Act 2 · 13 journal steps · starts around the Last Light Inn
A Flaming Fist lies in a bed at Last Light, singing the same little song over and over. Bring him back to himself and he may tell you where he has been.
Act Two
The singing Fist
Last Light Inn
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Who is the man singing in a bed at Last Light?
Hint 1
Talk to him, even though he won't really talk back. That's enough to start this quest.
Hint 2
His name is Art Cullagh, a Flaming Fist. If you rescued Counsellor Florrick in Act 1, she's at the inn too, along with a Fist called J'ehlar who has been looking after him. Florrick will tell you about him if you haven't met him yet.
Hint 3
He's been lost in the shadow curse for a very long time, and his mind hasn't fully come back. Your job is to find something that reminds him who he is.
What's wrong with Art Cullagh, and how do I find out?
Hint 1
Examine him from every angle the conversation offers: his body, the magic on him, and that song.
Hint 2
Medicine tells you he needs a reminder of his old life. Arcana explains where his mind has gone. Look at his hands, and think about who writes a song like that.
Hint 3
He was a musician, and he's missing his instrument. Once you know that, the conversation lets you use it later. Also listen to the name in his song: if Halsin has already told you about Thaniel, you or a companion will pick up on it.
Solution
All checks are DC 14 unless noted. Medicine: he needs something from his past. Arcana (advantage for Sorcerers): the Shadowfell has hold of his mind. Clerics can commune with his soul (Wisdom, advantage): he has lost a treasured object. With J'ehlar there, Investigation DC 10 on a closer look finds string calluses on his fingers, and saying the tune sounds original lets you ask if he's a musician. Without her, History identifies the song as his own, which opens the same question. Bards get options with no roll at all. Any of these tells you it's a lute he needs.
Is there anything on Art Cullagh that says who he was?
Hint 1
Soldiers carry orders.
Hint 2
If J'ehlar is there, ask her whether anyone checked his belongings, or just go to leave. She hands you his papers. If you're on your own with him, look around the bed when the conversation ends.
Hint 3
It's his Writ of Command. Read it: it says he was sent to look into the House of Healing in Reithwin.
Solution
Without J'ehlar, each character gets one Perception check (DC 14) at the end of a conversation with Art to spot the writ. If everyone fails, ask Halsin for advice once he's at the inn and he tells you to search him, which reveals it. You don't need the writ to wake Art; it just points you to the right place.
Act Two
A second opinion
Camp and Last Light Inn
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Is there anyone who could help with Art Cullagh?
Hint 1
Someone in your camp knows a great deal about the curse on this land.
Hint 2
Tell Halsin about the Fist at Last Light. He goes straight to the inn and waits by Art's bed.
Hint 3
Talk to Art with Halsin there and Halsin joins the conversation. He recognises the name in Art's song. Ask him for ideas and he tells you what Art needs; he can also take the writ from J'ehlar for you, or tell you what to do with the lute once you have it.
I know what Art Cullagh needs. Where is it? unverified
Hint 1
Follow his orders to where he was last sent.
Hint 2
The House of Healing in Reithwin. The surgeon there, Malus Thorm, has kept a souvenir.
Hint 3
Malus Thorm carries a battered lute with Art's initials on it. Take it off him, one way or another.
Solution
Defeat Malus Thorm and his four assistants and the lute drops when he dies, or pickpocket it from him. If you find it before you ever meet Art, carry it when you first speak to him and the quest picks that up. A shadow you kill in Reithwin's central square also drops a shadowstone whose memory shows Art with his lute, if you need a clue.
The lute is flagged as pickpocketable, but whether stealing it works cleanly, or starts the fight anyway, hasn't been checked in play. Also: if you pick up the lute after meeting Art but without ever reading the writ, no journal entry marks it. You can still wake him once he's told you about the lute.
Act Two
Waking Art
Last Light Inn
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
I've found what Art Cullagh needs. How do I wake him?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The character who talks to him needs to be the one carrying it.
Missable Art can be lost for good before he wakes: if Last Light falls to the shadows, or if you finish things at Moonrise Towers while he still sleeps, he dies. Wake him before either.
Hint 2
Play it for him. The option only appears if that character holds the lute and you've learned that it matters, from examining him, from the writ and the House of Healing, or from Halsin.
Hint 3
It goes best with Halsin at the bedside. What Art saw on the other side matters most to him.
Outcomes
Wake him with Halsin there
Art recognises Halsin and describes where Thaniel is held: a place that shifts, but always smells of lavender. Halsin asks you to meet him at the lakeshore, and his curse-lifting quest moves on.
Wake him without Halsin
Art tells you about Thaniel and asks you to fetch Halsin. Tell Halsin at camp, then talk to Art again once Halsin is at the inn; the scene carries on as above.
Halsin is dead, or was left behind in Act 1
Telling Art so leaves him in despair, and the quest closes there. Only pick this if it's true.
Later
Art turns up again after the battle at Moonrise Towers. Once the curse is lifted he'll trade with you, and if he survives you may hear from him in Act 3. Waking him also counts towards background inspiration for Entertainers, Nobles and Sages.
Can this quest go wrong?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Art Cullagh is in no state to defend himself. Keep fights well away from his bed.
Hint 2
If he's knocked down before he wakes, he doesn't get back up. Events at Last Light later in the act can also cost you him.
Missable Art dies for good if he's knocked down or killed before waking, if Last Light falls in the siege, or if you reach the aftermath at Moonrise Towers without having woken him. Speak with Dead still saves Halsin's lead, but the waking scene and everything after it are gone.
Hint 3
Even then, the most important thing he knows can still be learned, if you have a way to talk to the dead.
Solution
If Art dies, cast Speak with Dead on him. Ask what happened to him first; that unlocks the question about where he was held, and he describes Thaniel's lavender-scented prison. Take that to Halsin at camp. The character who killed him can't question him, so have someone else cast the spell.