Acts 1–3 · 11 journal steps · starts around the Underdark
Something in the lava near Grymforge is laughing. Fish it out and you get a powerful amulet with a passenger, and a long walk to Baldur's Gate to see him home.
Act One
Laughter in the lava
Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
Search the dead on Grymforge's waterfront, not far from the duergar at the pier.
Hint 2
A group of Dark Justiciar skeletons lies there. One carries a journal, and some decent armour too.
Hint 3
The journal mentions an amulet that was thrown into the lava, and marks the lava lake below the ruins by the Adamantine Forge. Reading it is optional: finding the amulet starts the quest just as well.
The amulet is in a locked chest in the lava. How do I get it? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The chest won't break, so you need the key or a very good lockpicker.
Hint 2
The Adamantine Key is on a skeleton lying lower down in the lava, about 20 metres from the chest.
Hint 3
Expect fire on the way. Fire resistance, jumping and Misty Step between solid spots help. Lava Balloons keep popping up around you while you're in the lake; they burst into fire, so pop or avoid them.
Solution
Loot the Adamantine Key from the low skeleton near the chest, then open the Adamantine Chest. Without the key the lock is DC 20. The balloons do 2d6 fire and leave burning ground. They come from the Lava Elemental in the lake: it's vulnerable to cold, but leaving it alive is worth a little hidden experience when you pick up the amulet.
Missable If the Lava Elemental is dead before you first pick up the amulet, you lose a small hidden experience bonus for sparing it. Killing it does count for the Outlander's inspiration, so choose which you'd rather have.
Not confirmed in play: whether the elemental attacks on sight, how much solid ground there is in the lake, and how the balloons are triggered and saved against. The route advice is inferred from positions.
The amulet is talking to me. What does it want? unverified
Hint 1
Keep talking. There's a voice in there, and it has a request.
Hint 2
Ask the spirit where it wants to go. A Wisdom check (DC 10) lets you fight off the urge to laugh, and some classes and races get an easier version, but failing only makes you laugh.
Hint 3
The spirit wants to be taken to his granddaughter, Shirra Clarwen, at the Open Hand Temple in Wyrm's Crossing. That's a long way off, in Act 3.
Solution
If you ended the conversation without asking, wear the amulet and use its Talk to the Sentient Amulet spell to pick it up again. If you dropped it during the first talk, picking it up again replays the conversation.
What Shar clerics and paladins see instead of the resist-the-laughter option isn't traced.
Using the amulet makes my character laugh uncontrollably. Is it getting worse? unverified
Hint 1
Only the amulet's Shatter spell triggers it. Its Ki restoration and talk spell are safe.
Hint 2
Each Shatter cast calls for a Wisdom save. Fail, and you're helpless with laughter for a round. Pass, and the spirit's grip quietly grows.
Hint 3
After three successful saves (counted across the whole party), you get a scene where you can resist the madness or give in. Losing it raises the save for every later cast.
Solution
The save starts at DC 10. The resist scene is a Wisdom save at DC 10 the first time and DC 15 the second; fail or give in and the casting save rises to 15, then 20. Madness is tracked per character and never goes down. Never casting the amulet's Shatter avoids all of it. Once the quest is over in Act 3, the madness stops mattering.
Whether the scene ever fires for someone who never casts Shatter isn't confirmed in play (expected: no).
Act Three
The Open Hand Temple
Wyrm's Crossing
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've reached Wyrm's Crossing. Where is Shirra Clarwen? unverified
Hint 1
Go to the Open Hand Temple, wearing the amulet. The spirit will have something to say.
Hint 2
Ask Sister Yannis, the priestess at the temple, about Shirra. The question is there whatever stage the temple's own troubles are at.
Hint 3
Sister Yannis sends you below the temple. Shirra Clarwen is in the crypt under the temple, and you'll find her name on one of the tombs.
Solution
Shirra died the year before. Her tomb is in the crypt in the temple basement; reading her tomb plaque there tells you the same as Sister Yannis.
If you never asked the spirit where to go in Act 1, the temple comment fills the journal in, but whether the 'reached the temple' entry also appears then isn't confirmed. Nor is whether the crypt can be reached without any progress on the murder case.
Act Three
Below the temple
Open Hand Temple crypt
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I found the crypt under the temple. What now?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The spirit still wants to meet her, so the tomb has to come open.
Hint 2
The character who opens it must be carrying the amulet. Read the plaque first so you know it's hers.
Solution
Read the plaque on Shirra's tomb (the west one of the four), then open the lid with the character who has the amulet. Opening it before reading the plaque only opens the tomb; looting her or reading the plaque afterwards then sets things off. Before you open it, save your game: what follows is a choice.
Missable Once the spirit leaves the amulet, its original Shatter and Ki restoration are gone for good, whichever way the next choice goes. Use them while you can.
The spirit wants something from me in the crypt. What should I choose? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Find out the cost before you answer. You can ask, or try an Arcana check (DC 15).
Hint 2
He asks you to take on his madness. Saying yes means two mental checks, and a reward whatever the rolls. Saying no means a fight.
Outcomes
Accept the madness
Two Wisdom checks at DC 15 (or a Constitution check at DC 15, or a tadpole option at DC 10 for illithid-powered characters). Each failure costs a point of Wisdom, as a passive that nothing removes. Either way you learn Tasha's Hideous Laughter (once per long rest), the monk finds peace, and you keep an amulet with no powers.
Refuse
He turns on you and the party in the crypt starts the fight Surprised. Win, and he fades away still mad, but your amulet becomes a Very Rare one with a 3rd-level Shatter and full Ki Restoration, and no madness.
Back out after the first check
That counts as refusing: you get the fight, and any Wisdom you already lost stays lost.
Missable Hideous Laughter and the upgraded amulet are exclusive. Pick the one you want.
That the Wisdom loss is permanent comes from the scripts (nothing removes it); not tested in play. Companion approval for each answer isn't known.
How do I win the fight in the temple crypt? unverified
Hint 1
Watch which body the spirit is in. That's the only one that matters.
Hint 2
When the body he's in drops to half health, he jumps to another one and heals it heavily. Knock out the body he's in, and all the others fall with him.
Hint 3
Either burst him from above half health to zero in a single round, or kill the other bodies first so he has nowhere to jump.
Solution
There are four bodies, each with 76 to 92 hit points, immune to poison. The spirit starts in Shirra's body. He checks for a jump at the start of his own turn, so damage between his turns doesn't trigger it. Ignore the others unless you're cutting off his escape. When the possessed body goes down, the fight is over.
Tactics are inferred from the fight script, not tested in play.
Act Three
The quest failed
Anywhere
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
My journal says the quest has failed. What happened?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Two things end it: losing the amulet, or moving on too far.
Hint 2
If the amulet is left somewhere you can never go back to, the spirit's story is over. So is it if you leave Wyrm's Crossing behind for the final act without finishing.
Missable Keep the amulet with you, not in a chest or on the ground somewhere you're leaving, and finish the crypt before you head into the endgame.