketheric is noted.
Missable Shar's night at camp is lost once you've defeated Viconia in Act 3. The wolf memory comes only from the Nightsong's visit or, later, from your parents' scene; there's no earlier conversation for it as there is with a companion Shadowheart.
Act Three
Finding the cult
Wyrm's Crossing and the Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where are the Sharrans? unverified
Hint 1
The trail is the same as with a companion Shadowheart, but your journal updates as soon as you reach Wyrm's Crossing.
Hint 2
You can't miss your part in the conversations along the way: you're always there for them.
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The choices are the same four as with a companion Shadowheart, and your choice at the cage decides which two you get.
Missable If your parents die outside the scene, the scene is lost (it doesn't cost you a companion, since you're the one it's about). Finish it before heading to the final battle, too, or the chance is gone.