Shadowheart says little about herself, and remembers even less. Earn her trust, and her story will take you from a cursed temple to the heart of Baldur's Gate, with a choice at the end of Act 2 that shapes everything after.
Act One
Finding Shadowheart
Nautiloid, crash site and beyond
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Where can I recruit her?
Hint 1
If you can, free her on the nautiloid. It doesn't add a journal entry, but she remembers it.
Hint 2
After the crash, look for her near the wreck, or on the beach if you left her behind.
Hint 3
Missed her? She keeps moving: later she turns up at the Emerald Grove, then near your camp. If you pick up the artefact she carries, she'll even come looking for you near the goblin camp.
Outcomes
She died before you recruited her
Revive her and you can still recruit her.
Lae'zel or a githyanki is with you
That's noted when she joins, and it colours her first impressions.
What if she dies or leaves?
Hint 1
Her quest ends if she dies for good, turns hostile, or leaves because she disapproves of you too strongly.
Act One
What she's hiding
Camp and on the road
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
What is she carrying, and who does she worship?
Hint 1
Talk to her at camp, and keep talking. She opens up slowly.
Hint 2
She's taking the artefact to Baldur's Gate on someone else's orders.
Hint 3
She's a cleric of Shar. Your companions, or a few conversations, will bring that out sooner or later. Ask about her past and she'll mention a Mother Superior.
What's wrong with her hand?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It flares up now and then. Pay attention to when.
Hint 2
Looting a Selûnite shrine, eating a certain Underdark mushroom, or simply reaching the Underdark or the plains can set it off.
Hint 3
When it flares, be supportive, and ask her about it afterwards. She may or may not be honest with you.
Missable After it has flared four times, she stops wanting to talk about it.
Can I help her remember?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
There's a rare mushroom in the Underdark that's said to restore lost memories.
Missable Noblestalk grows only in the Underdark. The memory it unlocks matters in Act 3 (see “A Familiar Face”).
Hint 2
It's called a Noblestalk. She won't eat one straight from your pack; you have to talk her into it.
Why is she afraid of wolves?
Hint 1
She can be frightened near wolves. Ask her about it afterwards.
Hint 2
With enough trust she'll share a dream about it. That needs high approval, for her to have told you she wants to become a Dark Justiciar, and for you to know about her Mother Superior.
Lae'zel and Shadowheart are at each other's throats!
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It comes to a head one night at camp. You can calm them down, or pick a side.
Missable Taking sides here can cost you either companion permanently.
Outcomes
Calm them
Both stay.
Side with one
The other may die or leave for good.
Act One
The Dark Justiciar trail
Emerald Grove, goblin camp, Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does “The Chosen of Shar” begin?
Hint 1
First she has to tell you she wants to become a Dark Justiciar. After that, take her to places tied to them.
Hint 2
She reacts to the murals in the druids' lair at the Emerald Grove, to an Idol of Shar in Grymforge, and to the ruined Selûnite temple under the goblin camp. Halsin also knows something about Dark Justiciars once you've rescued him.
Where is the Dark Justiciars' temple?
Hint 1
Grymforge is full of signs of them: dead Justiciars, and the devils they fought.
Hint 2
The duergar, or True Soul Nere, can tell you about a temple of Shar beyond Grymforge. The bridge there is broken, though, so you'll have to go overland.
In the most heavily cursed places her protection fails, and she's as vulnerable as anyone.
She seems troubled. Should I talk to her?
Hint 1
Yes. Her faith is starting to crack, and she'll talk about it if you ask.
Act Two
The Gauntlet of Shar
Gauntlet of Shar
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
How do the trials work?
Hint 1
Read the altar. There are three trials, and each one awards a gem.
Hint 2
One trial is about staying unseen by the shadows; one pits each of you against your own reflection; one asks you to cross a path you can't see.
Hint 3
In the mirror trial, only fight your own reflection; hitting someone else's counts as cheating. On the invisible path, falling just sends you back to the start.
Solution
One gem in the upper altar starts the lift. All three in the lower altar open the way to the Nightsong.
How do I open the secret door in the Silent Library?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
First, deal with the silence: find and destroy the thing that keeps the library quiet.
Missable Shar wants the spear in Shadowheart's hands at the Nightsong's cage. Skip it, and her conversations with Shar go differently.
Hint 2
A plaque by the wall wants a book. Which of the teachings on the shelves is about the Nightsinger?
Solution
Place “Teachings of Loss: The Nightsinger” on the “Riddle of the Night” plaque. Any other book springs a trap. Alternatively, cast Knock on the Relief of Shar. The secret room holds the Spear of Night and Dark Justiciar armour.
The last point is inferred: no Act 3 step fires unless one of the two path flags is set.
Can her wound be healed? unverified
Hint 1
Talk to her at camp after the Shadowfell. What she chose there changes what she can tell you.
Set from her camp conversations after the cage; exact timing not confirmed.
Act Three
Finding the cult
Wyrm's Crossing and the Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Where are the Sharrans?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Someone among the refugees at Wyrm's Crossing is keeping watch for the cult.
Hint 2
Find the Sharran lookout in the refugee camp. Shadowheart can get the cult's hideout out of him: the House of Grief, in the Lower City.
Missable Have Shadowheart in the party when you talk to the lookout. If she isn't there, her part in that conversation is lost.
Hint 3
At the House of Grief, speak to the attendant with Shadowheart beside you. What follows leads further in.
Missable Have her with you again when you enter the House of Grief. Her scene at the door doesn't happen without her.
Act Three
The Shar Grotto
Beneath the House of Grief
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I handle the confrontation with the cult's leader?
Hint 1
You don't have to fight everyone down there.
Hint 2
Before the fight, you can win over three groups of her followers. Anyone you sway won't fight for her.
Outcomes
After you beat her
You can spare her or kill her.
How do I open the Door of Loss?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Shar's door opens for the faithful, or for a sacrifice.
Missable Don't open it before you've dealt with the cult's leader. Opening it early starts the fight on the spot.
Solution
If Shadowheart still follows Shar, it opens when she approaches. Otherwise, lay items worth at least 1,000 gold on the altar in front of it and wait for the flames to die down.
The cult's leader offered me a deal for Shadowheart.
Hint 1
Think hard. There's no taking it back.
Outcomes
Accept
Shadowheart leaves the party for good, and you'll find her later with her mind wiped.
Act Three
Her parents
The Chamber of Loss
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
What can happen to her parents?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Her choice at the cage decides which options she has here.
Missable Don't let anyone harm her parents before the scene plays out. If they die outside it, Shadowheart turns on you or leaves. Also finish this before heading to the final battle, or the chance is gone.
Outcomes
Shar's path: sacrifice them
She becomes Shar's chosen.
Shar's path: free them
She breaks with Shar at last, and the cult turns on you.
Turned from Shar: let them rest
Her parents are laid to rest.
Turned from Shar: save them
They walk free, and you'll find them at your camp.
Act Three
A Familiar Face
Lower City and the Shar Grotto
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Who is the old friend she remembers? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This only happens if she recovered a memory in the Underdark.
Hint 2
The friend from that memory is among the Sharrans beneath the House of Grief.
Missable Go into the Grotto carefully. If you fight your way through, the old friend can be killed before Shadowheart meets her. Inside, the Mirror of Loss can take memories, including this one, which ends the reunion.
On entering the Lower City, the journal may say you've met the friend before you actually have.