Acts 1–3 · 12 journal steps · starts around the Underdark
A deep gnome lies in the Myconid Colony, too weak to stand, and she won't last for ever. Helping her opens doors you won't find any other way.
Act One
A gnome in pain
Myconid Colony
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
There's an injured gnome in the Myconid Colony. What's wrong with her?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Talk to her. Thulla can't move, but she can still answer questions.
Hint 2
A passive Nature check (DC 7) tells you what's wrong at a glance. If you miss it, ask her directly.
Hint 3
She's been poisoned by a duergar, with something brewed from an Underdark weed. Whoever made it probably carries the antidote.
Missable Once you know she's poisoned, every long rest makes her worse. See the question about how long you have.
Solution
Talking to her and learning she is poisoned starts the clock on her condition, so have a plan before you rest. A Medicine check (DC 15, with advantage if you passed the Nature check; automatic for a duergar) tells you the poison yields to an antidote or to natural remedies.
Act One
Finding a cure
The Underdark and beyond
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
What can I give Thulla to cure her? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You may already have something that works. Check your bags for anything that fights poison.
Hint 2
Plain potions do the job. So does a rare mushroom that grows in the colony's neighbourhood, and so does the antidote of the duergar who poisoned her.
Hint 3
Any of these works: an Antidote, an Elixir of Poison Resistance, a Remedial Potion, the Elixir of Silvanus, the Duergar Antidote, or the noblestalk mushroom. Talk to her and offer it.
Missable There's only one noblestalk in Act 1, and fire destroys it. If you'd rather save it, use a potion. And if you want the Elixir of Silvanus from Nettie herself, note that she drinks the dose she hands you in her own scene: take the one on her table, or brew another, to keep one.
Solution
Nearest options: an Elixir of Poison Resistance lies in Derryth and Baelen's corner of the colony, about 40 m from Thulla. A drow supply chest in the Underdark always holds an Antidote, and more Antidotes are scattered round the surface (the Druid Grove, the goblin camp, the Thayan cellar, near Auntie Ethel's tea house). The Elixir of Silvanus is in Halsin's study at the grove. The noblestalk grows in the bibberbang field beside Baelen. The Duergar Antidote is carried by Gekh, the duergar hunting her.
Outcomes
Give her the noblestalk
It cures her, and it's gone: there's only one in Act 1, and Derryth, Baelen and Shadowheart all have a use for it. An Outlander gets an inspiration for it.
Give her any potion
It cures her and leaves the noblestalk free for someone else.
That Gekh carries the Duergar Antidote comes from the quest's setup script, which moves it into his inventory; looting or pickpocketing it hasn't been confirmed in play.
I have no potions. Can I cure Thulla with magic? unverified
Hint 1
Think about spells and class features that end poison.
Hint 2
Lesser Restoration, Protection from Poison and a paladin's Lay on Hands (Cure) all work, and she starts talking the moment the poison lifts.
Hint 3
If no one can cast those, look at what Derryth sells, a few steps from Thulla.
Solution
Derryth always stocks the Herbalist's Gloves. Whoever wears them removes poison from anyone they heal, so healing Thulla with any spell should cure her. Don't attack her, even with an Arrow of Dispelling: at a quarter health, helpless, any hit is a critical and will very likely kill her.
The gloves' effect comes from the item's passive; using them on Thulla hasn't been confirmed in play. Curing her by spell before you've ever spoken to her should also work, but whether the journal records it properly is unconfirmed.
Act One
Running out of time
The Underdark
This part contains spoilers for Act One.
How long can Thulla hold on? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
The clock only starts once you've talked to her and know what's wrong. After that, it's rests that count, not hours.
Hint 2
Each long rest moves her one stage worse. So does each raft arrival at the Grymforge dock.
Hint 3
You can afford two long rests or Grymforge raft trips after you diagnose her. Cure her before the third. If she seems confused and mistakes you for someone else, that's the last stage: the cures still work.
Missable The third long rest or Grymforge raft arrival after diagnosis kills her. If she's ever knocked out while still poisoned, the next long rest kills her too.
Missable Leaving Act 1 closes the quest. Cure her first if you want her later help.
From the script. Not confirmed in play: whether only the trip to Grymforge counts and the return trip doesn't, and whether short rests or skipping to dawn count.
I'm about to free the prisoners at Grymforge. Anything I should do first?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Think about who else is waiting on you back at the Myconid Colony.
Hint 2
If Thulla is still poisoned when the freed gnomes leave Grymforge, her clock jumps to the last stage at once.
Missable Freeing her clan while she's poisoned and nobody's in the colony kills her for good. Cure her first.
Solution
Cure Thulla before you free the Ironhand gnomes. If she's still poisoned when they leave Grymforge, she dies at once unless someone in your party is in the colony, and dies as soon as the last of you leaves it. This happens even if you never spoke to her.
Her clan, the Ironhands, are held by duergar across the lake. Agree to help and she gives you her Boots of Speed and marks her escape route on your map.
Outcomes
Agree to help her clan
You get the Boots of Speed and the start of the rescue quest. Later she asks what became of her kin, and if they make it to the colony she promises they'll repay you in Baldur's Gate.
Doubt her story
A passive Insight check (DC 15) then Persuasion (DC 15) gets her to admit she lied about the expedition, and hint at a feud back in the city.
Answer cruelly (a Lolth-sworn drow or a duergar has the option)
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Not everyone who finds her wants to help. Look at what she's wearing.
Hint 2
You can end things for her, or rob her while she's helpless, and both have consequences in the colony.
Outcomes
Talk her into a quick death (Persuasion DC 15)
She agrees, and she dies. It counts as murder.
Finish her off (after an Investigation check, DC 10, or spotting the boots)
She dies. It counts as murder, and it also counts for Gekh, the duergar who wants her boots.
Murder her while she's still poisoned
The myconids confront you. Insight, Deception or Persuasion (DC 15) wins forgiveness and they raise her husk as a servant. Fail, or attack, and they turn hostile for a while.
Take her boots, then cure her
She notices, but still asks for your help. A Criminal gets an inspiration for stealing them.
Missable Killing her loses the cure reward, her gift of the boots, the chance for her to start the rescue quest, and her later appearances, for good.
I went back for Thulla and something has changed. What happened?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look closely at her, and at the myconids around her.
Hint 2
The poison got her first. The colony's sovereign has raised her body as a spore servant.
Missable Her death loses the cure reward, the Boots of Speed as a gift, her request to rescue her clan, and her later appearances.
Solution
There's no way back from this. Her husk has a short scene if you talk to it. If both myconid sovereigns are dead, nobody raises her, and you just find her body.
Act Three
An old acquaintance
Baldur's Gate
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
Does Thulla turn up again? unverified
Hint 1
If you cured her, look for her among her own people.
Hint 2
She's with Wulbren's Ironhand gnomes in the city, trades with you, and points you towards Wulbren's plans.
From the Act 3 setup script, which needs only that she was cured and not killed. Whether she appears if her clan was never freed hasn't been confirmed.