Act 1 · 17 journal steps · starts around the Wilderness
A ruined chapel on the cliffs near the crash site has a crypt nobody has managed to open. The grave-robbers camped outside would very much like to know what's down there. So, probably, would you.
Act One
Rumours of the ruins
Crash site, Emerald Grove
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
You'll probably walk into it. The ruins are on the cliffs, a short way from the wreck.
Hint 2
Shadowheart, if you find her at a locked door in the cliff, mentions she was hoping for supplies inside. The bandits camped by the ruins will tell you about it too.
Hint 3
There's also a book in the druids' lair at the Emerald Grove that points to a hidden cache in ruins south of the Grove. Going inside starts the quest as well.
There's a gang camped outside. Do I have to fight them?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
No. How you approach them matters. Come up the path past the statue and they'll stop to talk.
Missable You only get one conversation with them. If it ends in a fight, the peaceful outcome is gone. Save before you walk up.
Hint 2
If they spot you from somewhere else, they may just attack. Coming from inside the chapel, or from the west, gets you a different conversation.
Hint 3
They're grave-robbers who've failed to break into the crypt. Tell them the crash brought something dangerous their way, and they may decide it isn't worth it.
Solution
On the main approach: Persuasion DC 10 (the ship was full of monsters), Deception DC 12 (it's an invasion), or Intimidation DC 10. Barbarians and Astarion get advantage on the Intimidation, and the Dark Urge has a Strength DC 5 option. Some classes and races get lines that scare them off without a roll. From inside, Intimidation DC 10 or Deception DC 12 works; from the west, the same three checks as the main talk. Scared bandits leave, and you still get experience for it.
Outcomes
Talk them away
They leave alive and you get the peaceful-resolution experience.
Fail a threat, or attack
They fight. A failed threat starts the fight as soon as the conversation ends.
Drop the boulder on them
Anyone standing on the cracked platform under it takes 50 damage. It also opens a way inside (see below).
How do I get inside?
Hint 1
There's more than one way in. Walk all the way round the ruins, including the cliffs below.
Hint 2
The front door upstairs is guarded and locked. There's a cracked stone platform in the courtyard with a boulder above it. Down by the cliffs there's the crypt door Shadowheart was stuck at, and there's a hatch too.
Hint 3
The front door's lock is easy, but the guard behind it will want to know who's there. The boulder can be dropped through the platform to make a hole you can jump into. The crypt door and the hatch are hard locks, but both can be opened from inside.
Solution
Front door: lockpick DC 7, or get the guard, Andorn, to open it (see the next question). Boulder: hit it with almost any damage, or destroy the coiled rope vines holding it; when it falls on the platform, the platform breaks and you can jump down into the upper floor, even in combat. Crypt door: lockpick DC 20 outside (DC 15 from inside); one of the crypt's skeletons carries its key. Hatch: lockpick DC 20, or pull the lever beside the ladder from inside, which unlocks it and drops the ladder.
Someone behind the front door is asking who I am.
Hint 1
He's expecting his friends from outside. Think about what one of them might say.
Hint 2
Pretend to be one of the gang outside, or tell him something has happened to one of them. Gimblebock is a good name to drop.
Solution
Deception DC 10 (say Gimblebock set off a trap), or Performance DC 10 to imitate Gimblebock's voice. Either one unlocks both entrance doors and he waits for you. Telling him you killed his friends, or that Gimblebock ran, scares him instead: he locks down, turns hostile and may arm a blast mine by the entrance. Walking in through an unlocked door without talking to him first catches him by surprise.
Outcomes
Fool him
The doors open and he waits, unsuspecting, for his friend.
Scare or threaten him
He goes on alert, may set a mine at the entrance, and joins the others for a fight in the corridor.
Act One
The living quarters
Ruins, upper floor
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
This door won't open and can't be picked. How do I get through?
Hint 1
Lockpicks won't help. Look at what's on either side of it.
Hint 2
There's a candle on each side of the door, both unlit.
Hint 3
Light both candles. There's also a lever further in, in the inner sanctum, that does it for you.
Solution
Light both candles beside the door with any fire source (a torch, a fire cantrip, or anything that leaves something burning). The door unlocks and swings open. If either candle goes out, the door shuts and locks again. The lever in the inner sanctum lights both candles at once. Through the door, the stairs lead down to the crypt.
The bandits upstairs keep overwhelming me. unverified
Hint 1
There are six of them, split between the corridor and the inner sanctum, and alerting one brings the rest.
Hint 2
Fight on ground you choose. They're carrying poison, alchemist's fire, javelins and a Burning Hands scroll, and they may plant a mine at the front entrance.
Hint 3
Fooling the guard at the door gets you in without the alarm. A metal gate inside opens and shuts with either of the two levers next to it, which can split them up.
Splitting them with the gate is our suggestion from the layout; the gate and levers are confirmed, the tactic isn't tested.
Act One
Below the chapel
The crypt
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
There's a sarcophagus in a room full of vents and gargoyle heads. unverified
Hint 1
That room is a trap, and the sarcophagus is its trigger.
Hint 2
Check it for traps before you open it. It's worth it: there's a magic spear and a key inside.
Hint 3
Disarm the sarcophagus first (DC 10). There's also a button in the room that should switch the trap off.
Solution
The sarcophagus holds The Watcher's Guide (a spear) and the key to the sacred-room door. That door can also be picked, DC 10. A soul coin lies loose in the same room.
That opening the sarcophagus sets the trap off, and that the button switches it off, is inferred from how the objects are linked; not confirmed in play.
I've been through the whole crypt. Is that it? unverified
Hint 1
No. Some walls aren't walls. Have a careful look around the skeleton hall.
Hint 2
There's a hidden button near the end of the crypt. You need to be close to spot it, so walk slowly along the walls with someone perceptive.
Hint 3
Pressing it opens a hidden alcove. Get ready for a fight before you press it.
Solution
The button opens a stone wall into an alcove holding a large sarcophagus and a heavy chest with The Amulet of Lost Voices. Pressing it also wakes the five skeletons in the hall (so does moving any of their bodies). See the next question for the fight.
The button is hidden with a detection value of 7 within 3 m; that this is a plain Perception check isn't confirmed.
The big sarcophagus won't open. What does it want?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Listen to what you're told when you try. The crypt's dead aren't resting yet.
Hint 2
The skeletons in the hall have to go first. All five of them.
Hint 3
Once they're destroyed, open the sarcophagus and talk to whoever is inside.
Solution
There are four Entombed Scribes (spellcasters, AC 10) and one Entombed Warrior (AC 16, much tougher). All five are vulnerable to bludgeoning and immune to poison, so bring a mace, hammer or club and leave the poison at home. Kill the Scribes quickly. One of them drops the key to the crypt door outside. When all five are down, the sarcophagus opens.
Outcomes
Answer his question however you like
His name is Withers. None of the answers changes anything: he's satisfied either way, leaves the tomb, and later moves to your camp for good.
Attack him
Nothing happens. He can't be hurt and doesn't care. The conversation ends without its usual journal entry, but he still comes to camp.
Missable Meeting him here closes off the plaque route (the next section). Nothing of value is lost either way.
Act One
After the crypt
Camp
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
The crypt is quiet now. What happens next? unverified
Hint 1
Leave the crypt and get on with your adventure.
Hint 2
Once you've left that part of the crypt, Withers heads for your camp. He turns up after your next long rest.
Hint 3
Talk to him at camp to finish the quest. He offers useful services from then on, including bringing dead companions back for gold.
If you attacked him in the crypt, finishing the quest by talking to him at camp is inferred, not confirmed.
I found the great sarcophagus already open. What now?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Someone got there before you, or got out. Read the plaque beside it.
Hint 2
Its occupant may already be at your camp: he goes there on his own if you reach the goblin camp entrance, or travel on to later regions, without having met him.
Hint 3
Once you've met him at camp, read the plaque, then ask him about it.
Missable The plaque only counts after you've met him. Read it too early and nothing happens, but you can read it again later.
Is there a deadline? unverified
Hint 1
Only the end of Act 1. He comes to your camp eventually whatever you do.
Hint 2
Take everything you want from the chapel before you head on to the next act: The Watcher's Guide, The Amulet of Lost Voices and three soul coins.
The quest closing at Act 2's point of no return is confirmed; that the chapel is unreachable afterwards is inferred.