Act 3 · 6 journal steps · starts around the Rivington
Something is groaning in the cellar of an old windmill at Wyrm's Crossing. Whatever it is, it's very hungry, and it thinks you might understand.
Act Three
Noises under the floor
The windmill, Wyrm's Crossing
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start? unverified
Hint 1
Look for the old windmill on the high ground at Wyrm's Crossing, and go inside.
Hint 2
Once you're in, the ground shakes. Stand near the trapdoor in the floor and listen.
Hint 3
Go down through the trapdoor. The quest itself only opens when you talk to what's lying in the cellar, and only a character carrying a tadpole gets the full conversation.
The front door has a lock (DC 15, and the key is on the cellar's occupant), but the files don't say whether it starts locked, or whether there's another way in.
Is there anything else worth finding in the windmill?
Hint 1
Search the hay on the ground floor carefully. It takes a very sharp eye.
Hint 2
An Investigation check (DC 25) on the haystack turns up one Arrow of Acid. There's also a notice lying in the cellar.
Act Three
The sleeper in the cellar
The windmill cellar
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
There's something asleep in the cellar. What can I do?
Hint 1
It's in a bad way. Take a good look at its condition before you decide anything.
Hint 2
It's a newborn mind flayer, and it's starving. Its Brain-Starved status takes 10 off every one of its ability scores, so right now it's about as weak as a mind flayer gets.
Hint 3
You can wake it and talk, attack it while it sleeps, or try to sneak back out. If you carry a tadpole, the voice in your head will push you to kill it.
Outcomes
Wake it
It wakes and talks. A Barbarian can roar it awake instead, which some companions like.
Attack it in its sleep
It wakes hostile and surprised for 2 rounds. Given how weak it is, that's usually the end of it.
Sneak away
Stealth DC 10. Pass and you leave quietly; fail and it wakes up hostile.
It won't talk to my character. Why?
Hint 1
It only deals with someone it sees as kin.
Hint 2
Talk to it with a character who carries a tadpole. Anyone else is sent off to fetch the one they follow, though they can still pick a fight.
The thing in the cellar is awake and hungry. What are my options?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
It wants a fresh brain. You can supply one, refuse, or suggest it fends for itself.
Hint 2
Ask what's in it for you before you agree. It promises to help your powers grow.
Hint 3
Offer to fetch it a freshly killed corpse and the quest proper begins. A Persuasion check can send it hunting on its own instead, but you only get one try.
Missable The Persuasion check to send it hunting is a single attempt. If it fails, that option is gone.
Outcomes
Offer to bring it a corpse
It waits in the cellar for you to come back with a body. Its rewards are a touch on your mind and a ring, but feeding it has a grim consequence later in the Lower City.
Tell it to hunt for itself (Persuasion DC 15)
It climbs out and goes after the locals near the windmill. Fail and it refuses to risk itself; the option is gone.
Refuse, or attack
It turns hostile and you fight it in the cellar, still weakened.
Say you'll see what you can do, or just leave
Nothing happens. It stays put until you deal with it, or until the quest closes at the endgame.
Act Three
A meal for a guest
Wyrm's Crossing and the windmill cellar
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
It wants a body. Where do I get one, and what counts? unverified
Hint 1
It has to be a corpse you can carry in your pack. Look around the windmill: you're not the only people up here.
Hint 2
Any dead humanoid that isn't one of your party counts. The journal moves on as soon as you're holding one.
Hint 3
There's a courting couple picnicking just east of the windmill, and a few more locals nearby. Killing any of them is murder, with all the usual trouble from witnesses.
The script counts any defeated, non-party humanoid in your inventory, whoever killed it. Not yet checked in play: which corpses the game lets you pick up, and whether the offer line accepts an old body you didn't kill (it sits behind a script check we couldn't identify).
I've got a body. What happens when I hand it over? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go back down to the cellar and talk to the mind flayer with the corpse in your pack.
Hint 2
It takes one corpse, rewards you, and tells you to leave so it can eat.
Missable A Paladin who hands over the body breaks their oath. Let someone else do the talking.
Outcomes
Feed it
It touches your mind and gives you a tadpole point, which unlocks another illithid power. It also hands over the Ring of Truthfulness (advantage on Insight), if it still has it. Nobles and Haunted Ones earn background inspiration. After the next long rest it's gone from the cellar. The first time you enter the Lower City after this, it has moved into a family home there and killed the whole family.
Missable Feeding it costs the Armbrust family in the Lower City their lives the moment you first enter the Lower City afterwards. Kill the mind flayer instead, or leave it unfed, to spare them.
From the dialogue and script: the tadpole point goes to a speaker with the game's illithid tag; we haven't confirmed whether every tadpole carrier has it. Whether the oath breaks for every Paladin oath isn't confirmed either.
I talked it into hunting for itself. What now? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Head back up and outside. It's gone looking for a meal among the locals.
Hint 2
It picks off the civilians around the windmill one by one, and the crime is on its head, not yours. If a fight breaks out while you're nearby, it will ask you to help.
Hint 3
Once nobody's left to hunt, it waits at the front of the windmill, and the next mind it fancies is yours.
Outcomes
Help it in a fight
It becomes your ally, and everyone else in that fight turns on you.
Refuse to help
It turns hostile.
Let it finish
If a local is still alive, it eats and runs off for good. If it has run out of locals, it attacks you in front of the windmill.
Missable If it gets away, the Ring of Truthfulness probably goes with it. Pickpocket the ring before you send it off.
That the flayer leaves with its inventory is inferred; it simply disappears at an exit point in the script.
How do I beat it, and is it worth killing?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Fight it now, while it's starving. It won't get easier.
Hint 2
With every ability score cut by 10, it's very fragile in the cellar, more so if you attack it in its sleep and catch it surprised.
Hint 3
It drops its brain when it dies. A character carrying a tadpole can eat it.
Missable The brain's tadpole point is only there if you kill the mind flayer without feeding it first.
Solution
Its brain gives a tadpole point to a character with the illithid tag, but only if you never fed it; a fed flayer's brain is past its best and gives nothing. It also carries the Ring of Truthfulness, the windmill's front door key and a letter, all of which you can loot (or pickpocket while it's alive). Haunted Ones earn background inspiration for killing it.
What if I just leave it alone?
Hint 1
Nothing forces your hand. It stays in the cellar.
Hint 2
The quest closes on its own when the endgame begins, recorded as you leaving without helping.
Act Three
Loose ends
A family home, Lower City
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Is there more to this quest after the windmill? unverified
Hint 1
Only if you fed the mind flayer. In that case, keep your eyes open when you first reach the Lower City.
Hint 2
The mind flayer from the windmill has moved into the Armbrust family's house in the Lower City and killed everyone in it. It's back to full strength now.
Hint 3
You can attack it or leave it be. The family's belongings no longer have an owner, so taking them isn't theft.
Outcomes
Attack it
A full-strength mind flayer, so be ready. If you met the family earlier, you can throw that in its face first.
Leave
It stays where it is. A companion will blame you for what happened.
We haven't pinned down the house's street in the Lower City. Its full strength is inferred from the script restoring it. The only scripted way to save the family once it's fed is grim: if one of them is already dead before it arrives, the rest flee and it never comes.