Act 3 · 22 journal steps · starts around the Lower City
The priests of Umberlee are singing over one of their own, struck down by something in the harbour. Their high priestess wants whoever is responsible found, and she isn't asking for a trial.
Act Three
A funeral by the sea
Water Queen's House
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
How does this quest start?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Visit Umberlee's temple by Grey Harbour, the Water Queen's House. Something unusual is going on at the altar.
Hint 2
The high priestess, Allandra Grey, is leading a funeral for a waveservant named Holli. Talk to her. She'll want a tribute before anything else.
Hint 3
Gold, a prayer or a show of devotion all count as tribute, and admitting you brought nothing also moves things along. Then ask her how the waveservant died, and she'll ask you to deal with the one responsible.
Missable Allandra only offers the job before you've visited the Iron Throne. Meet her for the first time after that and you get the funeral and tribute, but no quest.
Missable A Paladin of Vengeance who turns Allandra down breaks their oath.
Solution
Talk to Allandra Grey at the altar. After her eulogy, offer a tribute (500 gold, a prayer, your weapon, or a class-specific option for Clerics, Monks and Barbarians), then ask about the dead waveservant and accept. If you can cast Speak with Dead, Holli's body has a few clues of her own: she was swimming in the harbour when something fast and metal hit her.
The priestess wants the culprit found. Where do I start looking?
Hint 1
Somebody found the body. Ask Allandra Grey who.
Hint 2
Fishermen brought Holli in. A brother and sister work the docks nearby.
Hint 3
The brother is busy cleaning something off his boat. Ask where the mess came from, then whether he's seen anything else out of the ordinary.
Solution
Ask Allandra how Holli was found (or, later, where to look again): fishermen found her. On the docks, talk to the fisherman scrubbing his boat. Ask about the dead waveservant or the muck on his hull, then ask if he's noticed anything unusual. He saw a wake heading for the warehouse across the channel. His sister isn't much help.
Act Three
The warehouse across the channel
Dock Warehouse
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I'm in the warehouse and there's nothing here. Where now? unverified
Hint 1
Look down. The dark stains on the floor are a clue, and they lead somewhere.
Hint 2
That isn't blood. It's machine oil, and there's more to this building than the ground floor.
Hint 3
A hatch is hidden in the floor. You need to be close and spot it.
Solution
Five worgs are kept on the ground floor, so be ready for them. A Perception check (DC 10) near the stains tells you they're oil, not blood. The hidden floor hatch needs a Perception check (DC 15) from within about 6 m. It can't be broken, so you have to find it. Go down it to reach a dock under the building.
The worgs' placement is confirmed in the level data, but whether they attack on sight, or answer to anyone, isn't checked in play.
There's someone in the basement. How do I get the truth out of him?
Hint 1
You won't need to start the conversation. Redhammer, the dwarf down there, notices you soon enough.
Hint 2
Redhammer isn't going to confess to a stranger. Give him a reason to think you belong there, or that you're not to be messed with.
Hint 3
Claim his boss sent you, pose as an official, or lean on him. If it works, he grumbles about Umberlee's swimmers and lets slip that he may have clipped one.
Solution
Deception, claiming the boss sent you: DC 15 (DC 10 for a Rogue). If it fails and he asks who the boss is, name Lord Gortash to recover; naming anyone else blows your cover. A Bard can pose as a waterway inspector: DC 15, or DC 18 for the long-winded version. Intimidation: DC 15, or DC 10 for a Barbarian. If Wyll is still looking for his father, he'll chip in too.
Act Three
The deviser and his machine
Dock Warehouse basement
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
What can I do about Redhammer?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Look at what's moored beside Redhammer, and think about where it might take you.
Hint 2
Redhammer's machine is the way to Gortash's prison, the Iron Throne. You can kill him for Allandra, strike a deal for a ride, or try to use the machine without him.
Hint 3
You can kill him now and go back to Allandra Grey, or make the deal and settle his fate later. The priestesses haven't forgotten about him either way.
Solution
To get a ride, tell him you need to reach the Iron Throne. Persuasion DC 10, Intimidation DC 15, or Deception DC 25. A 1,000 gold bribe or threatening to send the waveservants after him works without a roll, and so does saying you're going to free the prisoners, if you already know about them. Offering to protect him from the waveservants, or to forget you saw him, also gets a yes. If you're coming back after a failed attempt, pay 1,000 gold or pass Intimidation DC 20. To go without him, he has to be unable to see you: board while invisible.
Outcomes
Kill him
Accusing him of murder, or of complicity with the Gondians' captors, starts the fight; or just attack. Report his death to Allandra Grey for her reward.
Make a deal
The game autosaves and he takes you to the Iron Throne. His fate is settled when you come back, and you can still change your mind then.
Slip aboard without him
You reach the Iron Throne alone. If the waveservants are after him, they find him while you're away. If you turn back at the Iron Throne's entrance without going in, he turns on you.
Missable Slip off without him while the waveservants are hunting him and he's dead when you return. Neither Allandra's robe nor his own reward is on offer after that.
I came back and the basement is empty. Where did he go?
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Something has happened to the place he was meant to ferry people to.
Hint 2
With his job gone, Redhammer has packed up and left. He didn't go without a word, though.
Hint 3
Search where his machine used to be moored. Read what he left there.
Solution
If the Iron Throne is destroyed before you ever visit it (by Gortash's death, or by the Steel Watch Foundry going down), the machine disappears and Redhammer leaves once he's free to. A letter of resignation turns up by the empty berth, highlighted as you approach. Read it, then take the news to Allandra Grey for her reward.
Missable This only happens if the Iron Throne is destroyed while Redhammer is alive and you haven't been there. Once he's gone, he's gone: there's no reward from him and no Iron Throne ride.
Act Three
Settling up with the priestess
Water Queen's House
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've dealt with him. How do I claim the reward? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
Go back to the Water Queen's House.
Hint 2
Allandra Grey asks whether it's done. Tell her he's dead, or show her his letter if he's left town.
Solution
Either answer earns Wavemother's Robe: a very rare robe with +1 AC, fire and cold resistance, healing at the start of your turn while you stand in water, and a Create or Destroy Water spell once per short rest. Reporting his death also brings the funeral to an end.
Missable The robe is lost if you side with Redhammer against the waveservants, or if he dies at their hands while you're away. It also needs Allandra alive to hand it over.
Outcomes
Report him dead before going to the Iron Throne
You get the robe and the matter is closed. Nobody waits for you in the basement later.
Kill Allandra
The quest ends with her death, and there's no robe.
That the robe is lost when Allandra dies is inferred: it's handed out from her conversation, and nothing else gives it.
Act Three
Back at the warehouse
Dock Warehouse basement
This part contains spoilers for Act Three.
I've come back to the warehouse basement. What happens now? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
If you never told Allandra Grey the job was done, she hasn't stopped looking.
Hint 2
Allandra and six waveservants are waiting for you. If Redhammer came with you, she wants him handed over.
Hint 3
Hand Redhammer over, or stand with him and fight. There's no talking her out of it.
Outcomes
Hand Redhammer over
He goes quietly with the waveservants, and you get Wavemother's Robe. You'll find out later what they did with him: his body turns up in the temple's vault.
Defend Redhammer
Allandra and all six waveservants attack, and Redhammer fights beside you. Win with him alive and he pays you in gold. The surviving waveservants, if any, go back to the temple hostile, and its offering blessings stop.
You came back without him
The waveservants found him while you were away and killed him. They talk briefly, then leave. No reward.
You killed him but never reported it
Allandra credits you, hands over the robe and leaves.
Nobody is waiting
If Allandra is dead, never gave you the job, or already heard he was dead, there's no confrontation. If he took you, he thanks you for the ride. If you went without him, he's gone, and leaves a note behind.
Missable Defending Redhammer costs you Wavemother's Robe for good. Handing him over costs you his gold. A Paladin of the Crown who accepted Allandra's job breaks their oath by turning on her.
See also: Save the Gondians, the Iron Throne rescue this happens after
Who approves of handing him over or defending him isn't confirmed. Attacking the waveservants yourself after Redhammer is already dead seems to count as turning on them, but that route isn't confirmed in play.
How do I win the fight in the basement? unverified
Something here can be lost for good. The hints say what, when you get to it.
Hint 1
You're fighting seven of Umberlee's faithful, and they're at home in water.
Hint 2
Allandra Grey is the toughest, at 92 HP, with Magic Resistance. Her waveservants all resist lightning, and water doesn't slow any of them down.
Hint 3
Keep Redhammer alive. His reward only comes if he's still standing when the last waveservant falls.
Missable If Redhammer dies, or you escape before all seven waveservants are down, his reward is lost for good.
Solution
Enemies: Allandra Grey (92 HP), three Dark Breakers (68 HP each, hit hard), two Savage Seawinds (54 HP, Dex fighters that riposte), and one Untaken (46 HP). Redhammer has 80 HP and fights in melee. Defeat all seven with him alive, then talk to him for a gold reward. The game autosaves when the last waveservant goes down. The freed prisoners from the Iron Throne will be around, so mind your area effects. If Redhammer dies, or you flee and leave waveservants alive, they retreat and he's killed later, with no reward from him.
The exact gold depends on level and isn't confirmed. The advice about lightning, save-based spells and area effects near the prisoners is inferred from the enemies' resistances and the fight's setup.