Act 1 · 18 journal steps · starts around the Emerald Grove
Strange music drifts up from a little cove below the Emerald Grove, and a tiefling boy is standing in the surf listening to it. Help him, and the Grove's youngest residents won't forget it.
Act One
Music on the beach
A cove below the Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
My party keeps mentioning odd music. Where is it coming from?
Hint 1
Follow it downhill, towards the sea.
Hint 2
It comes from a small beach cove below the cliffs on the Grove's sea side. A young tiefling boy is standing in the shallows there.
Hint 3
Walk up to the boy with your own character, not a summon or a follower. If a summon or follower reaches him first, the scene skips straight to a fight.
The boy in the water won't snap out of it. How do I get through to him? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Whatever has hold of him can get hold of you too. Look after yourself first.
Missable Once you've seen him, don't take a long rest or let the whole party leave the Grove before this is settled. He dies offscreen if you do, and so does everything that follows from saving him.
Hint 2
Listening to the song closely gives you a passive Nature check. Pass it and you learn what the song is, which helps you resist it.
Hint 3
Shouting at him to come back does nothing. A Bard or a Barbarian can break the spell on him from the conversation itself. Everyone else has to deal with the singer.
Solution
First, resist the song: a Wisdom check (DC 5, with advantage if the Nature DC 10 check passed), or a Sorcerer's Charisma check (DC 5), or a Bard's Performance (DC 5). Fail and your character is charmed and wanders off towards the singer. Then, to free the boy: a Bard can finish the song with Performance (DC 10 with advantage if they started it while resisting, otherwise DC 5); a Barbarian can roar him out of it (Performance DC 10 with advantage). Either way the fight starts with him free. Any other route ends with him walking into the sea, and you have to act at once (see the next question).
Outcomes
Free him in the conversation
He's no longer under the spell when the fight starts, so he won't walk to his death.
Free only yourself, or leave
The singer arrives and he starts walking out to her. Attack straight away.
Pick his pocket (Sleight of Hand DC 5)
You get a pouch of 15 gold. Some companions react, and not kindly.
Missable The pickpocket chance only exists in this first conversation.
Which companions approve or disapprove of the pickpocket isn't confirmed. A wildshaped character gets a short version of the conversation with no checks, and a silenced one can only listen.
He's wading out to sea. How do I stop him? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Don't wait to see what happens. Start a fight.
Hint 2
Attacking the singer, or anything pulling her into combat, stops the scripted ending. So does walking up close to her perch while not hidden.
Hint 3
If he reaches her before the fight has started, he's killed on the spot a couple of seconds later. Attack from range the moment the conversation ends.
Missable If the boy dies here, his whole thread is gone: the thanks, the trail to the Grove's young thieves, and the gift he'd have given you. Reload if you want them.
How long his walk takes in play isn't measured, so how much time you have is unconfirmed. If you only ever find his body, the quest opens and closes on that.
The fight in the cove is going badly. Any tips? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Four of them, and the leader's song keeps pulling your people out of the fight. Silence that.
Hint 2
Silence is the hard counter: anyone standing in it can't be lured, and a silenced singer loses her song. Killing her clears it from everyone.
Hint 3
Don't worry about catching the boy in your own area spells. Your attacks can't drop him below 1 HP. Theirs can kill him, so keep them off him.
Solution
Four harpies, 24 HP and AC 11 each: two melee, two ranged. The leader opens with Luring Song, a concentration aura with 30 m reach. Anyone affected makes a Wisdom save each turn; failing it means losing the turn and walking towards her. Cast Silence on her or on your own group, or burst her down. When all four are beaten, the boy runs to you to talk. Keep someone inside the cove when the fight ends: that's what earns the gift he gives you later.
Missable To get the boy's gift later, a party member has to be inside the cove when the fight ends.
Damaging the singer should be able to break her concentration and end the song, but that isn't confirmed, nor is the song's save DC. The script also ends the encounter if the boy leaves the cove alive mid-fight, so getting him out (say, by teleporting him) may work instead of winning; not tested.
Is there anything else worth finding around the cove? unverified
Hint 1
The singers live somewhere nearby. Look up.
Hint 2
Their nest sits up the cliff, about 55 m south of the beach. It holds a Ring of Colour Spray, a gem, supplies and a couple of books.
Hint 3
There's also a wooden chest down on the beach, about 15 m east of the singer's perch, with some gold in it.
The climbing or jumping route up to the nest isn't confirmed, and the chest may be buried or hidden.
Act One
After the rescue
Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
The boy wants to talk to me. Does it matter what I say? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Yes. He's frightened, and how you treat him decides whether he trusts you.
Hint 2
Be kind to him and he'll tell you his name, Mirkon, and who to look for next. Be cruel and he runs off.
Hint 3
A kind answer gets you a name, Doni, and a password to use with him. That's the way to the Grove's hidden gang of young thieves.
Outcomes
Answer kindly
Mirkon names Doni and the password, then runs home. Gale has a short scene about his own childhood and approves. The young thieves treat you as friends, and their leader, Mol, hands back anything they stole from you without fuss.
Answer cruelly
He shrieks and flees. The quest closes there, with no Doni trail and no moment for Gale. He still runs home, and the thieves still count you as friends.
Never talk to him
He makes his own way home at the next long rest. You get no trail.
Later on
Mirkon stays with the other tiefling children through the Grove's troubles, then turns up at Last Light in Act 2, where Mol mentions you saved him, and at the refugee camp near Wyrm's Rock in Act 3. A Folk Hero gets their inspiration from this rescue.
Missable A cruel answer, or never speaking to him, loses the Doni trail and Gale's moment for good.
Coming back into the cove after the fight without having spoken to him also closes it as if he fled; whether he's still standing there to talk afterwards isn't confirmed. His later appearances depend on the tieflings surviving Act 1.
Mirkon told me to find Doni. Where is he, and what do I do?
Hint 1
Doni hangs about the Emerald Grove with the other tiefling children. He doesn't talk; he grunts.
Hint 2
Use the password Mirkon gave you. Don't get distracted by whatever Doni seems to be staring at.
Hint 3
Say the password and Doni opens a hidden hatch for you. Turn to look where he's staring instead, and he slips away into the rocks.
Solution
Doni is near the other tiefling kids and the pickpocket Mattis in the Grove. Ask to see the "Dragon's Lair" and he opens the hatch. If he slipped away: a passive Perception check (DC 10) shows you where he went, and Investigation (DC 10, advantage for Rangers and Rogues) finds the concealed entrance, though it won't open from outside. When you next meet him, Insight (DC 10) shows he's miming opening something; then Persuasion (DC 10), reading his mind with Detect Thoughts, or a bribe gets him to open it.
I'm in the young thieves' hideout. Is there more to this? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Talk to the girl in charge, Mol, before anything else.
Hint 2
Mol thanks you for bringing Mirkon home. Then find Mirkon himself in the hideout. He has something for you.
Hint 3
Mirkon has written a story about you, and Mol has told him to say thank you properly. Accept it.
Missable Mirkon's Story is only offered while the Grove is at peace, only if someone in your party was in the cove when the fight ended, and only once: turn it down and he keeps it.
Outcomes
Accept Mirkon's story
You get Mirkon's Story, a book that counts towards the achievement for reading books.
Decline it, or ask for gold instead
He keeps it, and the conversation ends.
Anger Mol
The children turn hostile and you can no longer speak to Mol about Mirkon. The quest closes.
Leave it too long
If the Grove's situation changes (the druids' ritual, the goblin raid) before you've spoken to Mol, the quest closes.
Missable Turning Mol and the children hostile, or letting the Grove's state change first, loses Mol's thanks.
No later chance to receive the story was found in the files. Mol's thanks seems to work even after the cruel answer, but that isn't confirmed.
Act One
Loose ends
Leaving the region
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I never went back to the beach. Can I still do this later? unverified
Hint 1
Not for long. The cove is a Grove problem, and it doesn't wait.
Hint 2
If you saw the boy and left him, a long rest or leaving the Grove settles it for you, badly. If you only heard the music, the quest closes when you leave the Act 1 map.
The journal entries for leaving Act 1 with this open may never actually appear, since the quest's script shuts down once the tieflings leave the Grove.