Act 1 · 35 journal steps · starts around the Underdark
A drow True Soul is sealed behind a rockfall in the duergar dig at Grymforge, and everyone in camp wants the rubble gone for reasons of their own. Find the firepower to clear it, then decide whose side you're on when the dust settles.
Act One
A dig in trouble
Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Everyone here keeps talking about the rubble. How do I get involved?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go and look at the cave-in itself, at the back of the dig where the gnomes are working.
Hint 2
Touch the rubble. Someone on the other side reaches into your mind: True Soul Nere, a drow who is trapped in there with a few gnome slaves.
Missable Touching the rubble starts a clock: Nere is running out of air. See the question about a time limit before you leave Grymforge or take a long rest.
Hint 3
You can also get the job from Sergeant Thrinn, the duergar running the dig. Ask her how the work is going.
Solution
Interact with the rubble to mind-meld with Nere, or talk to Sergeant Thrinn. During the mind-meld, a Perception check (DC 10) lets you see more through Nere's eyes, which gives you an extra line to use with the gnome diggers later.
Is there a time limit? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about what the air must be like behind a sealed rockfall.
Hint 2
Yes, but only once you have touched the rubble. Until then, nothing is counting down.
Hint 3
After that, the first time you leave Grymforge or take a long rest, you get a warning. The second time, it's too late.
Missable Leaving or long resting a second time after the warning loses the whole confrontation, the Spider's Lyre, Nere's dagger, any payout from the mercenaries, Philomeen's vial if you haven't got it, and the chance to save the trapped gnomes. Don't rest or leave until the rubble is down.
Solution
After the mind-meld, the first time the whole party leaves Grymforge, or takes a long rest, Nere warns you that the air is going bad. The next time, with the rubble still standing, the dig is abandoned: Nere suffocates, the duergar and the gnome workers are gone, and the rubble has been cleared without you. Once you get the warning, finish the job before your next long rest or trip away. Separately, everything here closes when you cross into Act 2.
From the dig's script. Not confirmed: whether a long rest anywhere on the Act 1 map counts (the script checks the whole map, not just Grymforge), or only rests nearby.
Brithvar and Kur want a private word. What do they want? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The two duergar guards aren't as loyal as their sergeant. Hear them out before the rubble comes down.
Missable The mercenaries only have this conversation once, and only while the rubble is still standing. Both of them need to be nearby.
Hint 2
Brithvar can tell you carry a tadpole and takes you for a True Soul. Lie convincingly, read his mind, or fight. If you keep talking, he has an offer.
Hint 3
Brithvar wants Nere freed so that his crew can kill him and take his gold. He offers you a cut. You can haggle, and you can ask him where to find explosives.
Solution
Several Deception checks at DC 10 get you through his suspicion; Detect Thoughts and a deep gnome option help too. Accept the deal to get the job. Haggling for half is Persuasion DC 10 (Rogues have advantage) and pays more later. If the scrying eye is still floating around, Brithvar asks you to destroy it first. Ask him for a lead and he points you to a runaway gnome. Telling Thrinn about the plot, or starting a fight, sets off a skirmish.
Outcomes
Take the deal, with the eye destroyed before the blast
Rebel reinforcements join the fight against Nere in the second round. Afterwards Brithvar pays your cut from Nere's gold: 400, or 500 if you haggled.
Take the deal, eye still alive
Nere's masons join instead of the rebels. Afterwards Brithvar says the eye saw everything, calls the deal off and demands 500 gold from you. Pay, talk him out of it with Intimidation or Persuasion (DC 10), or fight him.
Refuse, or tell Thrinn
Telling Thrinn or attacking starts a fight with the mercenaries now. Refusing leaves them as a wild card when Nere comes out.
Which of the two payouts (400 or 500) goes with the haggle is inferred from the dialogue order.
Act One
Find Explosives
Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I hit the rubble and nothing happens. What can break it? unverified
Hint 1
Swords and spells aren't going to do it. This needs something bigger.
Hint 2
The rubble ignores any single hit that isn't very heavy, and most damage types don't touch it at all.
Hint 3
You need explosives. Smokepowder or runepowder, and enough of it.
Solution
The cave-in has 44 hit points and ignores any hit under 22 damage. Only bludgeoning, force and thunder hurt it. In practice: one smokepowder barrel always clears it; one smokepowder satchel never does on its own, but any two always do; Philomeen's runepowder vial clears it on its own every time. Pile the explosives at the rubble, back off, and set them off with fire or a hit (the mercenaries suggest a fire arrow). The smaller rockfall elsewhere in Grymforge, where the duergar are bullying a rothé, is a separate obstacle and can be broken with ordinary force.
The numbers are worked out from the game's damage formulas. Not confirmed in play: whether a single very big hit (a crit, say) of 22 or more can chip it without explosives.
Where can I get explosives?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Listen to the gnome diggers near the rubble. Two of them, Lunkbug and Laridda, are arguing about something.
Hint 2
One of their crew set off a blast and ran off with powder. They know where the gnomes hide.
Hint 3
Get Lunkbug to talk. He marks the runaway sapper's hiding place on your map.
Missable Ask Lunkbug for payment before he tells you about Philomeen, or you miss the Scroll of Revivify. The gnomes stop having this conversation once the rubble is cleared.
Solution
Eavesdropping on Lunkbug and Laridda is Perception DC 10. Getting them to open up is an easy Persuasion or Intimidation check (DC 5); Barbarians and gnomes get options with advantage, and a gnome can try History (DC 5). Lunkbug tells you about Philomeen and marks her hideout, a hidden room up and away from the dig. Ask him what's in it for you before he spills, and he hands over a Scroll of Revivify. Brithvar, the mercenary, can point you to her as well. If you already carry explosives, the journal notes that.
Philomeen is threatening to blow us all up. How do I calm her down?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
She's terrified, not cruel. Don't make any sudden moves near that barrel.
Hint 2
Talk, don't fight. Mentioning that you've spoken to her friends helps, and so does reading her mind.
Missable A failed check or any aggression and she detonates: the vial, the barrel and Philomeen are all lost. Save before you talk.
Hint 3
Once she calms down, she offers you something small but very powerful in return for letting her go.
Solution
Calm her with Persuasion DC 10 (the 'Laridda sent me' line, available if you promised Lunkbug your help), Intimidation DC 15, Persuasion DC 15, or Detect Thoughts, which opens an appeal to her gods. A good passive Perception (DC 15) notices the barrel isn't ordinary smokepowder: it's runepowder. Once she's calm she offers a single runepowder vial if you let her go, and that vial alone is enough to clear the cave-in. If you move the barrel more than 15 m away before talking, she can't detonate it and gives up instead.
Outcomes
Take the vial and let her go
She leaves, taking the barrel with her if it's close by, and asks you to tell Laridda she's dead.
Fail a check, attack, or go for the barrel
She blows herself up, along with the barrel and the vial. If the barrel is out of her reach, she fights you instead.
Missable She also leaves for good once the fight with Nere is over, so get the vial before you blow the rubble if you want it.
Is there more powder anywhere?
Hint 1
Search Philomeen's hideout once she's gone, or even while she's still there. Read what she left lying around.
Hint 2
Her note marks a reserve stash on your map, down near the lift at the fort.
Hint 3
The stash is behind a wall that isn't really a wall. Look for a way to open it, or a way to squeeze through.
Solution
Read the letter next to Philomeen's backpack in her hideout to mark the reserve stash. The two smokepowder satchels there sit behind a secret wall. A hidden button nearby (Perception DC 5) opens it, or a Tiny character can slip through the small holes. Two satchels together are exactly enough for the cave-in.
Act One
Blind the Absolute
Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Brithvar wants the floating eye gone. How do I do it without getting caught? unverified
Hint 1
The eye watches the diggers and follows anyone it catches sneaking or stealing. Pick your moment.
Hint 2
Once you've taken Brithvar's job, the mercenaries look the other way. The loyal duergar are another matter.
Hint 3
It won't heal itself, so you can whittle it down outside combat. Or study it closely first.
Solution
Attacking the eye isn't a crime in itself, and it can't heal, so a few quiet hits out of sight of Sergeant Thrinn and her loyal guards will do it. Staring at it gives a passive Insight check (DC 10); pass it and you can reach into the eye and briefly sense who is watching through it, or attack it from there. If Brithvar dies first, the journal notes it, but killing the eye still matters for how the fight with Nere goes.
Outcomes
Eye destroyed before the rubble comes down
With a deal in place, the mercenaries' reinforcements turn up in the fight and Brithvar pays you afterwards.
Eye still alive
With a deal in place, Brithvar calls it off after the fight and demands money from you instead.
That loyal duergar will treat an attack on the eye in front of them as trouble is inferred; the script only confirms it isn't flagged as a crime.
Act One
Clearing the cave-in
Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
I have the explosives. How do I set them off? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Put them right up against the rubble. The people around you will notice.
Hint 2
Then set them alight from a safe distance.
Hint 3
A fire arrow or a fire cantrip does it. Get everyone you care about well back first.
Missable The runepowder barrel's blast is huge. Using it here may kill the gnome diggers and the people trapped inside. One vial or two satchels is all you need.
Solution
Drop the explosives at the foot of the rubble. Laridda and a guard comment, and Sergeant Thrinn tells you to light it. Ignite them from range with fire, or any hit. Every duergar on the dig comes running when the rubble falls, so be ready for what follows. If you use Philomeen's whole runepowder barrel, expect an enormous blast (about 18 m) that will catch the gnomes and anyone else nearby.
Not confirmed in play: whether the barrel's blast actually reaches Nere and the trapped gnomes, and what the journal does if it does.
Act One
When the dust settles
Grymforge
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
Nere is free and everyone has gathered. What should I do?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about what you've already promised, and to whom, before you open your mouth.
Hint 2
Nere has his own ideas about the gnomes who were trapped with him. You'll have a moment to object, or not.
Hint 3
Who is still alive matters: Sergeant Thrinn, Brithvar, and the scrying eye all change how this plays out.
Outcomes
Stop Nere killing the gnomes
One gnome, Meerna, dies the moment Nere walks out, whatever you do. If you object to more, Nere treats it as a test and orders Thrinn to attack you. With Brithvar alive and no deal, everyone turns on you. With Brithvar dead, Nere invites you to cut down the disloyal duergar: side with him and the loyal duergar against the rebels, or with the rebels against him. With a deal, Brithvar demands his pay: back Nere, back Brithvar, or stand aside (which counts as backing Brithvar).
Urge Nere on, or say nothing
Nere executes every gnome worker. A Paladin who hasn't already broken their oath breaks it here. If Thrinn is alive, Nere blames her and kills her, then tells you to kill the duergar: agree and you fight beside him against all of them; refuse and everyone fights you. With a deal, Brithvar demands his pay instead, and you pick a side.
All the duergar are already dead
Explain it away with Deception (DC 10). If the gnomes are still alive, Nere tells you to kill them; refuse and he attacks. Or plant a thought with a Wisdom check (DC 15) and Nere frees the gnomes himself, with you on his side. Failing a check makes him hostile.
Attack anyone, or walk off without choosing
All the duergar and Nere turn on you. Hurting a gnome turns the gnomes hostile too.
Missable Staying silent, or urging Nere on, gets the gnome workers killed for good. Objecting, or the Wisdom check if the duergar are already dead, is the way to keep them alive.
Nere is a caster first. Watch for his mind tricks on your party.
Hint 2
He can make one of your characters fight for him. Characters with good Wisdom saves are your best answer.
Hint 3
When he's taken a fair bit of damage, he changes his approach and wades into melee.
Hint 4
There's a brazier hanging above the fight. It may be worth knocking down.
Solution
Nere has 78 hit points (more on higher difficulties), Extra Attack, resistance to psychic damage and sensitivity to sunlight. Shield of Screams gives him +3 AC for two turns. Coercion (Wisdom save, DC 14) turns one of your characters against you for up to four turns. Below 70% hit points he switches to a melee style and a new set of spells. In Honour Mode he also has a legendary action that casts a protective visage on himself when attacked, once per round. Break the hinge on the hanging brazier to drop burning coals on whoever's under it.
The brazier's effect is inferred from how other tippable braziers work; only its hinge is confirmed.
Nere wants a word after the fight. What's at stake? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
If any gnomes are still alive and unfreed, Nere hasn't forgotten them.
Hint 2
He wants you to carry a message, and he has a gift to help you on your way.
Hint 3
If you're carrying something that shields you from the Absolute's voice, you may be able to show him the truth about it.
Missable Nere's Dagger +1 is only given on the reveal-the-truth path, and only if you have the artefact that blocks the Absolute with you.
Solution
If the gnomes are alive and still slaves, Nere moves to kill them: stay quiet and he does, pass a Wisdom check (DC 15) to make him free them, or attack him. He asks you to report his failure to the General at Moonrise Towers, and gives you the Spider's Lyre, which summons a guide through the cursed lands. Mention that Minthara offered you passage and he sends you to her. Agree to help and he leaves for the temple. Refuse and he attacks, unless the party carries the artefact that blocks the Absolute. In that case you can keep up the act, or tell him the Absolute is a front for mind flayers: Deception or Persuasion (DC 10) to be believed, then a second DC 10 check (Persuasion or History), or Detect Thoughts and a Lolth-faithful drow's option, to make him walk away. Mocking him or failing a check means a fight.
Outcomes
Help him and let him go
He leaves to follow Balthazar to the temple. In Act 2 you'll meet him again, as one of Balthazar's undead.
Reveal the truth and win him over
He turns his back on the Absolute and gives you his Dagger +1 if he still has it. He doesn't turn up again among the undead.
Refuse him, or provoke him
He attacks. If he dies, Sergeant Thrinn or the mercenaries handle the aftermath instead.
Missable If Nere dies before this talk, you may still be able to loot the Spider's Lyre from his body.