You are Gale of Waterdeep: a gifted wizard with impeccable manners and something in your chest that is always hungry. Keep it fed, find help for it, and your story runs all the way to the end of the game.
Act One
The orb in your chest
Camp and on the road
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
My first night in camp, a familiar face turned up. What's going on? unverified
Hint 1
Your journal starts the moment the game does. There's no one to persuade: you already know your own secret.
Hint 2
Your first long rest is a private scene. Your tressym, Tara, has found you, and she has brought a present.
Hint 3
The present is a magic ring, and it's food for the orb. Your answers to Tara only change what she says back; the ring arrives either way.
Solution
Tara gives you a Ring of Evasion. It carries the marker for items you can eat, so you can feed it to the orb straight away and meet your first hunger. The same night sets the hunger going: your first need starts here, and the next two come later as you explore.
The scripts suggest you can keep the ring and wear it instead, feeding the orb something else. That isn't confirmed in play, nor whether eating it on the first night counts towards everything later that wants one item eaten. If the private scene doesn't play, the first hunger should come from exploring instead.
How do I feed the orb, and which items count? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Nobody hands you anything here. You eat the items yourself, from your own inventory.
Hint 2
Edible items are marked in your inventory from the very start. Look for that marker before you sell or equip something.
Hint 3
Use a marked item while the orb is hungry. It's consumed, and you feel better. When the hunger is satisfied, you can't eat any more until it comes back.
Solution
Any item with the consumable-artefact marker works; the companion page lists examples. You need one item per hunger, three in all. The first hunger comes on your first night. The next two come as you reach new main areas: the second at the second area after that night, the third at the fourth. Eating doesn't slow that clock down, unlike for the companion. Entering Act 2, and reaching the Reithwin tollhouse, each count as two areas. While you're hungry you carry a debuff that persists through rests: first disadvantage on Constitution saves, then disadvantage on attack rolls and all saves, and at worst half movement and no running as well.
Missable If the orb is still at its second or third level of hunger when Elminster settles it in Act 2, the disadvantage on Constitution saves stays with you for good. Reach him with at most one hunger unfed.
The debuff stages and the permanent Constitution penalty come from the scripts and haven't been confirmed in play. The order the game removes and reapplies the penalty in is inferred.
What happens if I ignore the hunger?
Hint 1
Less than for the companion. Gale can't walk out on himself, so you can't lose him.
Hint 2
The cost is the stacking debuffs, and a bad moment later in the journey if the orb still isn't settled by then.
Hint 3
Help comes in Act 2 whether or not you've eaten anything. The question below about collapsing says how.
Act One
In Case of Death...
Wherever you fell
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I died, and an image of me started talking to my companions. What do they do? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's the same protocol as when Gale is a companion: your party follows the instructions you left.
Hint 2
The pouch, the flute, the tune and the name all work the same way. The companion page has the details.
Hint 3
Two differences. The projection appears on every death, with a shorter reminder after the first. And any way of bringing you back counts as finishing this.
Missable Don't stay dead too long. As for the companion, after about three long rests the orb goes off and the game ends.
Whether the pouch and scroll steps land in this sub-quest's journal for an avatar Gale, when the script names the parent quest, isn't confirmed.
Act Two
An old friend
Mountain pass and the Shadow-Cursed Lands
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Is there any real help for the orb?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Help comes looking for you as you head into the Shadow-Cursed Lands.
Hint 2
If you've eaten at least one item, an old man waits where you come out of the mountain pass or the Underdark lift, as for the companion.
Hint 3
Talk to him, then go back to camp. This time the scene there is just the two of you, and every path ends with the orb settled and a new spell in your head.
Missable If the orb was at its second or third level of hunger when he settles it, you keep disadvantage on Constitution saves permanently. He warns you about it in the scene.
Solution
The old man is Elminster. Whether you lead him to camp or say you'll join him later, he heads there. The camp scene stabilises the orb, ends the hunger and its debuffs, and gives you the spell that detonates it. If you thought you'd killed him earlier, a passive Arcana check (DC 14) lets you notice it was only a copy; that only changes the conversation. Tara has something to say afterwards if she's in camp.
Missable Never cast the orb spell except in the very last battle of the game. Anywhere else it ends the game.
Something went badly wrong on the road and I woke up in camp. What happened? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
This only happens if the orb was still unsettled when you got close to Moonrise Towers.
Hint 2
The orb went critical. You were paralysed for a few moments, then died, and nothing could bring you back on the spot.
Missable Reaching this point means you're at the worst level of hunger when Elminster arrives, so the permanent disadvantage on Constitution saves applies unless you've eaten enough. Meet him on the road earlier to avoid it.
Hint 3
It can't end the game. Your body is sent to camp, you're revived there, and Elminster turns up to settle the orb.
Solution
Passing a trigger on the road towards Moonrise with the orb unstabilised raises your hunger to its worst, paralyses you briefly and blocks resurrection. When it wears off you die; the game-over is blocked, and you're revived in camp, where Elminster holds the same private scene as above.
The paralysis is scripted at 18 seconds, which is probably three rounds. The rescue scene in camp hasn't been watched in play.
Act Two
Balthazar's Experiment
Moonrise Towers
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
There's a strange ritual circle in a lab at Moonrise. What do I do with it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Mostly as for the companion: it's a shadow-magic circle, with its ingredients lying nearby.
Hint 2
You're the expert here, so you examine it yourself. There's no high roll to overrule anyone.
Hint 3
Crafting it and erasing it are both plain options in the conversation.
Outcomes
Craft it
You get the Shadow Lantern, and you're left uneasy about it.
Erase the sigils
You should gain Mystra's blessing: advantage on Concentration saves.
Leave it alone
Once Act 3 begins, the chance is gone.
Missable The circle is single use, and leaving it untouched past the end of Act 2 loses both the lantern and the blessing. Erasing it on first sight works, but leaves the journal entry for it unstarted.
Whether a promise here limits the choices you get at the very end wasn't traced.
Act Three
Your fate
The final battle
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
What decides how my story ends? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Two things you do in the city: reading the book, and going to the temple.
Hint 2
Unlike the companion, there's no hidden lean that decides for you. When the time comes, you choose.
Hint 3
Without the book, the crown isn't on the table at all.
Outcomes
Read the book and met Mystra
After the battle you're sent to face her. You can hand over the crown, then ask to be her Chosen again, go to Elysium, part ways, or decline for a partner's sake. Or become a god of ambition, or try to take her godhood.
Read the book, skipped the temple
You choose to claim the crown, reforge it for Mystra, or give it up: home to Waterdeep, seek Elminster, travel, write your memoirs, or celebrate.
During the final fight
You can still detonate the orb against the final enemy, as a sacrifice.
Missable The crown endings need you to have read the book before the final battle, and facing Mystra at the end needs the temple audience.
If you're the one who becomes a mind flayer, the journal records it as yours; if another player's character does, that entry doesn't appear for you. The ending choices come from dialogue and haven't all been seen in play.