Act 3 · 22 journal steps · starts around the Lower City
A dazed merchant outside a quiet Lower City charity can't remember his own life. The House of Grief promises to lift your sorrows, for a fee, and its back room asks some very personal questions.
Act Three
A charity for the sorrowful
Lower City, outside the House of Grief
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start? unverified
Hint 1
Look for a quiet building in the Lower City called the House of Grief, and the confused man standing near its door.
Hint 2
Talk to Arves, the merchant who can't remember who he is, and ask whether he has anyone to turn to. Or go in and ask the Attendant of Grief what the House does.
Hint 3
Either conversation opens the quest. Do both: Arves tells you what happened to him, and the attendant explains what being unburdened costs.
With Shadowheart in the party the attendant's conversation is replaced by Shadowheart's own scene. It isn't confirmed whether the quest then opens at the door, or only once you reach the back room.
Is there anything more to get out of the confused merchant?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Arves doesn't remember much, including what he owes and to whom.
Hint 2
You can claim to be collecting a debt from him. It's a lie, and it needs a good one.
Missable You get one try at the debt bluff. Fail it and the gold and the Black Diamond are gone.
Hint 3
Rogues lie to him more easily. So does anyone who has read his thoughts first, which gives you a name to drop.
Solution
Tell Arves you've come to collect a debt: Deception DC 20, with advantage as a Rogue or if you use the name you got from reading his mind. On a success, ask for 100 or 500 gold and he pays it. Ask for 2,000 instead and he says he doesn't have it; lean on him and he hands over a Black Diamond.
Act Three
The door at the back
House of Grief, front room
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
The attendant wants 1,000 gold to let me into the back. Is there another way? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Paying is the easy way. The man guarding the back door can be talked round too, and the door itself is only a door.
Hint 2
The sentry at the back door will listen to persuasion, threats or a lie. It goes much better if you already know who is really worshipped in this house.
Hint 3
The door is locked, but it can be picked, and keys to it are kept near the attendant's station. If Shadowheart is with you, the attendant lets you in without charging a thing.
Solution
Pay the attendant 1,000 gold and she shows you in. Or talk to the sentry: Persuasion DC 20 (with disadvantage unless you know the House is a Sharran front, with advantage if you know and worship Shar yourself), Intimidation DC 20 (disadvantage if you don't know about the cult; a Dark Justiciar gets advantage), or a Deception DC 25 claim that you already have permission, which sends him off to check at the attendant's desk. Or pick the back door's lock (DC 15) or take one of the two Grief Keys from beside the attendant's station.
Missable Each of the sentry's checks can be tried only once. Fail them all and you'll need the gold, the lock or the key.
Not confirmed: whether the sentry goes back to his post after the deception, and whether taking a Grief Key counts as theft (they sit inside the House's owned area, so it probably does). You can learn about the cult from Shadowheart's scenes at the Wyrm's Crossing refugee camp or at the House.
Act Three
The Mapping of the Heart
House of Grief, back room
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I sat on the bench and someone started asking me odd questions. Does it matter what I answer? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It's a test, and it matters more than it seems. Someone is taking notes on you.
Hint 2
Your five answers sort you into one of six types of heart, and the third question records what you fear most. Both are used against you later, if things come to a fight.
Missable The test runs once. Your heart type and your fear are fixed for the rest of the quest.
Hint 3
If you're perceptive, you'll notice your questioner reading your mind after the first answer, and you can call it out to end the test early. You're then judged on what you've answered so far.
Outcomes
Shadowheart is with you and you let her take the test
Shadowheart sits the Mapping in your place, and the way on opens when it's over.
Shadowheart is with you and you keep her back
You take the test yourself.
Shadowheart is in your party but not with you
At the end you're asked to bring her to the altar. The way down opens when she steps up to it, though the hidden button still works.
You finish the test without her
The altar sinks and the stone wall opens on the way down. You meet your questioner properly below.
Missable If Shadowheart isn't part of your party at all when the test starts (dead, gone or never recruited), or you drop her while you're being waited on, her scenes here are lost for good.
After keeping Shadowheart back, it isn't confirmed that the normal five questions follow, or that her later scenes stay available. The passive Perception check to spot the mind-reading is DC 18.
Which answers are safest in the Mapping? unverified
Hint 1
Think about the fear question most. What you name there is turned into a spell.
Hint 2
Some fears only hurt one person. Betrayal turns your own party against you, and spiders bring friends.
Hint 3
Your heart type decides a curse that can be put on you later. Each kind can be broken a different way, and some are much easier to break than others.
Solution
A safe set: Loneliness, To dominate, Darkness, Kill them, Restless. That makes you Violent (by a clear margin), whose curse ends when you're healed, and your fear Darkness, which only blinds one character. Other clear-cut sets: Melancholy (A wound, Indulge every hunger, To be without power, Forgive them, Restless; the curse breaks with Hideous Laughter, Otto's Irresistible Dance or a good Performance). False (An onion, Wealth and power, Betrayal, Fabricate a threat, Suspicious; breaks with Silence, but Betrayal is the worst fear for a full party). Craven's curse needs you to end a turn close to her without attacking or casting; Prying's needs you poisoned; Jealous's needs the Help action.
Scores worked out from the Mapping's scoring rules (scratch tools/solve_mapping.py). How each curse breaks is our reading of the status rules. That Darkness, Disease and powerlessness hit only the person who took the test, and that ties may set two heart types, are inferred.
Can I skip the questions, or force my way on? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The figure across from you isn't really there. And the altar in the room hides more than it shows.
Hint 2
Hurting the figure ends the test on the spot. Something else in the room speaks up, and the way on opens anyway.
Missable Attacking the projection ends the Mapping for good, and you'll be reminded of it below.
Hint 3
Search around the altar. A hidden button opens the stone wall without any of the questions.
Solution
Attack the projection with anything that does damage, and the wall opens once a carved bust has had its say. Or find the hidden button by the altar (DC 20) and press it. If the House has already turned hostile, the button shows itself when you step near it.
The button's check is flagged as Investigation in the item data; whether passive Perception also finds it isn't confirmed. Skipping the test means no heart type or fear is recorded, so the matching spells in the fight probably have nothing to work with.
Act Three
What waits below
Beneath the House of Grief
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Guards down here won't let me past. What now?
Hint 1
You aren't welcome yet. Someone further in decides who is.
Hint 2
Head for the training hall. Once the one in charge has dealt with you, one way or another, the guards let you through.
The one in charge confronted me and wants something. What are my options? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You can fight, or you can talk. Talking well gets you an offer, and the offer has a price.
Hint 2
Viconia DeVir, mistress of the House, is after the Astral Prism. Threats or an offer to stand together against the Absolute can make her listen. So can asking what her goddess thinks of her.
Hint 3
If you win her over, she asks for Shadowheart. You can promise to bring her, refuse, or, if Shadowheart is standing right there, hand her over on the spot.
Solution
Without Shadowheart present: Intimidation DC 20 (the artefact is bound to you), Persuasion DC 20 (unite against the Absolute), or ask about Shar, notice with passive Perception DC 7 that Viconia fears being replaced, then offer Shadowheart (Persuasion DC 20 with advantage). Any success leads to her demand for Shadowheart. If Shadowheart is dead or gone, a Persuasion DC 30 can still get you an alliance. Failing a check starts the fight.
Outcomes
Promise to bring Shadowheart
Viconia lets you go and you're free to move about the grotto. A sub-quest opens to bring Shadowheart back to her.
Hand Shadowheart over (she's with you)
Viconia's followers stand down, you're allied with her, and she backs you in the final battle. Shadowheart leaves the party for good; after your next long rest you find her in the grotto, a cultist with her mind wiped.
Alliance with Shadowheart dead (DC 30)
Same alliance and support, nobody handed over.
Refuse, attack or fail a check
The cult fights you.
Missable Surrendering Shadowheart can't be undone: she leaves your party permanently.
After the DC 30 alliance, the journal may still say Shadowheart was handed over. Not confirmed in play.
Act Three
Unfinished business below
Camp and the Shar Grotto
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I agreed to bring someone back to the grotto. What now? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You can be honest with Shadowheart about what you promised, or not.
Hint 2
Tell Shadowheart the truth in camp, or spin her a story about why Viconia wants to see her. How readily she believes you depends on how much she trusts you.
Hint 3
If she comes, Viconia offers the deal again in front of her. You can still say no and fight.
Outcomes
Tell Shadowheart the truth
She knows what she's walking into.
Lie to her
With high approval she goes along without question; with moderate approval, or some reassurance, she still agrees.
Hand her over
Shadowheart leaves the party for good and turns up later in the grotto with her mind wiped. You gain Viconia as an ally.
Change your mind and fight
Allowed. The journal skips straight to the end once Viconia falls.
Missable Handing Shadowheart over is permanent.
Approval thresholds from the dialogue: 40 or more, she trusts you outright; 20 or more (or after reassurance) she still agrees.
How do I win the fight in the grotto? unverified
Hint 1
She is a drow priestess who loves the dark. Don't give her any.
Hint 2
Viconia hits much harder outside clear light and hates sunlight. Bring light. She also starts protected, so strip that before you commit.
Hint 3
Remember what you told her in the Mapping. She can curse whoever matches your heart type, and her hits on a cursed target are critical. Break the curse fast.
Hint 4
Shadowheart can win over some of Viconia's followers before it starts. The quest ends when Viconia herself is beaten, not when every cultist is dead.
Solution
Viconia is level 11 with about 124 HP, Magic Resistance and Sunlight Sensitivity. She opens under Shield of Faith and Sanctuary. Her weapon hits add 4d8 necrotic when she isn't in clear light, and her darkvision sees through magical darkness. Once per combat she can call on divine intervention. Her fear spell uses a 4th-level slot and a Wisdom save. If Shadowheart is in the fight, Viconia can't be killed: she drops at 1 HP and Shadowheart decides her fate. Without Shadowheart you can kill or knock her out.
See also: Daughter of Darkness, swaying the followers, and sparing or killing her
Stats from the character and spell data. That lighting the field takes the necrotic bonus away is inferred from the passive's condition. Honour mode adds legendary actions.
Act Three
Leaving it be
Baldur's Gate
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
What if I never deal with the House of Grief? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The quest stays open for most of the act.
Hint 2
Head for the final battle with it unfinished and the quest closes, with the House still standing.
Missable Once you move on to the final battle, the quest can't be finished.
Not confirmed whether this closing line also appears on a quest you already finished.