Act 2 · 8 journal steps · starts around the Shadow-Cursed Lands
A grim stranger with a raven on his shoulder wants a dead barkeep put on trial, and he wants you to be the judge. What kind of judge you turn out to be is up to you.
Act Two
A stranger with a raven
Shadow-Cursed Lands, near Oliver's house
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
How does this quest start?
Hint 1
Look out for a kneeling figure with a raven beside him, out in the cursed lands rather than in Reithwin itself.
Hint 2
He's a shadar-kai called He Who Was, crouched over a dwarf's body not far from three dead Harpers and Oliver's house. Walk close and he'll start talking to you.
Hint 3
He wants the dead woman, Madeline, judged for betraying her friends, and needs a ledger she kept. Agree to fetch it and the quest begins.
Solution
Accept his offer in any form (plain agreement, asking what he needs, or asking to be paid all work). If you turn him down, nothing is lost: talk to him again later and you can still take the job.
Act Two
The barkeep's ledger
The Waning Moon, Reithwin
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
Where is Madeline's ledger? unverified
Hint 1
She ran a bar. Go to the one in Reithwin.
Hint 2
The Waning Moon distillery. The brewer, Thisobald Thorm, and his undead staff are in the same building, so expect company.
Hint 3
It's hidden under a loose floorboard on the ground floor, near the rat catcher. You need to be within a few metres and pass a passive Perception check to spot it.
Solution
On the Waning Moon's ground floor, look for a loose plank near the rat catcher (passive Perception DC 10, within about 4 m). Madeline's Ledger is inside. When you leave the distillery with it, his raven turns up to remind you to bring it back.
The level data also lists the ledger loose near the brewer's diary and chest, deeper in the building. The plank should take priority, but if the plank is empty, check there.
Act Two
The trial
Shadow-Cursed Lands, near Oliver's house
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
I've brought the ledger back. What happens now?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Give it to He Who Was. He'll tell you what it reveals, and then ask how you mean to treat Madeline.
Hint 2
He speaks for her spirit himself, so he needs to keep hold of the ledger until the ritual begins. Leave his pockets alone.
Missable If you pickpocket the ledger back from He Who Was before the ritual, he can't summon her, the job is abandoned and he leaves. The reward is lost for good.
I'm her judge. Which verdict should I give? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about whose body her spirit is speaking through.
Hint 2
He Who Was wants her to suffer. He pays only if he gets a verdict he likes, and he takes a dim view of mercy.
Hint 3
Calling her a coward pays out whether your Persuasion check passes or fails. Asking her to atone in kind also pays, as long as you know when to stop.
Missable The Raven Gloves come only from the paid ending. They're lost for good if you forgive her successfully, push past two stabs, attack or kill He Who Was or his raven, move Madeline's body, or let him lose the ledger. The reward goes to whoever finishes the conversation.
Outcomes
Condemn her as a coward (Persuasion DC 10)
Pass or fail, she fades away and He Who Was pays you: gold and the Raven Gloves. Barbarians, Bards and Monks get their own version with advantage.
Tell her to hurt herself as her friends did (Persuasion DC 14; DC 6 for an evil Cleric)
If the roll fails, she fades and you're paid. If it passes, she starts stabbing, but it's his body taking the wounds: each stab costs him about 7% of his hit points. Tell her to stop after two and he's amused and pays you. Ask for more (Persuasion DC 14 with advantage, or DC 16) and he turns on you whether the roll passes or not.
Stop her once she's shown she's willing
That counts as forgiving her. See the next option.
Forgive her (Persuasion DC 10)
If it passes, she's at peace and He Who Was is furious: a fight, and no reward. If it fails, she fades in grief and he pays you anyway.
Dark Urge who has killed a favourite companion
A special line drives her to despair. You're paid, with a veiled threat on the way out.
Attack him before the ritual
A straight fight. The quest closes once you've seen his body.
Missable Paladins can break their oath here. Most oaths break if you condemn her, make her stab herself, or fail the stab-yourself check. Oath of Vengeance breaks instead if you forgive her after the knife, or choose to kill He Who Was. Plain forgiveness breaks no oath.
Which companions approve of which verdict isn't in our data. Acolytes get a background inspiration for helping him, and a different one for refusing him in any way; we haven't confirmed you can't get both.
Act Two
If it comes to blows
Shadow-Cursed Lands, near Oliver's house
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
How dangerous is He Who Was in a fight? unverified
Hint 1
Keep your distance. His melee hits are the real threat, and his raven fights alongside him.
Hint 2
Each spear hit adds 4d12 necrotic damage, and he attacks twice. Standing within 3 m of him gives most creatures disadvantage on every save except Constitution. Elves are immune to that.
Hint 3
When you hurt him, he uses his reaction to turn invisible. He also has Bane, Fear, Darkness and Confusion, but few spell slots. He has 76 hit points; the raven has 18 and can blind you.
Solution
Fight at range, keep spread out, and bring a way to deal with invisibility (See Invisibility, Faerie Fire, or area damage). Kill the raven early if it's blinding your casters, but note that if the raven dies and he survives, he vanishes when combat ends. If you pushed the knife ritual before the fight, he starts it already missing roughly a fifth of his hit points.
Stats from his character and spell data. The counters to invisibility are general advice, and the 'missing a fifth' figure is arithmetic from three stabs at 7% each.
Act Two
Loose ends
Shadow-Cursed Lands
This part contains spoilers for Act Two.
He Who Was has gone and the quest closed. What happened? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about what you did to him, his raven, the body, or the ledger.
Hint 2
He leaves if Madeline's body is moved away from where it lay, if his raven dies and he survives a fight, or once the job is done. If he loses the ledger before the ritual, he gives up and leaves.
Missable Don't carry, throw or push Madeline's body, and don't harm the raven. Either one ends the quest without the Raven Gloves.
Hint 3
The quest also closes if you kill him, or if you move on to Act 3 with it unfinished.
There's also a greeting where he says Madeline has fled, after a ritual that was started and then interrupted. We haven't confirmed what interrupts it in play.
Can I question Madeline's body or loot it? unverified
Hint 1
Speak with Dead won't help: she has nothing more to say.
Hint 2
Her body belongs to He Who Was as far as the game is concerned, so taking from it counts as stealing from him.
The ownership is from the script; whether looting her in his sight starts trouble isn't confirmed.