Two men are shouting at an old woman. Whose side should I take? unverified
- Hint 1
Look around before you weigh in. Something is lying on the ground a few steps away.
- Hint 2
The brothers, Demir and Johl, are looking for their sister Mayrina. The note on the ground is hers, and it says a good deal about where she went and why.
- Hint 3
Pay attention to the old woman's story. A sharp eye (passive Insight) can tell she isn't being honest, and it's easier once you've seen through the woods around her home.
- Hint 4
Whatever you choose, Demir and Johl don't survive this quest. Don't reload trying to save them; there's no branch where they live.
- Outcomes
- Side with the old woman
- Demir and Johl attack you and you have to fight them. She thanks you and vanishes, and greets you as her hero when you reach the tea house.
- Side with the brothers
- She vanishes and her disguised creatures turn on you. The brothers talk to you, refuse your help and run on ahead. Once they're out of sight, or after your next long rest, they're found dead.
- Walk away
- The old woman kills both brothers on the spot with magic and leaves.
- Start a fight mid-scene
- She vanishes, and the brothers die soon after unless you sided with her.
- Skip the scene entirely
- If you reach the tea house before this argument plays out, the brothers are killed off-screen.
- Later, at the tea house
- If you killed the brothers yourself, you can confess to Mayrina or try to pin it on her host (Deception DC 15). A confession sours Mayrina's mood later on, and can turn her against you at the very end.
Insight check: passive DC 19, with advantage once the woods illusion is broken. Speak with Dead on either brother also counts as having spoken to them. It isn't confirmed that the 'brothers died' journal entry appears if you sided with them, or that the quest shows in the journal at all before you've spoken to them or reached the tea house.