You crawl out of the wreck with your master's hold on you broken, a secret to keep and a thirst to manage. How long your new friends stay in the dark is up to you, for a while.
Act One
Waking up free
The crash site
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How is my story different from recruiting Astarion as a companion?
Hint 1
There's no recruitment scene. Your journal opens the moment you wake up at the crash site.
Hint 2
You already know what you are, and you already have the bite. Look in your spells.
Hint 3
You also know your own weakness: you can't walk into someone's home unless you're invited.
If the bite ever goes missing, it's given back the first time you load each new region.
Act One
The first hungry night
Camp
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I woke from a bad dream at camp, and I'm starving. What are my options? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Nothing you say in the dream changes anything. The choice that matters comes after you wake.
Missable This night is cancelled for good if anyone learns what you are before it plays, for instance by watching you bite someone in a fight. If you've not had it by the time you travel to the githyanki creche or out of the Underdark to the Shadow-Cursed Lands, it's forced on you then, except in solo play.
Hint 2
You can go off and hunt an animal, or creep up on one of your sleeping companions.
Hint 3
Hunting is the safe choice. Feeding on a companion takes a quiet approach and some self-control, and a sharp tongue if they wake up.
Missable A companion can be lost for good here, killed by drinking too long or walking out after a failed Persuasion or Deception. Hunt an animal if you don't want to risk it.
Solution
Sneaking up takes Stealth DC 10. Pass it and you drink unseen; a Wisdom saving throw DC 5 then lets you pull away in time, and they wake weak and puzzled the next morning. Fail that save, or choose to keep drinking, and you kill them. Fail the Stealth check and they wake up: confess everything (no roll), or try Persuasion DC 10 or DC 15 to calm them, or Deception DC 20 to convince them it was a nightmare. A failed Persuasion or Deception means they walk out on the spot. In multiplayer, trying it on another player's character gets you nothing but a stare.
Outcomes
Hunt an animal
No risk to anyone. This is where the drained boars in the wild come from.
Feed unseen and stop in time
You feel good, they feel weak, and your secret holds for now.
Keep drinking
The companion dies, permanently, and their story ends with them.
Get caught, then confess or talk them round
They know what you are, and stay.
Get caught, then lie well
They believe it was a bad dream. The secret holds for now.
Get caught, then fail the roll
They leave the party for good.
That the stare only happens when the target is another player's character is inferred. Whether the night plays at all in solo play, with no companion to approach, isn't confirmed.
Feeding on Gale or Karlach didn't go to plan. Why?
Hint 1
Some companions aren't quite ordinary flesh and blood.
Hint 2
Gale's blood tastes foul, and he wakes up whatever you rolled. What he says depends on how much the party already knows about him.
Hint 3
Karlach runs far too hot to bite until her engine has had its second upgrade. The attempt just ends.
Gale isn't left weakened the next morning the way other victims are.
Act One
Keeping the secret
Anywhere in Acts 1 and 2
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
My companions want a word about what I am. Could I have kept it quiet? unverified
Hint 1
Only for a while. The truth comes out sooner or later.
Hint 2
Using your bite on a party member where a companion can see it gets you a talking-to. It also costs you 5 approval with whoever you bit.
Hint 3
If nobody has seen anything, the party corners you anyway on the mountain pass or on the way into the Shadow-Cursed Lands. Meeting a certain monster hunter with a companion close by does it too.
Solution
You can also come clean yourself in conversation with a companion, which counts as telling them the truth. Each companion has their own version of the confrontation; if the only other people in your party are other players, you just get a remark instead.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: his secret at camp
Confessing in a companion's dialogue, or reaching Rivington with nobody knowing, are the likely routes to the 'told them yourself' entry, but that's inferred.
Act One
The monster hunter
Near the Riverside Teahouse
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
A monster hunter on the road is asking about a pale elf. How do I play this?
Hint 1
The hunter, a Gur called Gandrel, doesn't know your face.
Hint 2
You can make an excuse and walk off, ask him questions, needle him, or tell him who you are. Telling him, or attacking, means a fight.
Hint 3
Mind who's standing near you. If a companion is within earshot when Gandrel names his quarry, they'll want an explanation.
Outcomes
Walk away
He goes on looking. There's no night visit to your camp in this version: he can't take you.
Reveal yourself or attack
A fight. Killing him updates your journal.
Who sent the hunter?
Hint 1
Same as in the companion version: the dead can still answer questions.
Hint 2
Cast Speak with Dead on Gandrel's body. You're the one asking, so you get the name.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: the monster hunter
Act Two
Another nightmare
Camp in Act 2
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
I had another nightmare at camp. Does anything I do in it matter?
Hint 1
Not for what happens next. It's a memory, and you can't change it.
Hint 2
You can study it closely, push it away, or let it run. Both of the first two are Intelligence DC 14.
Hint 3
Studying it is worth the roll if you want the story: you work out that what was carved into your back is Infernal writing.
It plays at any Act 2 camp. If it hasn't by the time you leave for Baldur's Gate, it's forced on you then, unless another scene can take its place. In this version there's no separate camp talk asking to see Raphael: the dream does that job.
Act Two
Seeking answers
Shadow-Cursed Lands
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Who can tell me what the marks on my back mean?
Hint 1
This plays as in the companion version, with you asking the questions.
Hint 2
Raphael, at Last Light Inn, over Mol's lanceboard game.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: seeking answers
If Raphael leaves the inn before you ask, the journal only notes it once you've had the second nightmare.
Raphael has an offer at the graveyard. Does it matter who talks to him? unverified
Hint 1
Not really. If you're anywhere nearby and able to talk, Raphael speaks to you, whoever walked up to him.
Hint 2
Otherwise it's the same deal at the Thorm Mausoleum entrance as in the companion version.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: seeking answers
In the companion version, Raphael can come to camp to make the offer if he leaves the graveyard without it. That visit runs through a companion conversation, so it's not confirmed that it happens when you're playing as Astarion.
Do I have to do what Raphael asks?
Hint 1
This plays as in the companion version.
Hint 2
His target is the orthon in the Gauntlet of Shar. Kill it for Raphael's answer, or don't.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: seeking answers
Act Three
Going home
Rivington and Wyrm's Crossing
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've reached the city. Is there anyone I should talk to first?
Hint 1
There's no one to talk you through it this time: the camp chat about your old master on the road belongs to the companion version.
Hint 2
Head into Rivington. People there know your name, or at least your face.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: going home
The Gur in Rivington recognise me. How do I stop this turning ugly?
Hint 1
You answer their leader, Ulma, yourself. Her grievance isn't really with you.
Hint 2
Promise to help get their stolen children back, and there's no fight.
Solution
A passive Religion check (DC 15) tells you more about the Gur. Agree to save the children for a peaceful result; refuse or attack and the camp turns hostile. Your companions can't side with Ulma against you here.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: the Gur
Two familiar faces are hiding in Fraygo's Flophouse. How do I get what I need from them? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Dalyria and Petras are your siblings in Cazador's service, and you're the one confronting them.
Hint 2
What you want from them is where Cazador's ritual will be held. Not every way through the conversation gets it.
Missable You can leave the flophouse without the ritual's location in this version. The palace route should still get you there, but that isn't confirmed.
Hint 3
Talking them round, or a show of force, can work. Playing along for a while is fine, but don't leave without the location.
Solution
Persuasion DC 15 or DC 18 can win them over, and an unarmed attack roll lets you drag Petras into the sunlight. Only some branches end with them giving up the location.
Which branches leave the location unrevealed isn't confirmed.
Act Three
Visitors in the night
Lower City camp
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Spawn attacked during a long rest in the Lower City. What do I do? unverified
Hint 1
You get your own version of this scene. They're spawn like you, and you can try to talk.
Hint 2
Stay on your feet in the fight. If you go down, they carry you off to the palace kennel.
Hint 3
If you're taken, you wake up in Godey's kennel, as in the companion version. Get out of that room.
Solution
You have Persuasion DC 15 (two different lines, one only if you don't yet know what the ritual is for), Deception DC 15, and Persuasion DC 20 if you do know what the ritual is for.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: visitors in the night
Every way out of the talk still leaves the spawn hostile, so what passing the checks changes isn't confirmed. Playing solo, being downed or taken here isn't a game over: they carry you off, and a forced rest follows.
Act Three
The palace
Cazador's palace, Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I get down to where Cazador is?
Hint 1
The route through the palace is the same as in the companion version.
Hint 2
Godey, in the hidden kennel, knows you of old. You can try to talk your way past him.
Solution
With Godey: Deception DC 15 or DC 20, Persuasion DC 15 or DC 20 (both need you to know what the ritual is for), or Intimidation DC 20.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: the palace
A prisoner in the cells seems to know me. How do I handle him?
Hint 1
His name is Sebastian, and he remembers you better than you remember him.
Hint 2
Try to remember who he is before you try to win him over.
Hint 3
Win him round and you'll learn how the cells are opened.
Solution
Passive Perception DC 15 picks up a detail. Intelligence DC 18 brings back his name, or read his mind with the parasite. Then Persuasion DC 20 or Deception DC 20 wins him over; get it wrong and he turns on you. The good branches tell you that Cazador's staff opens the cells.
Act Three
Facing Cazador
The chapel under the palace
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I win the fight in the chapel?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The fight is the same as in the companion version. The difference is what's at stake.
Hint 2
You roll your own Constitution save against the pull of the circle. It's much harder with an ally near you, oddly enough.
Hint 3
If Cazador completes the ritual, the story ends there: you're the sacrifice.
Missable If the countdown finishes, the game is over, not just this quest. Save before the chapel.
Solution
The save is Constitution DC 10 with no ally within 20 m, DC 18 if one is close, or you can give in. Otherwise, use the companion page's tactics for the pentagrams and the countdown.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: facing Cazador
The fight is over. What happens now?
Hint 1
It's your decision. Nobody needs to talk you into or out of anything.
Hint 2
You can finish Cazador's ritual yourself, or kill him and stay as you are. The costs are as in the companion version.
See also: The Pale Elf, the companion version: the fight is over
If you ascend, it counts as an ally for the final battle. Heading into the final battle with this unfinished closes the quest.