Act 3 · 31 journal steps · starts around the Rivington
The refugees of Rivington live on charity, and someone has slipped something nasty into the donations. Follow the trail from a guarded barn to a respectable doorstep, and further than you'd think.
Act Three
The Requisitioned Barn
Rivington refugee camp
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
There are two ends to this thread, and you can pick up either first: a barn full of donations in the refugee camp, and a house a short walk away.
Hint 2
The donations are kept in the Requisitioned Barn, guarded by the Flaming Fist under Manip Nestor. Something in there isn't what it seems.
Hint 3
The quest starts when you either find the suspicious crate in the barn, or read a letter locked in a chest in the basement of a merchant's house nearby. If you've read the letter first, talking to Manip Nestor at the barn points you at the donations.
The guard won't let me into the barn. How do I get in?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Manip Nestor, the Flaming Fist at the barn door, stops anyone he sees walking in. He'll listen to a good reason, though.
Hint 2
Evidence is the best reason. If you've already read the letter from the merchant's basement, he's easy to convince.
Hint 3
With the letter read, persuade Manip to search the donations with you. He then walks over and checks them alongside you, and nothing you find there can get you into trouble.
Missable If the toys set off an alarm while Manip hasn't agreed to investigate, your access is revoked and the barn becomes a trespass zone. Get his agreement first.
Solution
Talk to Manip Nestor. With the basement letter read: Persuasion DC 10 (an Oath of the Crown paladin can use Intimidation DC 10) gets you in and he joins the search. Without it: Persuasion DC 20 to carry a donation in yourself, or a Fighter can pose as a Fist with Deception DC 18. Both only get you in. If he catches you inside, telling him about the toys (if you've found them) makes him investigate; with only the letter, Persuasion DC 15 or Intimidation DC 18 works; anyone can try the pig story, Deception DC 20. Otherwise you're arrested, marched out, or fighting.
Which donations should I be looking at, and how do I handle them safely? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The quest's name is a clue. Look for a crate of toys, and don't be careless with it.
Hint 2
The crate of teddy bears in the barn is a trap. Keep your distance until you've dealt with it, and don't let it get hit.
Missable A Guild Artisan's background inspiration needs the toys found before the crate blows up. If it explodes first, that's lost.
Hint 3
Disarm the crate, or take all three bears out of it, which turns it into an ordinary empty crate. If it does go off, it's a big fire blast and it alerts the guards.
Solution
The toy crate is near the back of the barn. It's a trap: disarm DC 20, and an Investigation DC 15 check when you get close reveals what's inside. If it explodes it deals 12d6 fire in a 5 m radius (Dexterity save DC 15 for half) and sets the ground alight. Taking all three Surprise-Based Teddy Bears out disables the trap. Each bear is a throwable bomb (6d6 fire, 4 m radius, Dexterity DC 15 for half). If Manip Nestor didn't agree to investigate, the toys make a racket that alerts the guards, unless the crate, or Manip and the two nearby guards, are Silenced.
Whether the Investigation check fires on its own when you walk near the crate, and whether the toys' noise alone (without touching anything) alerts the guards, isn't confirmed in play. A Dark Urge being questioned near the toys can throw a bear at Manip, which turns him hostile.
Act Three
The house with the locked basement
A house in Rivington
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
There's an argument outside a house in Rivington. Does it matter?
Hint 1
It does, a little. How it ends decides where the owner of the house goes next.
Hint 2
Arfur Gregorio, a well-off toymaker, has hired some Guild muscle under Zenovia Dawg to throw a refugee family, the Golewits, out of his house. You can help either side, or neither.
Outcomes
Help evict the family
Zenovia's thugs (or you) chase the Golewits out, for free or for pay. Arfur moves back into his house, and you can find him there later.
Make Arfur let them stay
Intimidation or Persuasion, DC 10 to 25 depending on the line you pick. Arfur storms off to the Sharess' Caress taproom in Wyrm's Crossing, and the family is housed once you leave Rivington. You can also do this later in his own dialogue (Intimidation DC 10).
Fight
Attacking Arfur or Zenovia turns her thugs hostile.
Several background inspirations hang off this scene: Criminal, Folk Hero, Noble and Urchin. Once Arfur has confessed to the toys, intimidating him no longer sends him away.
How do I get into the house's basement? unverified
Hint 1
The toymaker's house hides its secrets downstairs, but the way down isn't obvious. Search the upstairs carefully first.
Hint 2
The way down is a hidden hatch in the workshop. Its key is tucked away upstairs, among the books.
Hint 3
In the basement, look for a heavy chest. Its key is lying loose nearby, but the chest itself is trapped. The letter inside is what you're after.
Solution
The upstairs door is locked (DC 10); its Silver Key is in a liquor shelf in the house. The basement hatch is in the workshop: it's hidden until you spot it, and locked at DC 18. Its key is hidden in a row of books on the upper floor. In the basement, the Heavy Chest is locked at DC 20 (its key lies loose in the basement) and trapped with a poison cloud, disarm DC 15. Read the letter inside. While you're upstairs, read the letter in the desk too: it tells you where Arfur Gregorio likes to spend his evenings.
That the hatch stays hidden until a Perception check (around DC 10) succeeds is read from its item settings; the check itself isn't confirmed in play. Reading the letter does nothing for the quest if Arfur is already dead; see the question about getting answers from him.
Act Three
Whoever made them
Rivington and Wyrm's Crossing
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I know who made the toys, but he isn't at home. Where is he?
Hint 1
Arfur Gregorio has a favourite haunt. His own correspondence gives it away.
Hint 2
Read the letter in the desk on the upper floor of his house. It's addressed to someone he visits often.
Hint 3
He's at the Sharess' Caress taproom in Wyrm's Crossing. Talk to him there.
He ends up there if you forced him to let the Golewits family stay in his house. The journal only mentions the taproom once you've read the desk letter.
I've caught up with the toymaker. How should I handle him? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You need both pieces of evidence, the toys and the basement letter, before you can accuse Arfur Gregorio.
Hint 2
He'll try to buy you off first. Turn him down if you want to know who's behind him.
Hint 3
Lean on him about who 'they' are. If he cracks, he names a shop in the Lower City, gives you a passphrase, and hands over his Coronation pass. Then decide what to do with him.
Missable The passphrase and the Coronation pass come only from the Intimidation DC 15 branch (Speak with Dead on his body gives the passphrase only). If you learn who's behind the shop before you confront him, for example because the shopkeeper senses your tadpole on a first visit, that branch is gone. The pass also gets you into the Lower City and counts towards the coronation later.
Solution
Accuse him, refuse the bribe, and ask who 'they' are: Intimidation DC 15. On a success he names Felogyr's Fireworks as the source of the explosives; ask further to get the passphrase and his Archducal Coronation pass. Then choose his fate. To send him to prison: Intimidation DC 15 or Persuasion DC 18 (Persuasion DC 10 if you know who's really behind the shop and that person is dead).
Outcomes
Take the bribe
He hands over all his gold (550 at the start) and vanishes for good. Any paladin breaks their oath. Charlatan and Criminal backgrounds get their inspiration.
Let him run, or take his gold and let him run
He leaves the game for good. Manip Nestor and the camp count the culprit as dealt with. An Oath of the Crown paladin breaks their oath.
Send him to prison
He's taken to a cell in Wyrm's Rock, where he's stripped of his weapon and gold and dies. The camp counts the culprit as dealt with. Speak with Dead on him there gets you very little. If the roll fails he begs, and you can let him go or kill him.
Kill him
He turns hostile. He's only a level 1 civilian. The camp doesn't count the culprit as dealt with, so you lose Manip Nestor's thanks and the Folk Hero inspiration.
Already been to the fireworks shop
If you learned at the shop who's behind it, you can say so and he admits it without a roll. This path gives you no passphrase.
Missable If he runs off or goes to prison without handing over the pass, pickpocket it or loot it from him first. In prison his gold is deleted. Killing him loses the camp's credit; letting him walk free costs an Oath of the Crown paladin their oath, and taking the bribe costs any paladin theirs.
Not confirmed in play: whether the prison ending reliably gets him to his cell (an older version could make him vanish instead); whether the pass is still on his body in the cell; and whether the pass actually arrives on the 'already been to the shop' branch, which narrates an offer but doesn't set the hand-over. Pickpocketing the pass is inferred from it being in his inventory.
I can't get answers from the toymaker. How do I pick up the trail?
Hint 1
Being dead doesn't stop everyone from talking.
Hint 2
Cast Speak with Dead on Arfur Gregorio's body. Asking where the explosives came from is enough.
Hint 3
If that isn't an option, the trail isn't lost: the blackmail letter from his basement already names the shop in the Lower City.
Solution
Speak with Dead on Arfur gives you the passphrase to Felogyr's Fireworks in one question, as long as you know about both the toys and the letter and haven't yet learned who's behind the shop. The corpse won't talk to whoever killed him, so have another party member cast it. Without the passphrase, go to Felogyr's Fireworks in the Lower City anyway.
Act Three
Felogyr's Fireworks
Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How do I get past the counter at Felogyr's Fireworks? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The ground floor is a shop, but the workshop behind it is guarded. They'll let in the right people.
Missable Visiting the shop before you confront the toymaker can cost you his passphrase: once you learn who's behind the shop, his Intimidation branch no longer gives it, or his Coronation pass.
Hint 2
Give the passphrase from the toymaker to Avery Sonshal, the shopkeeper, or to Feloguard Sigurd at the checkpoint. It opens the metal door to the middle floor.
Hint 3
No passphrase? Four of the staff carry a key to the Reinforced Metal Door, or you can pick its lock, or fight.
Solution
The passphrase unlocks the Reinforced Metal Door and lets you onto the middle floor legally. Without it: the door is lock DC 20, and a Fireworks Workshop Key is carried by Sigurd, Avery, Feloguard Maeve and Clerk Tamara. Past the middle-floor counter is staff only, and the top floor is off-limits even with the passphrase. If Avery senses your tadpole, he gives you a free sample and you can bluff that Gortash sent you (Deception or Intimidation DC 15; a failure can be saved at DC 18, with advantage for Sorcerers, Rogues and Barbarians) to learn about the orders.
Which characters Avery's tadpole check picks up (any tadpoled character, or only one who has used its powers) and how many free samples he hands over aren't confirmed in play.
What's on the top floor, and how do I deal with it? unverified
Hint 1
The top floor is where the real work happens, and you're not welcome there. Go up ready for a fight.
Hint 2
Walking in is trespassing, and talking to Tomboldt the Pallid, the alchemist in charge, starts a fight either way. Read the report lying about up there.
Hint 3
The room is full of smokepowder. Mind where you throw fire, and remember the guards downstairs join in.
Hint 4
The quest wants every one of the shop's eleven Banites defeated, and that includes the friendly shopkeeper downstairs, Avery Sonshal.
Solution
Upstairs: Tomboldt the Pallid (a level 9 caster), Black Gauntlet Uva (level 12), the Fists of Bane Hyrriet and Volgu Drak (level 10), and two level 6 workers. When the fight starts, Feloguard Maeve and Clerk Tamara come up from the middle floor. Killing any hostile Banite turns the whole lot against you. Nine smokepowder barrels and loose bombs lie around the floor. All eleven, Avery Sonshal included, must be defeated; the two customers don't count. If any are left standing but not dead, they flee at your next long rest.
That the smokepowder barrels detonate on fire is inferred from the barrel's normal behaviour; the script only shows a reaction downstairs when one takes fire damage. If Avery dies, a long rest relocks the metal door.
Act Three
Loose ends
Lower City and Wyrm's Crossing
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've dealt with the shop. Why is the quest still open? unverified
Hint 1
The quest has two halves, and the shop is only one of them.
Hint 2
Arfur Gregorio, the toymaker, still has to answer for his part. Find him and get his confession.
Hint 3
If he isn't at home, try the Sharess' Caress taproom in Wyrm's Crossing. The letter in his desk upstairs points there.
Solution
The quest closes when both the shop's Banites and Arfur are dealt with. Get him to confess, or, if he's already dead, the quest closes once you know about both the toys and the basement letter. Left alone, it closes on its own when the final stretch of the game begins.
That the automatic close happens at the start of the endgame is read from the flag's name and use.